Off Season Trade Rumours

[RaisyDaisy]

Pick 19 is already overs

Surely they'll end up taking it

[RaisyDaisy]

Miles update

Pask on Miles: We'll have a better understanding next week on him. He's prepared to move if the opportunities for him are greater elsewhere

[Ringo]

You would think so RD. Agree 19 is already overs for a player who was picked up in a rookie draft and wanting to return home. (Boy wish we had played as hard ball with some of our go home boys.) Surely Adelaide will realise Pick 19 now is better than nothing next year.

[TomK]

You would think so RD. Agree 19 is already overs for a player who was picked up in a rookie draft and wanting to return home. (Boy wish we had played as hard ball with some of our go home boys.) Surely Adelaide will realise Pick 19 now is better than nothing next year.

I agree that we should take pick 19 but why is him being taken in the Rookie Draft relevant 4 years later? Should have no influence on his worth.

[Money Shot]

Adelaide out: 16 & second round 18
In: Gibbs

Brisbane out: Schache
In: 16

Carlton out: Gibbs
In: Kennedy & Schache

GWS out: Kennedy
In (ADE) second round 18

Seeing a lot of sites having a trade similar to this going down. What are people's thoughts on it? Gibbs seems happy at Carlton but I'm sure he'd be happy at the crows as well!

Also have Carlton actually said they are interested in Schache or is that just rumours?

[Ringo]

You would think so RD. Agree 19 is already overs for a player who was picked up in a rookie draft and wanting to return home. (Boy wish we had played as hard ball with some of our go home boys.) Surely Adelaide will realise Pick 19 now is better than nothing next year.

I agree that we should take pick 19 but why is him being taken in the Rookie Draft relevant 4 years later? Should have no influence on his worth.

No probs with it Tom Just that in these trades some people like to refer to draft positions. Personally think based on his current form pick in 20s probably more realistic so 19 should be accepted.

[Jukes]

You would think so RD. Agree 19 is already overs for a player who was picked up in a rookie draft and wanting to return home. (Boy wish we had played as hard ball with some of our go home boys.) Surely Adelaide will realise Pick 19 now is better than nothing next year.

I agree that we should take pick 19 but why is him being taken in the Rookie Draft relevant 4 years later? Should have no influence on his worth.

No probs with it Tom Just that in these trades some people like to refer to draft positions. Personally think based on his current form pick in 20s probably more realistic so 19 should be accepted.

I think 19 is certainly overs too, I may be from the Dodoro school of trading but I wouldn't give up anything above pick 30 for him. He's just not that great tbh. As you'll see in my next paragraph, we gave up equivalent of like pick 34/46/whatever for Smith, and it's fair to say Smith > Cameron.



Also guys, I'm just trying to work out the draft points system. From my calcuations we gave up the equivalent to pick 34 if you ignore the swap of 2018 picks, I'm not too sure how you factor those in - half the point value maybe? If so it would become like pick 46 which would be an absolute bargain in terms of point equivalency, but that doesn't seem that right (11 and 46* for Smith, 24 and 26*, *2018 pick seems like it favours GWS a lot more than just pick 34/46 for Smith). Somebody on BF said we gave up equivalent of pick 50+ for Smith so idk.

[RaisyDaisy]

SYDNEY midfielder Daniel Robinson has expressed interest in leaving the club as he searches for greater opportunities elsewhere.

[GoLions]

SYDNEY midfielder Daniel Robinson has expressed interest in leaving the club as he searches for greater opportunities elsewhere.

Big if true

[fanTCfool]

SYDNEY midfielder Daniel Robinson has expressed interest in leaving the club as he searches for greater opportunities elsewhere.

Big if true

Radical if factual

[Koop]

SYDNEY midfielder Daniel Robinson has expressed interest in leaving the club as he searches for greater opportunities elsewhere.

Big if true

Radical if factual

Erect if correct

[Purple 77]

SYDNEY midfielder Daniel Robinson has expressed interest in leaving the club as he searches for greater opportunities elsewhere.

Big if true

Radical if factual

Erect if correct

Trade will be immaculate, if accurate.

[TomK]

SYDNEY midfielder Daniel Robinson has expressed interest in leaving the club as he searches for greater opportunities elsewhere.

Big if true

Radical if factual

Erect if correct

Trade will be immaculate, if accurate.

Large if not a facade

[meow meow]

SYDNEY midfielder Daniel Robinson has expressed interest in leaving the club as he searches for greater opportunities elsewhere.

Big if true

Radical if factual

Erect if correct

Trade will be immaculate, if accurate.

Large if not a facade

Strewth!...if truth.

[RaisyDaisy]

HS reporting Watts has picked Port

Rocky, Motlop and Watts is a pretty impressive coup for a weeks work