The Playing Rookies Thread

[GoLions]

Should I field Heeney CEY Miller Vandenberg for m8

Same situation as me, thinking Miller or Heeney, perhaps Miller just cause I know he's not the sub, and against Dees

[Jackross10]

Currently I have.

VanBerlo, Cripps, Brayshaw, Cock.   Heeney, CEY, Vandenberg.

Should I take Newton over VanBerlo? Or is the 3 melbourne youngsters too many? Or Sheed or DeGeoy, or stick with VanBerlo?? ::)

[Ricochet]

Should I field Heeney CEY Miller Vandenberg for m8

Same situation as me, thinking Miller or Heeney, perhaps Miller just cause I know he's not the sub, and against Dees

Yep vanders or Miller i reckon

[Bones Bombers]

Ive decided to move Gray to the fwd and drop Lamb

I can afford Cockatoo but I'm about 15k short to get Newton. Newton will score better, but is JS solid Melbourne supporters?

Should I try and make a change somewhere to get Newton over Cockatoo?

I wouldn't change the team if you are happy with it just to get Newton in. He is still a risk and Cocky has been talked up by his team and could be better.

[RaisyDaisy]

Ive decided to move Gray to the fwd and drop Lamb

I can afford Cockatoo but I'm about 15k short to get Newton. Newton will score better, but is JS solid Melbourne supporters?

Should I try and make a change somewhere to get Newton over Cockatoo?

I wouldn't change the team if you are happy with it just to get Newton in. He is still a risk and Cocky has been talked up by his team and could be better.

Cheers Bones. I think I agree. I've got Vanders, and I think that might be enough. Newton or Bray could get dropped for Vince where as Cocky I feel has much better JS, but prob wont score as well as Newton

I've got Cripps on field and have now put Vanders on field. Just need to decide who gets the last spot on field out of Cocky, CEY, Heeney and Miller. Ive got the E on Miller currently. Hmmmmm

[Goosey]

Ive decided to move Gray to the fwd and drop Lamb

I can afford Cockatoo but I'm about 15k short to get Newton. Newton will score better, but is JS solid Melbourne supporters?

Should I try and make a change somewhere to get Newton over Cockatoo?

I wouldn't change the team if you are happy with it just to get Newton in. He is still a risk and Cocky has been talked up by his team and could be better.

Cheers Bones. I think I agree. I've got Vanders, and I think that might be enough. Newton or Bray could get dropped for Vince where as Cocky I feel has much better JS, but prob wont score as well as Newton

I've got Cripps on field and have now put Vanders on field. Just need to decide who gets the last spot on field out of Cocky, CEY, Heeney and Miller. Ive got the E on Miller currently. Hmmmmm

+1

Currently have CEY at M8.

[(._.)]

Dom Sheed anyone? Same price as Newton, better JS maybe...

[Jackross10]

Big question quickly please.

With Jaeger out for approx another month? Is it worth going VanBerlo to Miller and using the cash to trade Ibbotson to a premo?

[Bones Bombers]

Big question quickly please.

With Jaeger out for approx another month? Is it worth going VanBerlo to Miller and using the cash to trade Ibbotson to a premo?

Sure is!

[Torpedo10]

How many rookies are we starting in the midfield?

Not sure whether to downgrade JPK to Cockatoo, start Miller AND Vanders and use the cash to upgrade Bennell to Gray and Rampe to Heater.

[Ricochet]

Big question quickly please.

With Jaeger out for approx another month? Is it worth going VanBerlo to Miller and using the cash to trade Ibbotson to a premo?

Yep do it mate, think Ibbo will have a quieter game this weekend with Port having 3 talls in Lobbe/Ryder, Weshoff and Schulz. He'll have to play on one

[Torpedo10]

Big question quickly please.

With Jaeger out for approx another month? Is it worth going VanBerlo to Miller and using the cash to trade Ibbotson to a premo?

Yep do it mate, think Ibbo will have a quieter game this weekend with Port having 3 talls in Lobbe/Ryder, Weshoff and Schulz. He'll have to play on one

Agree

[Nige]

Im starting Lamb just over Hogan...hope it works

Same here mate. Fingers crossed!

[eg6914]

Dom Sheed anyone? Same price as Newton, better JS maybe...

I have sheed purely because i am only going with one melb mid rookie (i can't trust they will all play every week)

[petefisker]

Guys with the weather talk and possible CEY vest..
Should I bench Heeney and CEY and field Vanderberg and Miller?