Pk's 5 Minute Pick

[Pkbaldy]

Quick Redo. Dunno about Malceski, don't think I can trust Brodie Smith.

White Boy Jumping Fanplanner squad in the Super Coach competition coached by Pkbaldy. Salary cap left: $52,800.

Nick Malceski, Michael Hibberd, Grant Birchall, Jack Newnes, Jarryn Geary, Kyle Langford
Tom Lamb, Oscar McDonald

Gary Ablett jnr, Scott Pendlebury, Joel Selwood, Jobe Watson, Daniel Rich, Christian Petracca, Angus Brayshaw, Damien Cavka
Jarrod Garlett, Alex Neal-Bullen

Todd Goldstein, Matthew Leuenberger
Lewis Pierce, Max King

Lance Franklin, Dustin Martin, Devon Smith, Jack Ziebell, Paul Ahern, Daniel Markworth
Reece McKenzie, Jack Steele

[Vinny]

Very very good side man. One of the best I've seen.

[Pkbaldy]

After the releases of a few DPP changes i've decided to make a new quick team.

Brodie Smith, Michael Hibberd, Grant Birchall, Jack Newnes, Brendan Whitecross, Shane Biggs
Jake Kolodjashnij, Dillon Viojo-Rainbow

Gary Ablett jnr, Scott Pendlebury, Joel Selwood, Jobe Watson, Daniel Rich, Jonothon O'Rourke, Angus Brayshaw, Isaac Heeney
Nathan Freeman, Jack Steele

Todd Goldstein, Matthew Kreuzer
Mitch Harvey, Toby Nankervis

Brett Deledio, Brendon Goddard, Devon Smith, Dane Swan, Tim Membrey, Jesse Hogan
Nick Kommer, Mitchell Clark

Cash Left: $11,300

[Money Shot]

I really like the defence as it is unique but all should be solid picks.
Love the midfield also but not sure on the O'Rouke pick as I don't see him breaking into the side straight away.
rucks are standard but good.
Forward line is good although not sure on the Membrey pick as I don't see him being that good a scorer (although I see where you are coming from with that pick)
really cant fault the team it is very good just keep playing around with a few players and It will be a gun team.
could you please rate my team.

[Pkbaldy]

I really like the defence as it is unique but all should be solid picks.
Love the midfield also but not sure on the O'Rouke pick as I don't see him breaking into the side straight away.
rucks are standard but good.
Forward line is good although not sure on the Membrey pick as I don't see him being that good a scorer (although I see where you are coming from with that pick)
really cant fault the team it is very good just keep playing around with a few players and It will be a gun team.
could you please rate my team.

I just picked an expensive rookie for O'Rourke. Probs wont go with him. Ignoring them until NAB challenge really.
Membrey will be an alright scorer. Not expecting 100s every week. but he should be dirt cheap and will play every week. So to me he will be a cash cow.

Yeah I will soon mate. Movie time!

[Pkbaldy]

First quick dip. Don't mind the look of it. But will change when the meta shifts.

$1,400 Cash Left

[Ricochet]

man concern man would be Cox at R3. If you had Belly in the fwd line as cover with a dpp link then it would be fine, but without him i reckon you'll need something a bit more solid on the ruck bench. Maybe drop Rich down to a rookie or VB  to get some cash

[Bones Bombers]

Like the structure. Rookies will change a lot of course. I'm happy with the rucks as one of Kreuzer, Luey or Belly should prove reliable to start the season and then deal with any injury when or if it happens.
You have a couple of uniques you are obviously keen on too so it will be interesting to see how you go when the real thing starts!

[Pkbaldy]

Like the structure. Rookies will change a lot of course. I'm happy with the rucks as one of Kreuzer, Luey or Belly should prove reliable to start the season and then deal with any injury when or if it happens.
You have a couple of uniques you are obviously keen on too so it will be interesting to see how you go when the real thing starts!

Yeah i've just chucked in rough rookies. Only line I dont see moving (Unless injury) is my FWD line. Pretty happy with how it is at the moment.

[Bones Bombers]

Like the structure. Rookies will change a lot of course. I'm happy with the rucks as one of Kreuzer, Luey or Belly should prove reliable to start the season and then deal with any injury when or if it happens.
You have a couple of uniques you are obviously keen on too so it will be interesting to see how you go when the real thing starts!

Yeah i've just chucked in rough rookies. Only line I dont see moving (Unless injury) is my FWD line. Pretty happy with how it is at the moment.

Pretty certain Kommer won't be ready unfortunately but there will be a replacement pop up there.

[jasonpushy]

As a hawthorn supporter.    I am not sold on your hawk picks.

Birchall a great team man, but is very up and down and when is playing well is often tagged out.     Others in that price range would be better value.

Whitecross is cheap, but not a proven SC player.   I think he has had one season in the 80pt range, the rest has been mid 60's and less.    With Frawley into to the team, he might even struggle to get back in.    I would pick a rookie and save $50K.

Jono is a great pick up for the club, but will be hard for him to break into the team, which mid fielder from the G/F is going to drop out?    Go with a rookie.

[roti]

Think it's actually a very good effort in terms of structure. Defence is strong with 3 premo's plus Newnes and Whitecross. Midfield solid with 4 premo's plus Rich and O'Rourke, think you could do better than O'Rourke at that price range though. Rucks very strong. Forwards pretty spot on. Good platform to work with

[fasttrack13]

Think it's actually a very good effort in terms of structure. Defence is strong with 3 premo's plus Newnes and Whitecross. Midfield solid with 4 premo's plus Rich and O'Rourke, think you could do better than O'Rourke at that price range though. Rucks very strong. Forwards pretty spot on. Good platform to work with

Couldnt have said it better

[JBs-Hawks]

As a hawthorn supporter.    I am not sold on your hawk picks.

Birchall a great team man, but is very up and down and when is playing well is often tagged out.     Others in that price range would be better value.

Whitecross is cheap, but not a proven SC player.   I think he has had one season in the 80pt range, the rest has been mid 60's and less.    With Frawley into to the team, he might even struggle to get back in.    I would pick a rookie and save $50K.

Jono is a great pick up for the club, but will be hard for him to break into the team, which mid fielder from the G/F is going to drop out?    Go with a rookie.

Disagree with you on the hawks boys.

Birch is class, you pay for class and you get class.

Whitey is a lock if named rd 1.

Only one id change is orourke for hartung. Hartung is my tip for a Liam Shielsesque break out.

[Ricochet]

Whitecross is cheap, but not a proven SC player.   I think he has had one season in the 80pt range, the rest has been mid 60's and less.    With Frawley into to the team, he might even struggle to get back in.    I would pick a rookie and save $50K.

There aren't that many decent rookies down back man. Whitex is rookie priced and more established. You have to seriously consider him