Main Menu

WXV Trade Talk

Started by Ricochet, August 12, 2014, 11:23:10 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Boomz

Quote from: upthemaidens on November 14, 2014, 07:53:02 PM
  Just renegotiate the deal,  It's really not that hard.  ::) 


Nige

The renaming of this thread hahahahaha.  ;D

kilbluff1985


JBs-Hawks

Quote from: Holz on November 14, 2014, 08:00:32 PM
Quote from: meow meow on November 14, 2014, 07:39:38 PM
Rockliff has played every game of the season once, so if you're going to bring that up you also have to mention that he averaged 97.1 that year.

Now you can see why it's not a bad trade at all.

CHECK flowerING MATE

barely check mate.

he played 18/22 last year.

Rocky + Scully 132 * 18 + 4 * 80 = 122.55
Gibbs 106*22 = 106

lets add in captaincy and drop Rocky to 120

Rocky + Scully + 90 captain    240*18 + 110*4 + 80*4 = 230.9
Gibbs 212*22 = 212

bishop to E6 Check

Thats only half of the trade though....

Holz

Quote from: JBs-Hawks on November 14, 2014, 08:11:05 PM
Quote from: Holz on November 14, 2014, 08:00:32 PM
Quote from: meow meow on November 14, 2014, 07:39:38 PM
Rockliff has played every game of the season once, so if you're going to bring that up you also have to mention that he averaged 97.1 that year.

Now you can see why it's not a bad trade at all.

CHECK flowerING MATE

barely check mate.

he played 18/22 last year.

Rocky + Scully 132 * 18 + 4 * 80 = 122.55
Gibbs 106*22 = 106

lets add in captaincy and drop Rocky to 120

Rocky + Scully + 90 captain    240*18 + 110*4 + 80*4 = 230.9
Gibbs 212*22 = 212

bishop to E6 Check

Thats only half of the trade though....

I already stated why Gilbert is equal or better than Sandi.

Holz

Meow should do a review of my trade and see whether it should pass or fail.

Toga

Gilbert is not equal or better than Sandi

Vinny


meow meow

Quote from: Holz on November 14, 2014, 08:31:58 PM
Quote from: JBs-Hawks on November 14, 2014, 08:11:05 PM
Quote from: Holz on November 14, 2014, 08:00:32 PM
Quote from: meow meow on November 14, 2014, 07:39:38 PM
Rockliff has played every game of the season once, so if you're going to bring that up you also have to mention that he averaged 97.1 that year.

Now you can see why it's not a bad trade at all.

CHECK flowerING MATE

barely check mate.

he played 18/22 last year.

Rocky + Scully 132 * 18 + 4 * 80 = 122.55
Gibbs 106*22 = 106

lets add in captaincy and drop Rocky to 120

Rocky + Scully + 90 captain    240*18 + 110*4 + 80*4 = 230.9
Gibbs 212*22 = 212

bishop to E6 Check

Thats only half of the trade though....

I already stated why Gilbert is equal or better than Sandi.

Hands up if you think Gilbert is better than/equal to Sandilands? Oh look Holz, you're the only one with your hand raised.

Rocky (240) + 90 VC + Gilbert 70 = 400 for 18 weeks
90 VC (180) + Scully 80 + Gilbert 70 = 330 for 4 weeks
8520/22 weeks = 388 ppg

Sandi (216) + Gibbs (106) + 90 not VC anymore (90) = 412

412 vs 388 is a win.
24 ppg improvement.
Let's put that into perspective. You gave up pick #12 for a 9 point improvement in your best XV when you traded Boak for Sloane.

Not really worthy of being called one of the top 3 worst trades ever.

Nige


Jukes

Sandi has 1-2 years left. Gilbert has, what, 3-4 maybe? More? Lower scoring but both could have injury issues.

It depends how you look at it imo, one will be better/most useful to one team as the other will to another team.

elephants

I'd like this to be referred to as the Gilbert trade from now on.

Grazz

Nope thread nothing like the movie.  :(

kilbluff1985


Nige

What if Holz and meow are actually Bill and Ted?