WXV Trade Talk

[Toga]

Opinion again.

[Holz]

ok one of these trades is wrong than

Rocky + Green gets Boak + Gunston

than Rocky + Gilbert gets Gibbs + Sandi


I rate Boak above Gibbs as proven 105+ scorer. But lets say even (even though they are not)

Gunston + Gilbert = Sandi + Green?

Im not sure about ytou but I rate 23 year old 90 average forwards over 32 year old rucks.

[Nige]

Opinion again.

[Holz]

everyone should use their own opinion.

if people legit feel this is a faiir trade on their opinion than the system is flawed.

[Torpedo10]

Imagine a world where Rockliff stayed in New Delhi.

:'(


New Delhi Gives: Picks 8, 45, and Tom Rockliff
New Delhi Receives: Pick 7, Leigh Montagna, Clinton Young and Lee Spurr

I cri evrytiem

[Toga]

:-X

[Holz]

Imagine a world where Rockliff stayed in New Delhi.

:'(


New Delhi Gives: Picks 8, 45, and Tom Rockliff
New Delhi Receives: Pick 7, Leigh Montagna, Clinton Young and Lee Spurr

I cri evrytiem

I rejected it last time and kept saying how bad it was.

next year people will do the same thing when this joke is let through and go how could this have happend.

[Torpedo10]

:-X

I voiced my opinion  Fisher made his own choice. I was an assistant, how did I have any say over the decision?

[Toga]

Torp bud settle petal i wasn't talking about you. :)

Opinions... Opions everywhere!

[Vinny]

I rate Boak above Gibbs as proven 105+ scorer. But lets say even (even though they are not)

For the millionth time man, Gibbs only has one year of 105 because this is his first year in the midfield full time. Those years of 95 were in defence which was elite there. Boak has been playing there most of his career.

How can you rate one above the other? That's complete opinion.

I agree the system is flawed but in saying that. This trade isn't dead even but hardly bad enough to neg.

[Holz]

the opinion thing is rubbish,

people rejected Bennell on opinion.

the difference is im correct.

[meow meow]

next year people will do the same thing when this joke is let through and go how could this have happend.

Calm down Holz, I don't think I am going to win it by that much ;)

[Toga]

I think meow's reasoning is pretty sound tbh - Holz, I think you need to consider that Gibbs has a very good chance of getting better, rather than just saying it's not gonna happen... Very opinionated debate.

[Holz]

I think meow's reasoning is pretty sound tbh - Holz, I think you need to consider that Gibbs has a very good chance of getting better, rather than just saying it's not gonna happen... Very opinionated debate.

Rocky has a very good chance of keeping up his average, his seoncd half of the year was 140. last year when playing mids he went like 130 in the second half. those are numbers not opinion.

he used opinion, i used fact than opinion

[AaronKirk]

I rate Boak above Gibbs as proven 105+ scorer. But lets say even (even though they are not)

For the millionth time man, Gibbs only has one year of 105 because this is his first year in the midfield full time. Those years of 95 were in defence which was elite there. Boak has been playing there most of his career.

How can you rate one above the other? That's complete opinion.

I agree the system is flawed but in saying that. This trade isn't dead even but hardly bad enough to neg.

So how did this one pass and our trade fail (we passed all trades bar the fake one for the record)?

If Meow can assume that Rocky will score less with the new mids coming to Brisbane (which I agree with) why can't we assume that Libba will drop now that Griffen has left and will very likely cop a tag every week which he has never had to deal with.

How do we know that Bennell will get DPP next season? We cannot. We need to work on the assumption he will not and see what is best to improve our list- which IMO we did.

Its not a risky trade one way or the other- I won't mind if we cannot get a workable deal because we get to keep Libba and Bennell but Boak and Gunston are better structually,

anyway.