Off Season Trade Rumours

[Ricochet]

 

Next year's draft is better than this year's as well.

Lions would be happy with that one.

Really? Brett Anderson just said this one was deeper?

[lachie_001]

Umm, why would Carlton give their 2nd round pick and Softie to Adelaide to get a slightly worse 2nd round pick which they will then trade to GWS? That makes 0 sense.

Carlton are essentially getting
Marchbank, 15 for Softie, 25
Pickett for 45 and 58
That's fair value

[JBs-Hawks]

Umm, why would Carlton give their 2nd round pick and Softie to Adelaide to get a slightly worse 2nd round pick which they will then trade to GWS? That makes 0 sense.

Carlton are essentially getting
Marchbank for Softie
Pickett for 45 and 58
And upgrade 25 to 15?
That's fair value

Bryce > Marchbank + Pickett + pick upgrade

[lachie_001]

Umm, why would Carlton give their 2nd round pick and Softie to Adelaide to get a slightly worse 2nd round pick which they will then trade to GWS? That makes 0 sense.

Carlton are essentially getting
Marchbank for Softie
Pickett for 45 and 58
And upgrade 25 to 15?
That's fair value

Bryce > Marchbank + Pickett + pick upgrade

Hahahahah no he's not, Marchbank (pick 6) and Pickett (Pick 4) have only been in the AFL for two season. Not every 20 year old can have the same impact as the Bont in two seasons. Not to mention Gibbs is 28..

[Mat0369]

And there is no reason for 25 to head to head to Adelaide when we can keep it and get the same result.

[Mat0369]

Bryce > Marchbank + Pickett + pick upgrade

and this. Adelaide are dreaming if they think Carlton will trade them Gibbs for a mid round first and a downgraded 2nd round pick.

[RaisyDaisy]

Marchbank is getting rated so highly. Worth a 16-25 pick imo

Hasn't been able to break into GWS

Plowman went at 3, and we're seeing how average he is. And when I say average I'm referring to being a top 3 pick so I can't see how marchbank is worth more

[lachie_001]

Just heard on radio from scoop that Gibbs trade might go down tomorrow:

Gibbs + 25 for 13 + 2017 1st Round Pick

If true definetely feels like overs for Gibbs

[RaisyDaisy]

My Point: Just because a player is a high pick from previous years doesn't mean they're still worth the same now

5 for Marchbank which has what been mainly floated seems insane. Add Pickett and it's getting fairer, but even then I'd back this year's 5 to be better than both of them

[PowerBug]

If Port Adelaide make another dodgy trade I'm logging out without saving and I haven't saved this RL football game since 2014 ended so real life will revert to when everything was good then :D

[RaisyDaisy]

Just heard on radio from scoop that Softie trade might go down tomorrow:

Softie + 25 for 13 + 2017 1st Round Pick

If true definetely feels like overs for Softie

Might be overs, but in 12 months time your mob could quite easily get a 1st rounder from another club

12 months is a long time

Gibbs and a second rounder is solid for you guys

[kilbluff1985]

yeah i think thats a good deal for both clubs

[RaisyDaisy]

Look at it like this

13 + 13 (possibly higher) for Gibbs + 25

Good for both clubs imo

[TomK]

If Port Adelaide make another dodgy trade I'm logging out without saving and I haven't saved this RL football game since 2014 ended so real life will revert to when everything was good then :D

You re-signed Tom Jonas for 3 years, that's just as bad as another dodgy trade ;D

[Mat0369]

My Point: Just because a player is a high pick from previous years doesn't mean they're still worth the same now

5 for Marchbank which has what been mainly floated seems insane. Add Pickett and it's getting fairer, but even then I'd back this year's 5 to be better than both of them

If Carlton were dealing 5 they would be getting the GWS pick late in the first as part of the return. To be fair to Marchbank injuries are probably the only reason he isn't playing for them. Like you said with Plowman, these guys are often injured and unproven. Plowman has been really solid for us so I have been really happy with him at the Blues.

Carlton would probably ask for another player like Grigg and late pick upgrade in that deal if it was to go through. SOS is adamant thatnhe wants a player.