Who to replace Bartel for rest of season and trade 2??

[Dave085]

OK so Bartel out changes trade plans... So who replaces him for the rest of the season?? Narrowed it down to Malceski or Mitchell but who to trade for the second trade.

Option 1 - Bartel to Malceski, Minson to Sandi
Option 2 - Bartel to Malceski, Stanton to JPK 
Option 3 - Bartel to Malceski, Dahlhaus to Zaharakis
Option 4 - Bartel to Mitchell, Stanton to JPK
Option 5 - Bartel to Mitchell, Dahlhaus to Jack


Def - McVeigh, Hanley, Bartel, Swallow, Dal Santo, Simpson
Mids - Rockliff, Barlow, Beams, Priddis, J. Selwood, Cotchin, N. Jones, Stanton
Ruck - Minson, Martin
Fwds - Harvey, Parker, Martin, Dangerfield, Dahlhaus, Gray   - Emerg - Kersten

[jvalles69]

I don't like Mitchell against Freo this week, will get Crowley for sure.  I've had to bring in Jaensch for Bartel this week due to using the extra money in the forward line but happy with that as he's picked his numbers up again.

Dahlhaus is prob the weakest link as Stanton could be better now with Jobe back and fly under the rader picking up cheap possies.  Dahlhaus to Jack or Buddy.

[Dave085]

Trading Bartel and Dahlhaus with the money in the bank I have a maximum of $955403 which means that im going to have to compromise on one of the trades.

Best option so far is probably 3 unless I take a punt on a lower priced defender like Jaensch/Kelly/Burgoyne/Duffield?
Agree with you regarding Mitchell, will probably be tagged out. Of note though - He tagged Mitchell early in round 3. Looking at the match report he didn't have a good one and played a different role. How likely is Mitchell to break the tag this time around?

[jvalles69]

Trading Bartel and Dahlhaus with the money in the bank I have a maximum of $955403 which means that im going to have to compromise on one of the trades.

Best option so far is probably 3 unless I take a punt on a lower priced defender like Jaensch/Kelly/Burgoyne/Duffield?
Agree with you regarding Mitchell, will probably be tagged out. Of note though - He tagged Mitchell early in round 3. Looking at the match report he didn't have a good one and played a different role. How likely is Mitchell to break the tag this time around?

With Stevie J and Bartel out this week Kelly will have a very decent score, but the problem is when those guys come back next week.  I already regret bringing in Mitchell a few weeks ago, late out and tagged out of games...

[pommyadam]

Looking at the match report he didn't have a good one and played a different role. How likely is Mitchell to break the tag this time around?

He was originally tagging Smitchell, then Freo got belted in the first half and Crowley did his own thing in the second (Smitchell 45 in first half, then 76 in the second)

[Dave085]

So he was still looking at a respectable score I guess. Nothing less than what I could expect from the others...