WXV Trade Talk

[kilbluff1985]

Boak 105 + Gunston 90 vs Libba 110 + Bennell 95
27yrs old      24yrs old        23yrs old       23yrs old

you lose on points and age ???

[AaronKirk]

Boak 105 + Gunston 90 vs Libba 110 + Bennell 95
27yrs old      24yrs old        23yrs old       23yrs old

you lose on points and age ???

Based on last year.

Libba won't outscore Boak next year. Gunston helps with structure. Clear win for our side. 

[GoLions]

I have no problems with the trade, just think it's high risk for low reward

[nrich102]

Boak 105 + Gunston 90 vs Libba 110 + Bennell 95
27yrs old      24yrs old        23yrs old       23yrs old

you lose on points and age ???

Based on last year.

Libba won't outscore Boak next year. Gunston helps with structure. Clear win for our side.

How does trading a forward for a forward and a mid for a mid help the structure?

[Torpedo10]

Boak 105 + Gunston 90 vs Libba 110 + Bennell 95
27yrs old      24yrs old        23yrs old       23yrs old

you lose on points and age ???

Based on last year.

Libba won't outscore Boak next year. Gunston helps with structure. Clear win for our side.

How does trading a forward for a forward and a mid for a mid help the structure?

You honestly think Bennell will stay a Forward? No issues from me.

[nrich102]

Boak 105 + Gunston 90 vs Libba 110 + Bennell 95
27yrs old      24yrs old        23yrs old       23yrs old

you lose on points and age ???

Based on last year.

Libba won't outscore Boak next year. Gunston helps with structure. Clear win for our side.

How does trading a forward for a forward and a mid for a mid help the structure?

You honestly think Bennell will stay a Forward? No issues from me.

Do you honestly think Benell will lose it?

Bennell plays most his time as a forward, lets make him pure defender  ???

[Nige]

I see Boak outscoring Libba next year now that Libba is going to get tagged every week.

Macrae will be first tagged.

[JBs-Hawks]

Trade is fine. Holz wins slightly but not dramatically

[Torpedo10]

Boak 105 + Gunston 90 vs Libba 110 + Bennell 95
27yrs old      24yrs old        23yrs old       23yrs old

you lose on points and age ???

Based on last year.

Libba won't outscore Boak next year. Gunston helps with structure. Clear win for our side.

How does trading a forward for a forward and a mid for a mid help the structure?

You honestly think Bennell will stay a Forward? No issues from me.

Do you honestly think Benell will lose it?

Bennell plays most his time as a forward, lets make him pure defender  ???

Which idiot said he should be made pure defender? I (and many others) believe he will be pure Mid within 3 seasons.

[Toga]

Lol what are you guys even arguing about?

Think the trade is ok, Holz is building a young powerhouse side, going to be very scary for a long time!

[Jroo]

Libba > Boak
Bennell > Gunston

But clearly AK/RD are after Gunston as he'll be a fwd his whole career, Harley won't be.

[Nige]

Holz is building a young powerhouse side, going to be very scary for a long time!

That's exactly what this is about.

Holz has been telling me this for the past six months, his plan is basically to never bottom out by using his superior trading skillz to keep his team top of Worlds 5eva.  :P

[Vinny]

Yeah that's fine, that's the aim of the game.

Nothing wrong with the trade especially since Bennell will only be a forward for a year or two so trading him at his highest value isn't the worst idea.

[Nige]

Yeah that's fine, that's the aim of the game.

Nothing wrong with the trade especially since Bennell will only be a forward for a year or two so trading him at his highest value isn't the worst idea.

Yeah, I agree.

It's not easy, but Holz makes it seem effortless.

[Jay]

Libba > Boak
Bennell > Gunston

But clearly AK/RD are after Gunston as he'll be a fwd his whole career, Harley won't be.

Gunston > Bennell

Even trade.