EXV: Discussion

[nrich102]

I think we should do it. I really like the idea. Would need to be kept track of though.

[Vinny]

This competition can't handle it.

[nrich102]

This competition can't handle it.

Actually this is probably true  :-\

[Holz]

This competition can't handle it.

fair call,

im personally against it in the euro as the comp is soo even that its hard to predict where the team will finish the year after. I think with only 14 teams even the team that wins is guaranteed a chance of securing a decent player unlike the comps with more players. Along with that we have the strong rookie draft.

Im personally voting no but I want to hear everyone elses thoughts.

[Ziplock]

This competition can't handle it.

fair call,

im personally against it in the euro as the comp is soo even that its hard to predict where the team will finish the year after. I think with only 14 teams even the team that wins is guaranteed a chance of securing a decent player unlike the comps with more players. Along with that we have the strong rookie draft.

Im personally voting no but I want to hear everyone elses thoughts.

I think it's probably unnecessary tbh, I was just curious.

[Atto]

I like it in the AFL, I would be interested to see how it would work for something like this but I believe it would be too complicated.

[Nige]

Nope.

[Spite]

Nope.

[Rids]

Nope.

[Spite]

Nope.

All aboard the Nope train!

[Hellopplz]

Nope.

All aboard the Nope train!

Nah.

Think it could get messy indeed and not really needed for Euros. If the comp was a bit more organised could consider in a few seasons if an expansion comes in, otherwise happy to keep it the way it is.

[Holz]

here is the list of guys not taken in the rookie draft last year

Adelaide: D Talia, C Ellis-Yolmen, J Osborn, S Siggins, J Kelly, K Cheney, R O'Brien, K Ramsey, R Atkins, J Podsiadly, K Hartigan, A Otten, S Shaw, H Dear

Brisbane:   M Close, M Maguire, J Clarke,  J Bourke, J Freeman, A Smith, B Evans, H Beasley, M Hammelman, B Staker, J Paine, D Gardiner, J Watts, J McGrath

Carlton: M Watson, M Jamison, S White, C Byrne, N Holman, D Ellard, C Wood, B Johnson, B Gowers, B Walsh, T Fields, F Russell, D Armfield, J Foster

Collingwood: J Ramsay, T Goldsack, N Brown, L Keeffe,  A Toovey, A Oxley, J Frost, J Marsh, C Gault, M Manteit, B Abbott, M Cox, J White, B McCaffer

Essendon: A Browne, D Fletcher, A Steinberg, S Edwards, O Fantasia, Z OBrien, P Ambrose, W Hams, S McKernan, K Aylett, J Long, C McKenna, T Pears, H Hocking, J Ashby

Fremantle: R Crowley, A Silvagni, A Pearce, B Grey, Z Dawson, M Wood, T Vandeleur, J Ballard, J Hannath, E Hughes, S Hurley, E Langdon, M Apeness, A Morabito, C Sylvia

Geelong: M Brown, L McCarthy, T Lonergan,  J Cowan, J Walker, J Rivers, B Hartman, J Toohey, N Bourke, Z Bates, M Luxford, J Bews, T Read, P Lucey, C Gregson

Gold Coast: R Thompson, J Taylor, J Hutchins, S Tape, J Hall, J Ellis, J Leslie, C Cameron, A Raines, J Glenn, A Saad, K Brooksby, T Downie

GWS: T Golds, N Wilson, A Phillips, J Townsend, T Downie, S Schultz, A Corr, P Davis, J Stewart, J Patfull, C MCarthy, L Sumner, D Addison

Hawthorn: J Simpkin, K Brand, L Langford, S Tatupu, J Sicily, D Willsmore, Z Webster, J Hardisty, J Miller-Lewis, B Lake, T Miles, M Pittonet, M Spangher, T O'brien

Melbourne: J Spencer, R Bail, J Fitzpatrick, J Hunt, C Pedersen, J McKenzie, L Tapscott, J Harmes, M King, S Frost, M White, C Garland

North Melbourne:  E Wallace, M Warren, M Firrito, J Tippett, B Preuss, W Fordham, K Harper, T.Garner, M.Daw< D Nielson

Port Adelaide: P Stewart, A Carlile, B Ah Chee, T Logan, D Byrne-Jones, K Mitchell, S Russell, S Gray, T Jonas, N Krakoeur, J Wagner, M Shaw, J Butcher, D Howard, L Austin, J Palmer, B Frampton

Richmond: M Dea, D Astbury, S Lloyd, S Morris, M Thomas, T Elton, J Short, J Castagna, I Soldo, N Drummond, C Newman, L McBean, K McIntosh, D Butler

St Kilda: L Pierce, J Saunders, T Simpkin, D Minchington, J Holmes, J Sinclair, A Saad, B Payne, T Lee, A Siposs, A Schneider, B.Murdoch

Sydney: T Richards, H Marsh, X Richards, D Robinson, A Aliir,  P Mitchell, S McLaren, N Newman, L Melican, J Foote, G Hewett, J Hiscox, A Johnson,J Rose, A Davis

West Coast: M Brown, P McGinnity, F McInnes, J Bennell, S Tunbridge, D Main, T Barrass, R Powell, C Adamson, P Brophy, M Karpany

Western Bulldogs: E Wood, F Roberts, D Morris, J Redpath, D Pearce, T Campbell, J Hamling, R Smith, J Kelly, M Fuller, T Dickson, B Goodes, J Roughead

[Holz]

once again the rookie draft can be used to balance out the comp and give hope to those clubs on the bottom,while top teams can still find plenty of players

C Ellis-Yolmen 68 average mid
Jake Kelly 49 average defender
Cameron Wood 58 average ruck
Adam Oxley 74 average defender
Alex Pearce 46 average defnder
Adam Saad 66 average defender
Cameron McCarth 53 average forward
Colin Garland 62 average defender
Adam Schnieder 83 average forward
Joel Hamling 50 average defender

just to name a few. Not as good as usual but still some guys I would want on my list.

[Nige]

You're supposed to let the people find the hidden gems themselves Holz.  :P

[LF]

Have been looking at the list for a few weeks now haha