General Discussion

Started by Football Factory, September 29, 2014, 07:44:39 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

T Dog

Quote from: Pkbaldy on January 11, 2016, 09:32:30 PM
Quote from: T Dog on January 11, 2016, 09:30:07 PM
Will need to look at it too. Sounds a winner at 1st view though.

it's a positive for you :P More people will want to trade you. Haha


Awww C'mon..I don't just trade anyone,  >:(    I trade everyone   ;)

Football Factory

Quote from: T Dog on January 11, 2016, 09:50:26 PM
Quote from: Pkbaldy on January 11, 2016, 09:32:30 PM
Quote from: T Dog on January 11, 2016, 09:30:07 PM
Will need to look at it too. Sounds a winner at 1st view though.

it's a positive for you :P More people will want to trade you. Haha


Awww C'mon..I don't just trade anyone,  >:(    I trade everyone   ;)

pmsl

Pkbaldy

Yeah well if Bolivia had #1 this time last year. I wouldn't of hesitated, I would of chosen Darcy Tucker. And I would of been able to match the bid against LF at pick 30, wouldn't cost me much, but he isn't a worthy pick compared to like Hopper and Mills. Adds so much more depth, can backfire though :P

Atto

It's way complicated and hopefully I'll understand completely later on (I sort of do after watching the draft), but it's in consideration from my end. Question I have is how certain players will be allocated to which club?

Pkbaldy

#454
Quote from: Atto on January 11, 2016, 11:08:42 PM
It's way complicated and hopefully I'll understand completely later on (I sort of do after watching the draft), but it's in consideration from my end. Question I have is how certain players will be allocated to which club?

Mini draft for Academy rights either in the form of reverse ladder or lottery.

Obviously it'll only be 1 round, so it's only effecting 12 players. So it'll be quick and pretty easy to manage through out this years National Draft, mainly if 2 or 3 end up pick 40+ draftees... which CAN happen.

LF

Regarding any suspended Essendon players,I am thinking this could work am open to any ideas tho as to how to handle it.
Officially delist the player affected for the season and do a mini draft based on the players worth eg if a player is your main ruck then he'd be worth more than another player
Then at seasons end the players picked in the mini draft are delisted back into the player pool and each team gets their original player back so lists all remain the same size.

T Dog

Quote from: LF on January 12, 2016, 12:31:49 PM
Regarding any suspended Essendon players,I am thinking this could work am open to any ideas tho as to how to handle it.
Officially delist the player affected for the season and do a mini draft based on the players worth eg if a player is your main ruck then he'd be worth more than another player
Then at seasons end the players picked in the mini draft are delisted back into the player pool and each team gets their original player back so lists all remain the same size.

Worth = selection order from the player pool left over?

LF


T Dog

Works for me. Mods decision to be final, not going to a vote on value levels is my only suggestion.

Football Factory

Something needs to be done, sounds like a good idea, depending on how bad teams are affected, im even open to lending a player if a team is severely affected.

LF

I will look at all affected teams and use that coupled with avg,position and captain option to work out a players worth and then post it up to get coaches opinions on it

Pkbaldy

I thought it would of worked out like a LTI sort of thing... Not like people get compensated for players who get a season injury at the start of the year.

But either way it doesn't bother me, as it barely effects my team.

Football Factory

This isn't a normal situation though.

Pkbaldy

Quote from: Football Factory on January 12, 2016, 01:09:21 PM
This isn't a normal situation though.

Still, don't expect a player to get season injuries during pre-season.

It's not like it's a 5 year ban.

I can see peoples teams getting stronger when they release who the top of players are. As I could see a fair few of them being ex AFL players like Stokes, Kelly and ect...

LF

I'll add in this then maybe you need to pick like for like positions
Watson = mid
Carlisle = def or fwd etc