WXV Trade Talk

[Holz]

WHE has shown he can play. Lennon and Pick 11 have shown nothing. Fair trade every day of the week

And he's a pick 4. Surely his value has gone up a little?
Even if it hasn't, pick 11 + 12  for pick 4 would be probably be fair, wouldn't it?

I wouldn't give up 4 for WHE though, not sure he has lived up to the 4 tag. Lennon was a pick 12 but in fantasy he should go top 7-8

[meow meow]

WHE has been playing for 3 seasons and averages 68. Pick 11 could step in and do that in year 1. Writing off a former pick 12 as being next to worthless after 1 season is kind of odd. Dane Swan played 0 games in his first season, and 3 in his second.

[Nige]

WHE has shown he can play. Lennon and Pick 11 have shown nothing. Fair trade every day of the week

And he's a pick 4. Surely his value has gone up a little?
Even if it hasn't, pick 11 + 12  for pick 4 would be probably be fair, wouldn't it?

I wouldn't give up 4 for WHE though, not sure he has lived up to the 4 tag. Lennon was a pick 12 but in fantasy he should go top 7-8

Yeah, I think long term that Beatle will be a better fantasy prospect than WHE.

Could be interesting to see who Pick 11 is in this year's draft (WXV) and how they go after a season or two. Based on the talent in this year's pool London definitely giving up too much imo anyway (and I do like and rate WHE).

[RaisyDaisy]

So what do you guys think is fair?

If we added a 3rd round pick, say Pick 42 plus WHE for 11 and Lennon, is that fair?

[Nige]

So what do you guys think is fair?

If we added a 3rd round pick, say Pick 42 plus WHE for 11 and Lennon, is that fair?

Yeah, as one of the coaches who negged it, I'd be fine with that.

[kilbluff1985]

WHE has been playing for 3 seasons and averages 68. Pick 11 could step in and do that in year 1. Writing off a former pick 12 as being next to worthless after 1 season is kind of odd. Dane Swan played 0 games in his first season, and 3 in his second.

Not everything is about stats

He has huge potential plays a lot like Fyfe and will be M/F

I would of traded LeCras for him but Jbs stopped me lol :(

[meow meow]

WHE has been playing for 3 seasons and averages 68. Pick 11 could step in and do that in year 1. Writing off a former pick 12 as being next to worthless after 1 season is kind of odd. Dane Swan played 0 games in his first season, and 3 in his second.

Not everything is about stats

He has huge potential plays a lot like Fyfe and will be M/F

I would of traded LeCras for him but Jbs stopped me lol :(

I'd say 2 first round picks have plenty of potential themselves.

So what do you guys think is fair?

If we added a 3rd round pick, say Pick 42 plus WHE for 11 and Lennon, is that fair?

I think an early 2nd rounder is fair but this is close enough to let pass.

[kilbluff1985]

WHE has cemented his spot though Lennon hasn't and neither has whoever they pick

[meow meow]

WHE has shown he can play. Lennon and Pick 11 have shown nothing. Fair trade every day of the week

Trade me all your draft picks for Tony Armstrong. He has shown he can play (twice in one day!), all your picks have shown nothing.

[Vinny]

Just cause they haven't shown anything after 1 year or in this case even no years doesn't kill their value. Not every gun plays straight away.

[Nige]

WHE has cemented his spot though Lennon hasn't and neither has whoever they pick

Lennon couldn't cement his spot in his first season because he wasn't fully AFL ready like Dunstan for example and player who hasn't even been drafted obviously can't either, but for all we know he very well could in 2015.

WHE has had three years to 'cement his spot' and didn't even do so until this season.

[meow meow]

It's easier for young players to walk into shower teams. Richmond aren't totally shower so it's harder to break into their side. WHE was handed a starting spot at GWS on a silver platter, it wasn't like he had to force established AFL players out of the side.

[kilbluff1985]

Whatever NY just unlucky to many Tigers supporters in this comp

[Nige]

Whatever NY just unlucky to many Tigers supporters in this comp

???

[Toga]

Lol kb, have already said I didn't have a problem with it ;)