Off Season Trade Rumours

[Grazz]

Sam Landsberger ‏@SamLandsberger  3m3 minutes ago
Essendon has REJECTED St Kilda's offer for Jake Carlisle. Advantage Hawthorn.

flower em then. Ruin Essendon's day and go for Talia, Saints.

I Have no doubt Dodoro wants that pick 5 but gaining two 1st round picks from the Hawks is just about breakeven on pick 5 i reckon. Bombers not loosing alot if anything, certainly won't ruin their day. ;)

[Jukes]

If you're not willing to pay what he's worth you can get flowered saints, good luck never winning another premiership.

Hopefully can get this sorted with the hawks soon

[Pkbaldy]

If you're not willing to pay what he's worth you can get flowered saints, good luck never winning another premiership.

Hopefully can get this sorted with the hawks soon

Classic Dons. Well apparently Jake and his manager were happy with the deal. Hence why St Kilda sent it. Clearly spastic Dumdoro is just being a stubborn cow.

And a Dons supporter isn't exactly in the position to diss premiership hopes. They're pretty damn far behind the 8 ball themselves.

[iZander]

If you're not willing to pay what he's worth you can get flowered saints, good luck never winning another premiership.

Hopefully can get this sorted with the hawks soon

Classic Dons. Well apparently Jake and his manager were happy with the deal. Hence why St Kilda sent it. Clearly spastic Dumdoro is just being a stubborn cow.

If the offer doesn't beat the one from Hawks then why would they accept it...Im assuming it didn't beat that

[Pkbaldy]

If you're not willing to pay what he's worth you can get flowered saints, good luck never winning another premiership.

Hopefully can get this sorted with the hawks soon

Classic Dons. Well apparently Jake and his manager were happy with the deal. Hence why St Kilda sent it. Clearly spastic Dumdoro is just being a stubborn cow.

If the offer doesn't beat the one from Hawks then why would they accept it...Im assuming it didn't beat that

Well clearly it would of been on-par with the Hawks deal. Otherwise it would be been pointless for Bains to of send it. Probably included Players or switch of picks.

[Grazz]

If you're not willing to pay what he's worth you can get flowered saints, good luck never winning another premiership.

Hopefully can get this sorted with the hawks soon

Pick 5 is overs for him but if they want him then hand it over.

[Jukes]

If you're not willing to pay what he's worth you can get flowered saints, good luck never winning another premiership.

Hopefully can get this sorted with the hawks soon

Classic Dons. Well apparently Jake and his manager were happy with the deal. Hence why St Kilda sent it. Clearly spastic Dumdoro is just being a stubborn cow.

I believe that a list manager's job is to IMPROVE the list, not take bullshower lowball offers for players when another team has tabled a good offer.

If you're not willing to pay what he's worth you can get flowered saints, good luck never winning another premiership.

Hopefully can get this sorted with the hawks soon

Pick 5 is overs for him but if they want him then hand it over.

Already developed key backman who can go forward, was borderline-AA when playing down back, only 24...I'd give up pick 4 for that for sure.

[Ringo]

For those that have not yet seen the points value for picks here it is:

http://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-premiership/afl-draft-how-fatherson-and-academy-draft-picks-will-work-in-2015-full-draft-value-index/story-e6frf3e3-1227567743520

This is why Brisbane would be chasing picks and why Grazz point that 2 first round picks are better than 5th pick.  So say picks 13 and 18 are worth 2197 points compared to pick 5 1878.  So just accept it and then maybe trade the picks to clubs chasing points.

Trade night will be interesting as say Keays is rated pick 12 and Hipwood 16 as per some phantom drafts brisbane will have to give up some 2335 points. So you can see why Brisbane will be chasing draft picks.

[Toga]

And also why Brisbane is looking to trade future picks for guys like Jansen and Brown ;)

[Pkbaldy]

All Dodoro does is throw out bullshower offers. No doubt we wouldn't have bothered making an offer if it wasnt suitable. But go ahead, Kangas n Essendon can help out the favourite side to another flag. Surely they wont forget you in the victory speech.

[Ricochet]

But hey, he made Melbourne give 25 for Melksham... maybe he is actually a magician?

[iZander]

But hey, he made Melbourne give 25 for Melksham... maybe he is actually a magician?

lol, first plausible explanation I've heard for how that happened ;)

[Pkbaldy]

But hey, he made Melbourne give 25 for Melksham... maybe he is actually a magician?

Melk browlow chance for sure.

[Grazz]

If you're not willing to pay what he's worth you can get flowered saints, good luck never winning another premiership.

Hopefully can get this sorted with the hawks soon

Classic Dons. Well apparently Jake and his manager were happy with the deal. Hence why St Kilda sent it. Clearly spastic Dumdoro is just being a stubborn cow.

I believe that a list manager's job is to IMPROVE the list, not take bullshower lowball offers for players when another team has tabled a good offer.

If you're not willing to pay what he's worth you can get flowered saints, good luck never winning another premiership.

Hopefully can get this sorted with the hawks soon

Pick 5 is overs for him but if they want him then hand it over.

Already developed key backman who can go forward, was borderline-AA when playing down back, only 24...I'd give up pick 4 for that for sure.

Think you're over rating him a little there.
Saint will be paying overs for him with Pick 5 and Hawthorn will be to with two first rounders but the difference with the Hawks is they don't mess about if they want a player they are prepared to pay overs to just get it done. Now Hawks have thrown those picks in the ring Saints need to ask how far over is pick 5 now the Hawks are in the hunt if the Saints really want him that bad.

[Ricochet]

Saints Offer

Carlisle + N23 + n25
for
N5