Connect with us

Chat log

Chat log from R1 of 2025: Melbourne vs Western Sydney

Chat log for Melbourne vs Western Sydney, R1 of 2025

piesfan420: hope leake has a good game
GinniFan: lets go Oliver
circle52: Only Oliver and Gawn this game hoping for a couple of decent scores to resue the carnage,
puckeey: Dees fans do not turn up do they
Harambe: Bedford tagging Petracca
Ooost: C on Gawn.
kisip: ash, Callaghan and oliver for me this game. leake and stone on the bench
nbartos: tagging Oliver Harem
Harambe: Bartos, he’s not following Petracca forward but tagging him when in the midfield
nbartos: big day for Bedford then
Harambe: Don’t be fooled by centre bounces, Bedford rarely went to Naicos at centre bounces last week either
clay007: I went Lindsay over Langford as a trade. Much cheaper
connrs: gawn is gonna have a big game
piesfan420: connrs hope not coz i went darcy cameron instead of him
pcaman2003: Have Oliver,Whitfield and Callaghan. Leake on bench. Off to a flyer 🙁
Curnowww: what scores we all looking at this week?
connrs: piesfan420 who’s your other ruck?
piesfan420: curnow, on the boarder of 2000
piesfan420: connrs, xerri
kisip: predicted score so far is 2217. Ash, Callaghan, Oliver and Flynn left for me
pcaman2003: I’m looking at 2550, but my glasses do need a clean.
Curnowww: I’m at 2050ish, would passed up 2200 if I had the right rookies on field
TheWarlord: Projected score 2317 for me but I have clarry in this so it might be 2300.
piesfan420: dees looking solid so far
puckeey: I would’ve been around 2200 if it wasn’t for SPP
nbartos: Oliver regret
piesfan420: get involved leake pls
connrs: oliver can’t even lay a tackle come on
clay007: Did Oliver just tackle his brother?
connrs: nevermind 🙂
circle52: Like the look of Lindsay from the dees 5 debutamts
bhg26: Callaghan getting clangers for teammates fumbling the ball
clay007: not sure about that bhg
piesfan420: dees are such a boring watch they dont look like going quick at all
puckeey: Clarry needs to want the ball more
nbartos: cmon Piastri too
piesfan420: leake 55% TOG, smth to be worried about?
soup: His Tog was awful last week too piesfan
Stu7: Oliver will come good
Stu7: Come on Gawn keep,going buddy
Curnowww: I Captained Xerri over Gawn, hating this
Ninty: I still don?t understand why Greene has a tractor icon
MrWalrus: Anyone else thinking they need to get Tracc into their team? He looks great.
Gelly: melbourne always bring out the big crowds
Stu7: You would take 122 for Xerri every day of the week though
piesfan420: great mark for cadman
Creed1: because hes coming to the cattery for 500k and a free farm ninty
Ninty: I hope not creed, last player id want at the cats #dog
nbartos: is this the same gws as last week that smashed pies?
Harambe: As opposed to the morally inscrutable Stengle and Baz Smith, Ninty
clay007: What is a pass mark for Oliver?
piesfan420: clay, i’d say between 90-100
pcaman2003: Get moving Whitfield you sloth.
Ninty: no @nbartos, Briggs out – Green is playing today
clay007: yes, was thinking that piesfan
kisip: good to see that callaghan is not being affected by tom greens return
nbartos: briggs went out early last week, with green in they should be even better
DukeNewc: Horrible week for popular rookies
Ninty: When was the last time either of those players punched a bouncer or fly kicked an opponent?
pcaman2003: kisip. I agree! I picked Callaghan nervously, but feel better now.
Ooost: What do we think is a pass for rd1? 2200 ish?
thommoae: Just the same, they’d be better with Green in … and some ruck ball.
kisip: pcaman was rotating between Cerra, Callaghan and W Ashcroft and went with callaghan instead.
piesfan420: can leake get some time on and do something
Harambe: Drunk drivinh not too serious Ninty, might just kill an innocent family
pcaman2003: kisip. Nice move! I just hope I can make some good decisions this year.
Hazza09: Is this week rookie correction only or do we trade Perryman
Apachecats: giving Ferryman one more go.
TheOnyas: Onya Gawny
Birdman18: What rookies are we correcting though? They’ve all been bad, except the higher priced ones we knew about
piesfan420: birdman, ive been happy with most rookies only a few that I havent liked
Hazza09: Birdman, SPP, Paton and maybe FOS?
Swoop35: Windsor!
Harambe: WTF Daniels why would you go out on the ground if you can’t run
Swoop35: Bedford cant go with petracca
JaiDay12: Why are people already jumping off FOS?
Harambe: Is there anyone dumber that the fans that scream BALL when a player kicks it 30m while being tackled?
Birdman18: Wouldn’t count SPP as a rookie lol. There’s definitely corrections I’m doing, but I’m happy enough with my rookies
MrWalrus: Any other Gawn captainers happy about getting their round salvaged by the big champ?
soup: My three forward rookies aren’t even going to hit 100 combined
puckeey: Who do you have soup?
Swoop35: Me walrus
clay007: Cmon Callaghan
MrWalrus: It’s nice isn’t it?
clay007: What was idun thinking?
Swoop35: Very walrus, chose him over tdk, hopefully pays off
MrWalrus: My fwd line is averaging about 110, only C Gawn will top 100 out of everyone else.
MercAm: so what is everybody looking like they are gonna score this week?
PigeonPies: max gawn gets points for breathing
Swoop35: Im not complaining pigeon
piesfan420: whats a good score this week do we reckon, 2150-2200?
MrWalrus: Wait a second, why is Daniel Rioli sitting in my backline? How do I not remember this!
Stu7: I reckon so piesfan420
clay007: Who is in the fw line walrus?
Stu7: I might break 2050
pcaman2003: My 3 in this are consistent at least, 66,63,62
Swoop35: Whos everyone got next game? Ive got anderson and flynn
piesfan420: swoop, ive only got elijah hewett and need him tto score 30 for me to win my matchup
Stu7: I?ve got no one for that game
MrWalrus: Rankine, Jackson, MacRae, Smith Daniel, kako. Hewitt and Davidson bench
Swoop35: Wish ya luck piesfan
DukeNewc: Cmon Trac don’t fade on me
piesfan420: thanks swoop
MrWalrus: Will be lucky to crack 2000, I’ve had worse starts and no injuries is a win
sMiles: 2065 with Clayton and Finn to complete – then Flynn as Flex to combat Davidson’s 39
pcaman2003: Only have Hewitt as a flex Swoop.
piesfan420: leake is going next week for a different rookie
MrWalrus: Are they going to give Langford a run? Really poor form debuting him like this.
puckeey: Weren’t there 0eople saying SPP was going to get mid time
clay007: How does the flex possy work?
Pettiger: In Gawn we trust!
piesfan420: dees activating their sub
DukeNewc: Clay, he takes out your lowest score and you use his score instead
MrWalrus: Replaces your lowest score if it’s better, I really dislike the concept.
clay007: interesting duke. I have camporeale there, may switch to levi ashcroft
DaicosQB: Darcy Cameron went wild against GWS too, id want to see gawn another game or two
MrWalrus: Flex is going to make it harder to make up ground later in the season and really punish you if you get unlucky
Noxious: Clarry not having a good game? Not watching atm
piesfan420: daciosQB, giants no ruckman so interested to see against a proper ruck
Gotigres: Time to give Gawn a rest now for the rest of the game.
piesfan420: noxious, geting a lot of the footy but not effective
Noxious: Thanks piesfan
pcaman2003: Good qtr Whitfield.But where are you Mr Leake?
Harambe: Yeah because Gawn has yet to prove himself against better ruckmen at this early stage of his career
clay007: So I had Davidson on field, he got 39, Camporeal in flex got 50ish, do I get campo’s score then
McSquire: Clarry doing ok Noxious. In everything and looks fit
MrWalrus: Yes clay unless someone sucks more
MrWalrus: Lol Harambe
circle52: @clay007 It is the best 22 in non bye rounds so if your Flex scores more than the lowest of other players his score coun
TimT14: So you should play a premium mid in the flex then?
MrWalrus: I really don’t like this flex nonsense.
MrWalrus: That’s what will happen Tim just letting the already good teams smash everyone harder
Ash777: I wonder why ppl are going Flynn for flex when he doesn’t ton alot
clay007: thanks circle
PigeonPies: safer than r2 ash, and a money maker
kisip: ash I guess its more about getting a third ruckman that will score. Probably at the end of the year i want 3 premo rucks
piesfan420: since their is a bye next week is it best 18 or 22
Ngawaiwha: TDK is my Flex. Got Gawn and Xerri in rucks
CamT: The Flex is great. No one has come up with the best strategy to use it.
Ash777: Also glad I removed Leake from my team. That tog was a huge concern for his scoring
Ash777: I went with Luke Jackson for flex.
Ngawaiwha: I just view Flex as allowing me to play extra cash cow in midfield knowing TDK will overwrite it.
Ninty: Thought bulk rucks would be the best flex. TDK, Xerri, then Meek lol. Should?ve had Gawn instead. SDK def looks good too
piesfan420: i went with odiscroll in flex to make me cash
Apachecats: Flynn tonned up in 5 out of 12 games in 2022 ,been out injured a lot since then.
CamT: I went with Sam Lalor in the Flex.
piesfan420: gawn injured…
Ninty: I had Flynn all the way up until Meek scored well last week. :/
Yelse: I got Xeri as flex with gawn and TDK . thought ill go with extra premium ruck than mid
circle52: I had Knevitt at Flex
pcaman2003: Callaghan has slowed right down.
JaiDay12: Same Yelse, those three are gems compared to some of the rather lacklustre mids
MrWalrus: Flex will smooth out rook scores early then be cover for an early injury/poor score later, it’s a terrible idea.
Yelse: Also don’t have the worry of the dreaded tag
Swoop35: Oliver gives away too many free kicks
Apachecats: Clarry 4 f/a not helping.Crude kicking in danger on Whit.
Stu7: Big Maxy going to go huge
pcaman2003: Swoop. Oliver will be lucky to get his 84 BE.
Pettiger: Ignored Oliver and spent the extra cash on the Max/Xerri combo.
Ash777: Expecting some players will have better showing in round 2
Swoop35: Fingers crossed he can pca
Pavs: I reckon a premium ruck flex is the way to go. Good job Yelse
hinsch: My flex will replace Neales score
MrWalrus: Only once your team is complete Pavs, to start it won’t make a difference.
pcaman2003: Game on!
MrWalrus: At this stage a premium in flex just means one more rookie on field.
Pavs: Yep strange concept not sure i like it either Walrus
Ash777: I think at this stage the only trade I’m doing is Short because it’s Short
MrWalrus: It will just make it harder to catch up if you hit terrible luck and favour those who complete their team first.
Pavs: Yeah that definetly isn’t me.
MrWalrus: Also it’s going to make not going popular picks pointless because nobody will lose out if a high ownership guy goes down
Ash777: phew ollie made his be
Stu7: Toby Greene could be responsible for this loss due to his poor kicking
Stu7: Close one
Stu7: Xavier has had an awesome game
pcaman2003: whitty, Clllaghan and Ollie, so I’m happy enough.
Gelly: all 7 melbourne fans attending will be filthy
Stu7: Nice pca
Raspel31: Eat your words Stu-welcome back Green.
puckeey: How many points did keefe get for that goal
Curnowww: I have Leake and SPP on field, what this round could’ve been.
pcaman2003: Stu. Touch and go for a while but better 2nd half. Dees stiff!
Apachecats: Callaghan got a lousy 4sc for winning the game.
kisip: 2191 pre updates with flynn as flex to go
pcaman2003: Curnowww . Have both on bench but their scores a real worry.. One more chance!
Swoop35: 2032 with anderson and flynn to go
Curnowww: pca I don’t have a player on my bench who scored less than 55. Managerial error perhaps

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More in Chat log