2014 All Australian Team

[Big Mac]

How do you guys rate Nev Jetta's year?

[Mr.Craig]

How do you guys rate Nev Jetta's year?

Were you meant to post this in the Melbourne discussion?  ???

I think he's a little way off AA.  ;)

[Mailman the 2nd]

He's done pretty well, but he's in a position which doesn't get mentioned at all usually bar Nick Smith and played in a team that did poorly

[lachie_001]

FB: E. Mackenzie/A. Rance, C. Hooker, N. Smith
HB: B. Smith, D. Talia, N. Malceski
C: N. Fyfe, J. Kennedy, D. Heppell
HF: B. Harvey, L. Franklin, R. Gray
FF: L. Breust, J. Roughead, H. Ballantyne/ E. Betts
Fol: S. Jacobs, G. Ablett, J. Selwood
I/C: J. Lewis, L. Parker, S. Pendlebury, M. Priddis

I think all these players are locked in. Between betts and ballantyne who gets that small forward role and Mackenzie and rance for the third tall. I personally think ballantyne and rance will take those spots

[Big Mac]

How do you guys rate Nev Jetta's year?

Were you meant to post this in the Melbourne discussion?  ???

I think he's a little way off AA.  ;)

Just gauging how he is rated on here. He has played incredibly well this year (look at the shut down roles he played on Betts, Green, Chapman etc) and I was trying to use FF'ers opinions as a way to judge whether he would've even been mentioned during AA talks.

Edit: It probably sounds like i'm upset he didn't get selected or something but I legitimately just wanted to know where he sits in other people's opinion.

[lachie_001]

How do you guys rate Nev Jetta's year?

Were you meant to post this in the Melbourne discussion?  ???

I think he's a little way off AA.  ;)

Just gauging how he is rated on here. He has played incredibly well this year (look at the shut down roles he played on Betts, Green, Chapman etc) and I was trying to use FF'ers opinions as a way to judge whether he would've even been mentioned during AA talks.

He's done some good jobs on opposition smalls but I think the AA looks for a few years of consistency. Talia for instance has been really good for 2012-2013 and it's only really happened this year that he's been labelled as an elite CHB in the competition.

[Toga]

Importantly, the International Rules team will be picked from these 40 players!

[quinny88]

The biggest surprise for me is no McVeigh or Sloane.
Ellis is a nice surprise, he's had a great season.

From that squad my team would probably be:

FB: N.Smith, Rance, Mackenzie

HB: Malceski, Hooker, B.Smith

C:   Fyfe, Kennedy, Rockliff

HF: Gray, Franklin, Parker

FF: Breust, Roughead, Gunston

R:  Jacobs, Selwood (C), Pendlebury

Cbf picking an interchange


D Beams,
D Heppell
C Ward
J Lewis
B Harvey
T Boak
D Martin,
M Priddis

[lachie_001]

The biggest surprise for me is no McVeigh or Sloane.
Ellis is a nice surprise, he's had a great season.

From that squad my team would probably be:

FB: N.Smith, Rance, Mackenzie

HB: Malceski, Hooker, B.Smith

C:   Fyfe, Kennedy, Rockliff

HF: Gray, Franklin, Parker

FF: Breust, Roughead, Gunston

R:  Jacobs, Selwood (C), Pendlebury

Cbf picking an interchange


D Beams,
D Heppell
C Ward
J Lewis
B Harvey
T Boak
D Martin,
M Priddis

No Talia?

[Jukes]

Talia, Hooker, Rance
Malceski, Ward, Smith
Jacobs, Selwood (c), JPK
Rockliff, Pendles, Heppell (GOAT)
Dusty, Riewoldt, Gray
Gunston, Roughead, Buddy

Int: MacKenzie, Boak, Fyfe, Parker

[elephants]

Tbh, Jones is a must-have vs the Irish :(

[quinny88]

The biggest surprise for me is no McVeigh or Sloane.
Ellis is a nice surprise, he's had a great season.

From that squad my team would probably be:

FB: N.Smith, Rance, Mackenzie

HB: Malceski, Hooker, B.Smith

C:   Fyfe, Kennedy, Rockliff

HF: Gray, Franklin, Parker

FF: Breust, Roughead, Gunston

R:  Jacobs, Selwood (C), Pendlebury

Cbf picking an interchange


D Beams,
D Heppell
C Ward
J Lewis
B Harvey
T Boak
D Martin,
M Priddis

No Talia?

He's definitely a chance. I think there will be 3 out of Rance, Talia, Mackenzie, Hooker but one of them is going to be very unlucky.

[ossie85]

Importantly, the International Rules team will be picked from these 40 players!

I thought it was picked from all players who have ever been All Australian?

[Ricochet]

Importantly, the International Rules team will be picked from these 40 players!

I thought it was picked from all players who have ever been All Australian?

Yep previous AA players as well

[GoLions]

The biggest surprise for me is no McVeigh or Sloane.
Ellis is a nice surprise, he's had a great season.

From that squad my team would probably be:

FB: N.Smith, Rance, Mackenzie

HB: Malceski, Hooker, B.Smith

C:   Fyfe, Kennedy, Rockliff

HF: Gray, Franklin, Parker

FF: Breust, Roughead, Gunston

R:  Jacobs, Selwood (C), Pendlebury

Cbf picking an interchange


D Beams,
D Heppell
C Ward
J Lewis
B Harvey
T Boak
D Martin,
M Priddis

No Talia?

He's definitely a chance. I think there will be 3 out of Rance, Talia, Mackenzie, Hooker but one of them is going to be very unlucky.

More importantly, no Gaz?