General Discussion

[LF]

A question to do with VC scores
What happens if it ends up as for example 98.5 does it round up?

Yep, round it up.

Thank you :)

[Football Factory]

Hello coaches, Grannyboy and myself are still trying to work out a fair way to resolve the failure of Ele to post his team in round 1.

What are your thoughts about giving him the lowest score 1408 (memphs score) that way the percentages do not blow out.

[popedelio]

So why couldn't you name a team for him and give him a 1st warning? Doesn't ele have some sort of draft 2015 team in his thread?

[Football Factory]

So why couldn't you name a team for him and give him a 1st warning? Doesn't ele have some sort of draft 2015 team in his thread?

Because of the partial lockout, and the fact that Griff and Memph posted their teams ..but late and as a result did not receive points for the players that had already started playing .. Memph posted after quarter time and Griff posted at half time in the games in question.

Ele only posted his Richmond and Carlton players.

[popedelio]

Below was a team he made back in December, which would have been close to what he named in round 1...

First Team
B: Bachar Houli (d), Paul Duffield (d), Harry Taylor (d), Garrick Ibbotson (d)
M: Scott Pendlebury (m), Trent Cotchin (m), Dyson Heppell (m), Marc Murphy (m), Kieran Jack (m), Luke Parker (m)
U: David Armitage (m), Josh Thomas (f/m), Andrejs Everitt (d/m)
R: Shane Mumford (r)
F: Tom Mitchell (f/m), Brett Deledio (f/m), Josh Kennedy (f), Tom Lynch (f)

So updating his team with what he had named to what he drafted earlier

Captain:
Vice Captain: Trent Cotchin
DVC: Bachar Houli

Back: Bachar Houli, Duffield, Taylor, Ibbotson
Mid: Trent Cotchin, Marc Murphy, Pendlebury, Heppell, Jack, Parker
Ruck: Mumford
Fwd: Brett Deledio, Mitchell, Kennedy, Lynch
Utilities: Armitage, J. Thomas, .....(everitt was named here)
Int: Andrejs Everitt (F), Andrew Carrazzo (M)
Emg:

So above will be his team for the 1st round

[Football Factory]

Below was a team he made back in December, which would have been close to what he named in round 1...

First Team
B: Bachar Houli (d), Paul Duffield (d), Harry Taylor (d), Garrick Ibbotson (d)
M: Scott Pendlebury (m), Trent Cotchin (m), Dyson Heppell (m), Marc Murphy (m), Kieran Jack (m), Luke Parker (m)
U: David Armitage (m), Josh Thomas (f/m), Andrejs Everitt (d/m)
R: Shane Mumford (r)
F: Tom Mitchell (f/m), Brett Deledio (f/m), Josh Kennedy (f), Tom Lynch (f)

So updating his team with what he had named to what he drafted earlier

Captain:
Vice Captain: Trent Cotchin
DVC: Bachar Houli

Back: Bachar Houli, Duffield, Taylor, Ibbotson
Mid: Trent Cotchin, Marc Murphy, Pendlebury, Heppell, Jack, Parker
Ruck: Mumford
Fwd: Brett Deledio, Mitchell, Kennedy, Lynch
Utilities: Armitage, J. Thomas, .....(everitt was named here)
Int: Andrejs Everitt (F), Andrew Carrazzo (M)
Emg:

And if that team wins is that fair considering he didn't post a team after I sent multiple messages while he was online posting and ignored them.

So what do we do for Griff and Memphs teams ? do we give them some players to fill the spots that they didn't get ?

[Football Factory]

I can see this issue not being resolved and going on for weeks, im so over being in admin to be honest.

[popedelio]

So his scoring will be as follows:

Captain:
Vice Captain: Trent Cotchin
DVC: Bachar Houli

Back: Bachar Houli (78*1.5=117), Paul Duffield (68), Harry Taylor (70), Garrick Ibbotson (57)
Mid: Trent Cotchin (54*2=108), Marc Murphy (67), Scott Pendlebury (104), Dyson Heppell (111), Kieran Jack (104), Parker (111)
Ruck: Shane Mumford (66)
Fwd: Brett Deledio (53), Tom Mitchell (DNP), Josh Kennedy (67), Tom Lynch (DNP)
Utilities: David Armitage (89), Andrejs Everitt (80), Andrew Carrazzo (54)

Since no Captain was named, Cotchin becomes Captain and Houli becomes VC
Everitt replaces Thomas, Carazzo replaces open position in 3rd utility spot

score of 1326

Still lower then Memphs, but at least it was close to a side he would have named and would still lose

And if that team wins is that fair considering he didn't post a team after I sent multiple messages while he was online posting and ignored them.

So what do we do for Griff and Memphs teams ? do we give them some players to fill the spots that they didn't get ?

As I answered above he would still lose, if Memph and Griff had a draft team and a certain player were listed then sure they should get them.

But if they don't name again, then they get there 2nd offence and the team that was named in round 1 will be used. So for ele's case the team above will be used, and he would lose his VC score

It is only week one and most teams did post some form of draft team, so can't just name only 4 players on field as in ele's case

I can see this issue not being resolved and going on for weeks, im so over being in admin to be honest.

We all appreciate your effort FF as being our admin, it is just unfortunate that rd 1 didn't go smoothly, but I'm sure things will pick up :)

[Football Factory]

Ive been talking about this subject for ages and im over it if that's what people want to do then let me know mate. Not trying to be rude just so over it.

[elephants]

Hey lads,

I really don't mind what happens to the team last week. I deserve the loss and regardless it seems as though I'll get it.

Easter is a very major thing for my family, Friday involved one side, Sunday the other side, Saturday one side of the girlfriends and Monday the girlfriends other side. I literally hardly had a spare minute and when I did I was intoxicated and on my phone with zero chance of posting up a team.

I'll be endeavouring to post my side for the rest of the season.

Cheers, Ele.

[popedelio]

Ive been talking about this subject for ages and im over it if that's what people want to do then let me know mate. Not trying to be rude just so over it.

You asked for an opinion and I gave you my thoughts and solution on the matter, if you're over talking about the subject then just go with the decision you had made and make it final to close the discussion :)

Hey lads,

I really don't mind what happens to the team last week. I deserve the loss and regardless it seems as though I'll get it.

Easter is a very major thing for my family, Friday involved one side, Sunday the other side, Saturday one side of the girlfriends and Monday the girlfriends other side. I literally hardly had a spare minute and when I did I was intoxicated and on my phone with zero chance of posting up a team.

I'll be endeavouring to post my side for the rest of the season.

Cheers, Ele.

Good to hear Ele  ;D

[picker_man]

Seems easiest to give ele the lowest score (1408) doesn't give me a huge percentage boost that way either.

[T Dog]

Any decision works for me   :)

[LF]

Seems easiest to give ele the lowest score (1408) doesn't give me a huge percentage boost that way either.

Just go with this I guess easiest way to go

[Grannyboy]

I've updated the ladder giving ele the lowest points for which leaves him 2nd bottom 1.3% above Calgary so no-one get a huge advantage or disadvantage from his score.
As Asuncion posted a low but competitive score and was 1 player short which cost them a victory (and no captains named) we left their scores as is.
I hope everyone is happy with this as it seemed the fairest solution for the whole competition. Remember to post your teams this week!