WXV Trade Talk

[Vinny]

Ok guys, the votes are in! Thanks all.

Not going to announce them just yet, need some time to process them. Patience....

4 hours later. Sorry I'm trying to be patient hahaha. :P

[Hellopplz]

I reckon they'll be up sometime tomorrow or the day after. I'll just check up after my exam tomorrow and hope my trades pass as it's the ray of light for my day :P.

[Nige]

I reckon they'll be up sometime tomorrow or the day after. I'll just check up after my exam tomorrow and hope my trades pass as it's the ray of light for my day :P.

[ossie85]

Thanks guys... For all the rejected trades, you have a week from this post to renegotiate.

Trade 110
Christchurch trade: Jack Gunston and Travis Boak
Dublin trade: Josh Green and Tom Rockliff
Votes Against: 2
Coach Comments: Mixed feelings from the 2 coaches here
Admin Comments: Feel Rockliff > Boak, and Green < Gunston so no real issue
Final result: PASSED


Trade 111
Toronto trade: Jack Riewoldt + Nat Pick 62
Rio trade: Isaac Smith + Jack Crisp + Nat Pick 74
Votes Against: 1
Coach Comments: Believe JROOs value being overstated, Crisp values understated
Admin Comments: Interesting, but think fair trade
Final result: PASSED

Trade 112
New York give: Koby Stevens
NDT give: Dylan Buckley
Votes Against: 0
Coach Comments: 0
Admin Comments: 0
Final result: PASSED

Trade 113
Rio give: Rory Thompson + Nat 10
Cairo give: Andrew Mackie
Votes Against: 4
Coach Comments: Believe that too much is being paid for Mackie, an older defender with limited scoring power
Admin Comments: Ive ummed and arred about this one. Basically Pick 10 was traded for McKenzie earlier (ish), and Mackie was basically swapped for Giles. So does Rory Thompson + Trent McKenzie for Jon Giles make sense? Just. But in the end swapping 2 young players for an older one. Sorry guys, think Cairo need to add a bit more ( a draft pick or something).
Final result: REJECTED

Trade 114
Cairo trade: J.Clarke & T.Chaplin
Dildos trade: N38
Votes Against: 2
Coach Comments: Feel that N38 isnt enough for both of them
Admin Comments: Glad this one didnt come to me, feel it was borderline
Final result: PASSED

Trade 115
NDT gives: Nat 5 + Nat 45, Nat 47 and Nat 57
Cape Town gives: Nat 4 + Nat 54 + Nat 59 + Nat 88
Votes Against: 1
Coach Comments: Feels Cape Town winning too much
Admin Comments: If this has come to me, I would have rejected it. New Delhi move up one spot in the draft (From 5 to 4, which is admittedly valuable) while Cape Town move up a whopping combined 54 spots in the draft. But the coaches have spoken!
Final result: PASSED

Trade 116
Rio Give: N.Graham + B.Newton + N.Foley + R.Nahas
Dildos Give: K.Cornes + D.Hale
Votes Against: 2
Coach Comments: Question the Spuds being worth the Oldies
Admin Comments: Interesting again, but not real issue
Final result: PASSED

Trade 117
Mexico City give: George Hewett + Pick 37
Tokyo give: Jesse Lonergan
Votes Against: 0
Coach Comments: 0
Admin Comments: 0
Final result: PASSED

Trade 118
Tokyo Trade: Pick 37
Pacific Trade: Harry Cunningham
Votes Against: 0
Coach Comments: 0
Admin Comments: Thought this might get a vote or 2, no issue from me
Final result: PASSED

Trade 119
PNL Trade: #81 Nat
Berlin Trade: #84 Nat + #9 PSD
Votes Against: 0
Coach Comments: 0
Admin Comments: 0
Final result: PASSED

Trade 120
Mexico City give: Zak Jones
Berlin give: Leigh Montagna
Votes Against: 2
Coach Comments: Feel that Montagna worth a lot more
Admin Comments: Glad this didnt come to me, wouldve been a hard decision
Final result: PASSED

Trade 121
Mexico City give: Aaron Sandilands and Bryce Gibbs
Christchurch give: Tom Rockliff and Sam Gilbert
Votes Against: 5
Coach Comments: 3 coaches feel Christchurch win too much, 2 coaches feel Mexico City win too much.
Admin Comments: Eck. A hard decision. First of all how come Rockliff bounces around every team every trade period?? I dont understand. Anyways. A lot of concern over whether Sandilands is worth more than Gilbert. And Rockliff has to be worth more than Gibbs. Sorry, cant for this one.
Final result: REJECTED

Trade 122
New York give: Will Hoskin-Elliott and Pick 42
London give: Ben Lennon and Pick 11
Votes Against: 2
Coach Comments: Still dont think the trade is fair, even with pick 42
Admin Comments: Still questionable, but not my decision
Final result: PASSED

Trade 123
New York give: Tom Liberatore and Harley Bennell
Dublin give: Travis Boak and Jack Gunston
Votes Against: 7
Coach Comments: Feel that Libba and Harley are younger and average more than counterparts, and that assumptions over long term positions shouldnt carry as much weight.
Admin Comments: Agree with the coaches
Final result: REJECTED

Trade 124
Berlin trade: Relton Roberts
Pacific trade: Wayne Carey
Fake trade to see if people paying attention, please reject!
Votes Against: 17
Coach Comments: Mixed feelings here!
Admin Comments: All but ONE coach rejected this trade! That one coach is a genius.
Final result: REJECTED

Trade 125
Pacific give: pick 55
Seoul give: Joel Hamling
Votes Against: 0
Coach Comments: 0
Admin Comments: 0
Final result: PASSED

Trade 126
PNL Trade: #15 + Liam Jones + Tyson Goldsack + Xavier Richards
Dillos Trade: Dane Swan + #58
Votes Against: 1
Coach Comments: Still think Swan is worth more
Admin Comments: Finally! Swan, the original #2 pick, off loaded!
Final result: PASSED

Trade 127
Seoul give: Darley + N64
NDT give: N48
Votes Against: 0
Coach Comments: 0
Admin Comments: 0
Final result: PASSED

Trade 128
Tokyo trade: Luke Shuey and Ben Reid
Christchurch trade: Chris Yarran and Shaun Burgoyne
Votes Against: 2
Coach Comments: Feel Yarrans worth being understated
Admin Comments: Lots of ifs, buts and coconuts in this one
Final result: PASSED

Trade 129
NDT Trade: N64
Tokyo Trade: Will Hams + N79
Votes Against: 0
Coach Comments: 0
Admin Comments: 0
Final result: PASSED

Trade 130
NDT give: Tom Bell
Beijing give: N39 + Tim OBrien
Votes Against: 0
Coach Comments: 0
Admin Comments: 0
Final result: PASSED

Trade 131
Christchurch give: N27
Beijing give: Clay Smith
Votes Against: 0
Coach Comments: 0
Admin Comments: 0
Final result: PASSED

Trade 132
NDT give: N39 + N88
Tokyo give: Seb Ross
Votes Against: 0
Coach Comments: 0
Admin Comments: 0
Final result: PASSED

Trade 133
Mexico City give: Matthew Pavlich, James Kelly, Brendon Ah Chee + Pick 83
Toronto give: Michael Johnson, Mark Whiley + Picks 32, 74
Votes Against: 2
Coach Comments: 1 coach feel Mexico City winning too much, one thinking Toronto winning too much
Admin Comments: Intriguing
Final result: PASSED

Trade 134
Mexico City give: Luke Hodge, Craig Moller + Pick 32
PNL give: Kade Simpson, John Butcher + Pick 87
Votes Against: 1
Coach Comments: Simpson not being valued enough
Admin Comments: Meh
Final result: PASSED

Trade 135
Berlin trade: Jason Tutt, Nathan Wilson + Pick 81
Buenos Aires trade: Daniel Cross
Votes Against: 0
Coach Comments: 0
Admin Comments: *rolls eyes*
Final result: PASSED

Trade 136
TORONTO give: T.Jonas
BEIJING give: K.Mitchell + H.Schade + A.Toovey + N82
Votes Against: 1
Coach Comments: Toronto winning too much
Admin Comments: Surprised this didnt get more heat
Final result: PASSED

Trade 137
Beijing give: Elliot Yeo + Robbie Tarrant + Max Duffy
Rio de Janeiro give: Jared Polec
Votes Against: 4
Coach Comments: 3 coaches feel Yeo worth more than this, 1 coach feeling Polec worth more
Admin Comments: Tarrant and Duffy big unknowns and Im willing to let doubt over Yeo v Polec rule.. so..
Final result: PASSED

Trade 138
New Delhi: N70
Buenos Aires: Simon Tunbridge
Votes Against: 0
Coach Comments: 0
Admin Comments: 0
Final result: PASSED

Trade 139
Tokyo Trade: Trent West
Cape Town Trade: Pick 45
Votes Against: 0
Coach Comments: 0
Admin Comments: Thought West might get a bit of love1
Final result: PASSED

Trade 140
New York Trade: Pick 44 + Pick 72
Tokyo Trade: Brodie Murdoch
Votes Against: 0
Coach Comments: 0
Admin Comments: 0
Final result: PASSED

Trade 141
Toronto give: Goose Maguire
Christchurch give: picks 63 & 66
Votes Against: 0
Coach Comments: 0
Admin Comments: 0
Final result: PASSED

Trade 142
Moscow Give: Zachary Clarke
NDT Give: Clancee Pearce and Ryan Bastinac
Votes Against: 2
Coach Comments: Questioning over Clarke, Pearce and Bastinacs worth!
Admin Comments: Seems fine
Final result: PASSED

Trade 143
Cairo give: Matt White + 85
New York give: Nick Kommer + 53
Votes Against: 1
Coach Comments: White worth a lot more
Admin Comments: No opinion
Final result: PASSED

Trade 144
New Delhi give: N59 + N79
Toronto gives: Jesse White
Votes Against: 1
Coach Comments: White worth more
Admin Comments: Fine with me
Final result: PASSED

Trade 145
Mexico trade: Lindsay Thomas, Sam Gilbert, Sam Siggins, John Butcher
Dillos trade: Drew Petrie, Darcy Byrne-Jones
Votes Against: 3
Coach Comments: 2 for Buenos Aires, One for Mexico City
Admin Comments: Probably wouldve have let through but as Trade 121 rejected, so is this.
Final result: REJECTED

Trade 146
Dildos trade: P.Chapman
Rio trade: J.Neade + R.Bewick + 41
Votes Against: 2
Coach Comments: Chapman not worth this much
Admin Comments: Does seem a bit overkill, but not my decision
Final result: PASSED

Trade 147
Mexico Trade: Mark Whiley + Leigh Montagna
NY Trade: Ben Lennon + Mathew Stokes
Votes Against: 3
Coach Comments: Feel Mexico City winning too much, with Lennon > Whiley and Stokes > Montagna
Admin Comments: Begrudgingly let through, not hugely sure on the logic though. All comes down to Whiley and Lennon, who at this stage are unknown
Final result: PASSED

Trade 148
Tokyo Trade Golds
PNL Trades pick 84
Votes Against: 0
Coach Comments: 0
Admin Comments: 0
Final result: PASSED

Trade 149
Cape town gives: Nat 52.
Cairo: Karpany + H Marsh
Votes Against: 0
Coach Comments: 0
Admin Comments: 0
Final result: PASSED

[GoLions]

Cmon JROO, you just have to BELIEVE

[Ricochet]

Cmon JROO, you just have to BELIEVE

hahahaha

[kilbluff1985]

yeah JROO you need to BOLEIVE!!!

[ossie85]

God I hate this bug.

Now up

[Boomz]

Cheers os.

[Ricochet]

flower yeh. Thanks for the trade period lads (and of course your work Os), its been a big one for us.

[Jroo]

Haha I got no idea what's going on. (That's directed at GL and co., not to Oz)


Ok, so three coaches (well 2 + Oz) think I win, but three think I lose.

So who needs to add stuff to their side to make it fair haha.

Also, Oz surely Sandi is worth quite a bit more than Gilbert  ???

Even if Sandi is injury prone, when he plays he's a star, Gilbert has shown nothing in the past couple of years.

[kilbluff1985]

i got NFI why Rocky cant find a permanent team either Ossie no way i would trade him

[RaisyDaisy]

Trade 123
New York give: Tom Liberatore and Harley Bennell
Dublin give: Travis Boak and Jack Gunston
Votes Against: 7
Coach Comments: Feel that Libba and Harley are younger and average more than counterparts, and that assumptions over long term positions shouldnt carry as much weight.
Admin Comments: Agree with the coaches
Final result: REJECTED

Assumptions over long terms positions shouldn't carry much weight? Gunston is a 100% forward, and we only give up 10ppg in this trade for that security. As for ages, It's only Boak who is older out of the 4, and 26 is entering his absolute prime!

[kilbluff1985]

Haha I got no idea what's going on.

the copy and paste bug was in affect with one of the trades and one of the coaches comments was just 'Believe JROO'

[Jroo]

Haha I got no idea what's going on.

the copy and paste bug was in affect with one of the trades and one of the coaches comments was just 'Believe JROO'

Oh hahah, I just missed it.