would love some feedback

[fasttrack13]

Think this is looking pretty good.. Rookies will obviously change come round one.  Would love any feedback.. thanks heaps!

BACKS:
H. Shaw, L. Hodge, M. Hibberd, H. Lumumba, B. Waters, B. Whitecross
(N. Brown, H. Goddard)

MIDS:
G. Ablett, S. Pendlebury, J. Selwood, R. Sloane, T. Cotchin, N. Van Berlo, N. Freeman, M. Dick
(A. Vandenberg, K. Lambert, N. Krakouer)

RUCKS:
M. Kreuzer, M. Luenberger
(M. Cox)

FOWARDS:
B. Delideo, B. Goddard, D. Swan, T. Bellchambers, D. Moore, M. Clark
(T. Membrey, J.Hogan)

$9,000 left

THOUGHTS????

i

i'd take lumumba > Rookie then membrey to C.Daniel (Purely downgrade for cash) Upgrade D.Moore to buddy/gray...

be a ridiculously good team if you did that

[crowls]

Think this is looking pretty good.. Rookies will obviously change come round one.  Would love any feedback.. thanks heaps!

BACKS:
H. Shaw, L. Hodge, M. Hibberd, H. Lumumba, B. Waters, B. Whitecross
(N. Brown, H. Goddard)

MIDS:
G. Ablett, S. Pendlebury, J. Selwood, R. Sloane, T. Cotchin, N. Van Berlo, N. Freeman, M. Dick
(A. Vandenberg, K. Lambert, N. Krakouer)

RUCKS:
M. Kreuzer, M. Luenberger
(M. Cox)

FOWARDS:
B. Delideo, B. Goddard, D. Swan, T. Bellchambers, D. Moore, M. Clark
(T. Membrey, J.Hogan)

$9,000 left

THOUGHTS????

i

i'd take lumumba > Rookie then membrey to C.Daniel (Purely downgrade for cash) Upgrade D.Moore to buddy/gray...

be a ridiculously good team if you did that

Good team and structure.   Backs a similar to mine but whitecross probably not playing first half of season.  look to downgrade for cash.

Use cash to upgrade rucks.  You need at least one keeper.  Minson and Maric are good POD.  Or Goldy for reliability.

[Regs81]

Have made a few changes, trying to go with a few different picks.  Let me know your thoughts!

Backs:
Hibberd, birchall,newnes, docherty , waters, brown
(Goddard, viojo-rainbow )

Mids:
Ablett,  Selwood, Kennedy, a swallow, montagna, van berlo , heeney, freeman
( Vandenberg, Steele, lambert)

Rucks:
Naitanui, Giles
(Cox)

Forwards:
Deledio, Goddard, Smith, swan, hannath, Clark
(Hogan, Daniel)

$86,500 left

[ben_020285]

Interesting side and for the most part I like it but I do think it needs some tweaking.

DEF: I like the Hibberd and Birchall picks and Waters is a must at his price. I think both Newnes and Docherty have the potential to break out this season but I think picking both is too risky. I would choose one and upgrade the other.

MID: Ablett, Selwood and JPK are all good picks. A Swallow is great value but he will need to average at least 110 to be a good pick. If you think he will average that then keep him. I don't like the Montagna pick. He won't average enough to be a keeper so I would upgrade him to a premium.

RUC: Nic Nat is a good pick but Giles isn't. I think Belly will get first shot at the number 1 ruck mantle and Giles may not even get a game round 1. I would swap him out for Leuey or Kreuzer.

FWD: Deledio, Goddard and Swan are all good picks and I like the unique pick in Smith. He could be anything this year and could easily average 95+. I don't think Hannath is best 22 just yet so I would downgrade him to a cheap rookie.

I would have a think about getting a RUC/FWD link in your forward line too especially if you end up with Nic Nat and Leuey/Kreuzer.

[Regs81]

More changes!

Backs:
Shaw, birchall, hurley,  docherty, waters, brown
(Goddard, Delaney)

Mids:
Ablett, Selwood,beams, Parker, crouch, van berlo, vanderberg, freeman
(Boekhorst , krakouerkrakouer, lambert ))

Rucks::
Hickey , luenberger
(Cox ))

Forwards::
Deledio,, bartel ,, n reiwoldt ,, Smith , Jack , harper,
(Clark ,,Daniel ))
$41,900

[Hawker_08]

More changes!

Backs:
Shaw, birchall, hurley,  docherty, waters, brown
(Goddard, Delaney)

Mids:
Ablett, Selwood,beams, Parker, crouch, van berlo, vanderberg, freeman
(Boekhorst , krakouerkrakouer, lambert ))

Rucks::
Hickey , luenberger
(Cox ))

Forwards::
Deledio,, bartel ,, n reiwoldt ,, Smith , Jack , harper,
(Clark ,,Daniel ))
$41,900

Like the team Regsy. Love the parker, n riewoldt, smith, docherty picks. Crouch is an awesome pick, like it a lot. i am unsure on all the midprices you have picked though. I dont think much of hurley and imo there are better options that Bartel. You will need a cover for hickey and luenberger so perhaps a few downgrades (hurley -> Newnes, Bartel -> Swan/Tmitch/Walters) and you can go TBC for Clark or Hickey -> Nic Nat. Really nice team, wouldnt mind your thaughts on mine

no swan?