GL's SC Diary 2015

Started by GoLions, November 03, 2014, 07:32:40 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

eaglesman


GoLions

Quote from: Nige on January 24, 2015, 02:28:23 PM
Good stuff Davos, that looks like a really solid backline.

The rest of the team is fine too, just gotta have the right rookies now I reckon.
Yep, will just have to wait and see who gets named round 1 I guess, and then all this work will have been for nothing! :P

Quote from: eaglesman on January 24, 2015, 02:35:22 PM
Great side mate faultless
Cheers mate :)

GoLions



Squeezed in a 5th mid at the expense of Seedsman and NicNat. Kinda like this. If rookies don't get named, Sloaney becomes a rookie, and then I'll use the cash to make the necessary adjustments. Still have like 50k as well.

Mat0369

I think I would rather Hep over Jobe this year. Jobe has broken down the last couple of seasons with injuries while Heppell is about to hit his prime. At a similar price if I had to take an Essendon mid it would be hi.

In terms of you team, it looks really good as a starting point. I am not sold on Bellchambers and Hurn can be an injury risk (although he is an excellent scorer) but I really like it

GoLions

Quote from: Mat0369 on February 04, 2015, 03:31:50 PM
I think I would rather Hep over Jobe this year. Jobe has broken down the last couple of seasons with injuries while Heppell is about to hit his prime. At a similar price if I had to take an Essendon mid it would be hi.

In terms of you team, it looks really good as a starting point. I am not sold on Bellchambers and Hurn can be an injury risk (although he is an excellent scorer) but I really like it
I kinda prefer Jobe in SC, and HepD in AF atm. Think Jobe is underpriced, and if he stays fit, I'd back him for a 110-115 average easily. That's just personal preference though.
If a lot of the cheaper rookies end up playing round 1 (and look good to play more onwards), Belly would ideally become NicNat again. And I love Hurn, and think the captaincy might see his scores increase slightly (and already underpriced as it is). But yeah, injury risk.

cuz_crew

not bad... too many bombers. must be a bombers fan.

Bellchambers is a decent option... maybe you could have Ryder in your forward line for some dpp love.

I give this team 7 out of 10. good job

Big Mac

Quote from: cuz_crew on February 04, 2015, 03:45:29 PM
not bad... too many bombers. must be a bombers fan.

Bellchambers is a decent option... maybe you could have Ryder in your forward line for some dpp love.

I give this team 7 out of 10. good job

Hibberd, Watson, BC and Goddard are all solid options, and Laverde is just a placeholder - Definitely wouldn't say he has too many players from Essendon

Pkbaldy


Mat0369

Quote from: GoLions on February 04, 2015, 03:37:47 PM
I kinda prefer Jobe in SC, and HepD in AF atm. Think Jobe is underpriced, and if he stays fit, I'd back him for a 110-115 average easily. That's just personal preference though.
If a lot of the cheaper rookies end up playing round 1 (and look good to play more onwards), Belly would ideally become NicNat again. And I love Hurn, and think the captaincy might see his scores increase slightly (and already underpriced as it is). But yeah, injury risk.

Hepp can butcher the ball while Jobe is more a contested player so I understand that completely. I just think compared to his Brownlow year where he was tonning up almost weekly we haven't seen the same kind of production the last two years and with his age he will likely keep regressing. I think a 110 average is still obtainable but I don't see more then that which would make me hesitant.

I am also a huge fan of Hurn, if he stays healthy he will be a really good POD. He can put up the odd down score but which defender doesn't?

AaronKirk

Belly R2 with no cover?

Probably the only concern I would have with your side GL

GoLions

Quote from: Pkbaldy on February 04, 2015, 03:55:59 PM
Nice team GoBombers.
Cheers Marlon

Quote from: Mat0369 on February 04, 2015, 03:56:24 PM
Quote from: GoLions on February 04, 2015, 03:37:47 PM
I kinda prefer Jobe in SC, and HepD in AF atm. Think Jobe is underpriced, and if he stays fit, I'd back him for a 110-115 average easily. That's just personal preference though.
If a lot of the cheaper rookies end up playing round 1 (and look good to play more onwards), Belly would ideally become NicNat again. And I love Hurn, and think the captaincy might see his scores increase slightly (and already underpriced as it is). But yeah, injury risk.

Hepp can butcher the ball while Jobe is more a contested player so I understand that completely. I just think compared to his Brownlow year where he was tonning up almost weekly we haven't seen the same kind of production the last two years and with his age he will likely keep regressing. I think a 110 average is still obtainable but I don't see more then that which would make me hesitant.

I am also a huge fan of Hurn, if he stays healthy he will be a really good POD. He can put up the odd down score but which defender doesn't?
Yeah who knows, maybe I'd end up downgrading Watson instead of Sloaney haha

Quote from: AaronKirk on February 04, 2015, 03:57:03 PM
Belly R2 with no cover?

Probably the only concern I would have with your side GL
I feel Belly is a lot safer than Leuey/Kreuz. And I'll probably chuck Lobb at R3 eventually. If Belly gets injured during the year, either swap him for leuey/Kreuz, use Lobb if he's playing, or (in the scenario where he isn't injured instantly and has scored decently) upgrade him to a NicNat/Maric/etc. Depending on rookies though, could still start with 2 premium rucks and go with no cover as well. I don't even know why I do all this planning, because a lot of it comes down to what rookies are named round 1 haha.

shaker

Not sold on Belly at R2 and forwards are one quality player short for my liking GL

GoLions

Quote from: shaker on February 04, 2015, 04:20:56 PM
Not sold on Belly at R2 and forwards are one quality player short for my liking GL
Yeah I had Mitchell at F4 earlier, but prefer having the 5 premo mids. Don't really see a way to have both at this point without changing my structure completely.

shaker

Quote from: GoLions on February 04, 2015, 04:28:13 PM
Quote from: shaker on February 04, 2015, 04:20:56 PM
Not sold on Belly at R2 and forwards are one quality player short for my liking GL
Yeah I had Mitchell at F4 earlier, but prefer having the 5 premo mids. Don't really see a way to have both at this point without changing my structure completely.

Yeah it's hard to get all lines strong without some down grading of other lines , plenty of time to go and most have to change there team when round 1 teams are out haha

GoLions

Quote from: shaker on February 04, 2015, 04:41:45 PM
Quote from: GoLions on February 04, 2015, 04:28:13 PM
Quote from: shaker on February 04, 2015, 04:20:56 PM
Not sold on Belly at R2 and forwards are one quality player short for my liking GL
Yeah I had Mitchell at F4 earlier, but prefer having the 5 premo mids. Don't really see a way to have both at this point without changing my structure completely.

Yeah it's hard to get all lines strong without some down grading of other lines , plenty of time to go and most have to change there team when round 1 teams are out haha
Haha yeah exactly