Official Trades List 2014 - Trade Period 1

[R.Griffen]

Vancouver Give: S.Docherty + D.Rich + M.Golby + Nat 28
Hawaii Give: J.Lewis + 3rd Nat + C.Moller + Nat 40

Picker to confirm

Confirmed.

I think Docherty will be a gun defender one day so our back line will suffer from this trade in the future but I have very lil good midfielders, and to secure Lewis a top 5 ave playing from this yr our quest for the premiership just got a whole lot stronger!!

Did I miss something doesn't Mem have Nat 3?

[elephants]

3rd round Nat ^ so Nat 33

[R.Griffen]

3rd round Nat ^ so Nat 33

Oh sorry got confused as I never saw it traded before that

[R.Griffen]

Vancouver Gives L.Hansen + D.Gardiner + Nat 21
Calgary Gives L..Dunstan + D.Barry + K.Brand

[picker_man]

Vancouver Gives L.Hansen + D.Gardiner + Nat 21
Calgary Gives L..Dunstan + D.Barry + K.Brand

Confirmed.
My back line is getting small now :( Really needed another mid and prolly 2 more (anyone....) so hoping Dunstan improves next year, Should be a future gun though hopefully??

[Grannyboy]

Enormous trade this one!

Hawaii Give: T.Greene + T.Cloke + T.Bugg + S.Thompson + N16
El Paso Give: L.Parker + JJ.Kennedy + B.Lennon + B.Kennedy + N11

The Dog to confirm!

Eles now coaching the Alpacs and TDog the hydro bombs :P

[T Dog]

Enormous trade this one!

Hawaii Give: T.Greene + T.Cloke + T.Bugg + S.Thompson + N16
El Paso Give: L.Parker + JJ.Kennedy + B.Lennon + B.Kennedy + N11

The Dog to confirm!

Eles now coaching the Alpacs and TDog the hydro bombs :P

Ele would be so lucky..he can dream though.. ;D

[Football Factory]

Enormous trade this one!

Hawaii Give: T.Greene + T.Cloke + T.Bugg + S.Thompson + N16
El Paso Give: L.Parker + JJ.Kennedy + B.Lennon + B.Kennedy + N11

The Dog to confirm!

Eles now coaching the Alpacs and TDog the hydro bombs :P

pmsl

[Football Factory]

Can everyone involved in trades please check the OP to make sure your trades are posted correctly. And if I have missed a confirmed trade please let me know thanks.

[Grannyboy]

Zaharakis didn't take part in the supplements program cause he is shower scared of needles

Luckiest bloke alive haha

Him and windowlicker both.

[Grannyboy]

Vancouver Give: S.Docherty + D.Rich + M.Golby + Nat 28
Hawaii Give: J.Lewis + Nat 33 + C.Moller + Nat 40


El Paso give:  P.Dangerfield; B. Crouch; C. Shenton
Vancouver give: P. Hanley; S. Sidebottom; B. Brown

After some concern over these two trades raised by other coaches we are posting them for comment by other coaches. If you are involved in these trades please post reasons as to why you want the players/picks in question and why you are trading your players/picks.

[popedelio]

Vancouver Give: S.Docherty + D.Rich + M.Golby + Nat 28
Hawaii Give: J.Lewis + Nat 33 + C.Moller + Nat 40

This one I'm just not entirely sure, Lewis had a breakout this season so essentially the main essence of this trade imo would be Docherty and Rich for Lewis, which I would I say is fair. So imo a fairer trade would be
Vancouver Give: S.Docherty + D.Rich
Hawaii Give: J.Lewis + Nat 40

El Paso give:  P.Dangerfield; B. Crouch; C. Shenton
Vancouver give: P. Hanley; S. Sidebottom; B. Brown

This one I see as reasonably fair, especially if Hanley keeps his dpp back and Dangerfield loses his dpp fwd. If they are all going to be mids only, it still is fair as Sidebottom averaged more this season whilst Hanley is also a strong scorer, where Danger is a strong scorer and is proven to avg 100, and Crouch is a young gun who should avg 100 eventually. the other 2 players are just trade sweetners

[R.Griffen]

Vancouver Give: S.Docherty + D.Rich + M.Golby + Nat 28
Hawaii Give: J.Lewis + Nat 33 + C.Moller + Nat 40

El Paso give:  P.Dangerfield; B. Crouch; C. Shenton
Vancouver give: P. Hanley; S. Sidebottom; B. Brown

After some concern over these two trades raised by other coaches we are posting them for comment by other coaches. If you are involved in these trades please post reasons as to why you want the players/picks in question and why you are trading your players/picks.

The issue with the top one is that
Nat 28 + Golby
For
Nat 33 + Moller

Golby have played before and has been a 70+ Twice in his career at the age of 23.   
Moller has played 1 game. And to state the obvious pick 28 is better than 33 doesn't make sense

This means Docherty + Rich for Lewis and Nat 40 I am fine with

[R.Griffen]

The issue with the top one is that
Nat 28 + Golby
For
Nat 33 + Moller

Golby have played before and has been a 70+ Twice in his career at the age of 23.   
Moller has played 1 game. And to state the obvious pick 28 is better than 33 doesn't make sense

This means Docherty + Rich for Lewis and Nat 40 I am fine with
[/quote]

Its extremely concerning that he's been stuck in the NEAFL all season though. Leppa has come in and Golby is suddenly on the outer. Naturally, he's not a big part of this trade at all.
[/quote]

He played 12 games in the AFL that's not all season in the NEAFL

[LF]

El Paso give:  P.Dangerfield; B. Crouch; C. Shenton
Vancouver give: P. Hanley; S. Sidebottom; B. Brown

2014 Averages
Danger 92,Crouch 96,Shenton 52
Hanley 98,Sidey 108,Brown 57

Danger and Hanley likely to lose DPP,Shenton likely to be def and Brown likely a fwd only not sure if they have factored this in at all would be nice to know this from the coaches involved in the trade :)
If the proposed positional cchanges happen you have 2 mids with higher averages are being traded for 2 mids with lower averages that may or mat not boost their averages next year.Brown seems to have cemented a spot in the Roos best 22 where Shenton is in and out of the team and seems to be a fringe player atm.