The Jack Ziebell Award: Voting Thread

Started by BratPack, September 12, 2014, 10:54:09 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

BratPack



The Fan Footy Community nominated. Now it is time for the Fan Footy Community to vote for 2014's biggest Dream Team Failure. The Jack Ziebell Award Winner.

8 Worthy Finalists were chosen, all with plenty of reasons why they should be crowned but only one can win.

Voting Remains open till the end of Brownlow Night the 22nd of September. To not taint the vote the votes will only be revealed after voting closes. But it's your chance to speak Fan Footy.

Who is your source of hatred?

Who is the biggest Dream Team tease of 2014?

Who is the winner of the Ziebell?

Capper


BratPack


tbagrocks


jvalles69

Don't think you should include previous guns/premos, if they have had a DT premo year they don't deserve to be in the same category as some of the names mentioned.

Swan, Ward and Simpson are not "DT teases" as they have proven in the past what they can do on a consistent bases.  Simpson solid defender all year and dropped some bad scores towards the end but still up there in terms of defenders. Swan's injuries kept him down, picking him up at stages was always a high risk because of it.  Ward gun, but on a team that sometimes struggles and cops the most attention.

Wingard, Zorko and Liberatore are the 3 that should be right up there, potential to be guns and do enough to pick them up in your teams, but drop enough inconsistent scores that you regret trading them in, in the first place.

henry

Not sure how Carlisle's a tease, surely noone thought he was going to score well lol. Same with Simpson, he was a premium defender who scored consistently and reliably the whole year, sure he had a couple of shockers but if you'd of told me he'd average 92 (a 7 point average on last year) at the start of the year and play all games I'd take it no questions asked. Ward I think is only a tease because of injury, take away those scores and he's had a great year.

For me it definitely is Libba, far too many scores under 100, and especially for me as I brought him in as an upgrade target, where he proceeded to score  76, 90, 81, 97, 94, 75.

BratPack

I asked the community to nominate as it's a community nominated, community voted award. These were the names nominated

Justin Bieber

Quote from: BratPack on September 12, 2014, 11:08:00 PM
Quote from: tabs on September 12, 2014, 11:00:31 PM
hidden total. Who will win?
You'll find out on Brownlow night  ;)
Flower. I can see the results after I voted :(.

DAMN YOU ADMIN POWERS >:(.

jvalles69

Prestia is probably one who should've made this list.

Capper

Quote from: jvalles69 on September 16, 2014, 05:32:25 PM
Prestia is probably one who should've made this list.
then you should have nominated him

Mr.Craig

Was just looking at JZ's scores for the year. Whenever he went 100+ his score the following week was on average 49 points lower.

He's still got it!

SydneyRox

Quote from: Mr.Craig on September 17, 2014, 07:50:48 PM
Was just looking at JZ's scores for the year. Whenever he went 100+ his score the following week was on average 49 points lower.

He's still got it!

I was actually thinking is there any reason he cant win it? (besides not being in the poll?)

Mr.Craig

He had 1% ownership, the only ones who got burnt picking him were noobs anyway.

T Dog


Mr.Craig