first attempt

[Regs81]

Backs:
Hanley, Mckenzie, rampe, seedsman , lake, hunt (scharenberg , krakouer )

Mids:
Ablett, Selwood , sloane , b crouch, montagna , swan, rich, sheed (brayshaw , Salem)

Rucks:
Luenberger, kreuzer (king, Smith)

Forwards:
Dangerfield, Franklin, n reiwoldt, bellchambers , Clark, hogan (Karnezis , Saad)

Thoughts??

[AaronKirk]

1) Hanley won't have DPP, nor will Dangerfield

2) Krakouer and Saad would need to be upgraded to senior list from rookies- dunno if this will happen

3) Too many risky picks. Rampe, the seed and Lake all risky in defence, B.Crouch, Montags, Swan, Rich and Sheed in the mids and Nroo, Bellchambers and Clark forward

Max amount of risky picks max should be 3-4, need to cut those back. Have a good look at the rookies and see what you can do to fix your structure.

[Mr.Witt]

This team needs a lot of improvement.

In your defence you have way to many risks and I would say downgrade Lake to a rookie  and upgrade Rampe to a more proven player and then Seedsman could be your one major risk in the back line or do something along the lines of that.

Your midfield doesn't look to bad but I would downgrade Swan to a rookie (Heeney) and then that would leave you with heaps of money to upgrade Crouch and Montagna too premiums such as rocky and Fyfe

I like the idea of going cheap in your rucks.

I am not a fan of key forwards in supercoach as they are a bit inconsistent but that is just my opinion if you are confident in Riewoldt and Franklin that is up too you but if I was you I would look at other options. If you do take my advice you should have a bit of money left over and I think you should try and upgrade Saad to Walters as it would just improve your team that little bit more.


so what I would do in short is

Lake>Rookie (Lamb or Goddard)
Rampe>Premium (Simpson)
either one of them could be swapped with Seedsman

Swan>Rookie (Heeney)
Montagna and Crouch> Rocky and Fyfe

and try and upgrade Saad to Walters.

could you rate my team at http://forum.fanfooty.com.au/index.php/topic,99602.0.html

[SydneyRox]

i think the stating point for you to improve your team is the mids. You bat way too deep. Most teams will have rookies at M7 and M8, this savings will allow you to improve the back/fwds

Like the other boys have said you have too many risks. Need to try and limit them a little.
For what its worth, I like Rampe, he is a big chance to take on some of Eski's role next year IMO
Lake needs to be downgraded to a rookie
Roo and Bellchambers are not god risks in the fwd line, maybe try guys like Martin/Ziebell or Carlisle/Reid

Keep going, its a long off season and anyone who says the get it going first time is lying!!

[Regs81]

Ok made some changes. Rookies will change!
Backs:
Simpson, Smith, birchall , Henderson, c Pearce, j Kolodjashnij , lamb

Mids:
Ablett, pendlebury , Selwood, sloane, swan, rich, brayshaw , Salem, heeney , Karnezis

Rucks:
Luenberger, kreuzer, nankervis , Thurlow

Forwards:
Gray, Smith, ziebell , Walters, bellchambers, Reid, Moore, Clark

Thoughts??

[Samsturmfels]

Ok made some changes. Rookies will change!
Backs:
Simpson, Smith, birchall , Henderson, c Pearce, j Kolodjashnij , lamb

Mids:
Ablett, pendlebury , Selwood, sloane, swan, rich, brayshaw , Salem, heeney , Karnezis

Rucks:
Luenberger, kreuzer, nankervis , Thurlow

Forwards:
Gray, Smith, ziebell , Walters, bellchambers, Reid, Moore, Clark

Thoughts??

The team is a defender short  :o

[fasttrack13]

interesting defence. would recommend dropping c.pearce...  look for some more scoring potential or bargain value.
Youve gone too strong in the mids id recomend downgrading rich because there is heaps of value in the mid-price and bargain price range.
thurlow was delisted. maybe find a f/R to accomodate the belchambers swing. Moore too much for bench player. J.Hogan better selection. Id use left over cash to upgrade reid/walters/c.pearce.

[Regs81]

The last defender is Goddard