WXV Trade Talk

[meow meow]

Sicily is gonna play 200 games and kick 1000 goals.  8)

Sounds like a starting forward to me.

If that's the case he should be a good bet for the vfl Coleman.

Sicily will definitely get some games next year.

You gonna argue with Mr.Craig?

[Holz]

Sicily is gonna play 200 games and kick 1000 goals.  8)

Sounds like a starting forward to me.

If that's the case he should be a good bet for the vfl Coleman.

Sicily will definitely get some games next year.

You gonna argue with Mr.Craig?

I think he will get some, that's why I chased him. Not sure he gets a lot though

[ossie85]

Sorry JR Time flies and did not realise another vote had been done.  I have voted though.

not sure you have Ringo?

[meow meow]

Kristian Jaksch 38.6 DT/ 49.2 SC

If he gets his DT up to 60 which should be pretty easy we're looking at a 74.5 average with that ratio. Contested marking machine which is great for SC. I think he'll play backline at the Blues and gobble up all the intercept marks. Might lose fwd status so I am looking to trade him for a forward, or a pick.

[Jroo]

Sorry JR Time flies and did not realise another vote had been done.  I have voted though.

not sure you have Ringo?

Is Ringo the only coach who hasn't voted, os?

[Ringo]

Wil send again now OSS.  Thought I did but do not keep out box copies

[RaisyDaisy]

So, does anyone have any forwards they are willing to trade? If so then please PM me

We are still open to the idea of trading Libba or Macrae, so shoot me offers if your interested.

[AaronKirk]

So, does anyone have any forwards they are willing to trade? If so then please PM me

We are still open to the idea of trading Libba or Macrae, so shoot me offers if your interested.

just libba, not Macrae

[ossie85]

Sorry about being quiet!

Buenos Aires and Cape Town didn't vote. If they miss next week, they'll lose a pick.



Trade 88
NDT give: Wellingham + N72
New York give: Templeton + N45

Votes against: 1

Coach comments: Feel picks lead to New Delhi winning trade by too much

Admin comments: No issue

Final result: PASSED

Trade 89
Dublin give: M.Scharenberg
Dildos give: D.Swan

Votes against: 8

Coach comments: Scharenberg has yet to prove himself and has already suffered 2 serious injuries, Swan is fading but his worth is still much more.

Admin comments: Agree with coaches

Final result:  REJECTED

Trade 90
Mexico City give: Nathan Hrovat, Sam Gilbert, Tom Curren + Pick 18
Mexico City receive: Brad Ebert, Zak Jones, Taylor Hunt + Picks 46, 86

Christchurch give: Lachie Whitfield, Zak Jones + Pick 36
Christchurch receive: Nathan Hrovat, Sam Gilbert + Pick 22

Seoul give: Brad Ebert, Taylor Hunt + Picks 22, 46, 86
Seoul receive: Lachie Whitfield, Eli Templeton + Picks 18, 36

New Delhi give: Eli Templeton
New Delhi receive: Tom Curren

Votes against: 5

Coach comments: Many reasons... here we go.... but the headlines are people feel Seoul are loosing too much, Christchurch losing, and Mexico City winning too much (but there were some inconsistent responses).

Admin comments: Gives me a headache just looking at. So here we go....

New Delhi --> Personally see this as a strange swap. Young unproven Saint midfielder for another? But whatever, no reason to reject that part of it.

Mexico City --> Brad Ebert couldn't stay away? Hrovat has potential, but it isn't a sure thing yet. Gilbert is probably done, maybe 1 year left, Curren young with some potential. Pick 18 solid. Ebert is slipping, only averaged 83 in the last 13 games last year (but 106 in the first 12). Zak Jones hasn't done anything, Taylor Hunt has limited potential, and 2 poor-ish picks. Fine.

Christchurch --> Probably the most contentious, as I think Gilbert is worth nothing, and Hrovat not proven. Whitfield is also not proven (despite being high profile though), Jones will probably struggle for a bit... Pick difference may get this by just.

Seoul --> Some people think Seoul losing too much, but one coach thought the opposite. I kind of feel that Seoul's done well here myself.

Can't find a good enough reason to reject it, and I shouldn't be looking for it either.... so...

Final result: PASSED


Trade 91
Berlin Trade: Mitch Clark
Rio Trade: Xavier Ellis + Marco Paparone

Votes against: 0

Coach comments: 0

Admin comments: This could be one of those trades that in years go by one coach looks a genius, the other a fool. Not sure which is which though.

Final result: PASSED

Trade 92
PNL Trade: Nat #51.
Cairo Trade: Jed Bews.

Votes against: 0

Coach comments: 0

Admin comments: 0

Final result: PASSED

[kilbluff1985]

pretty silly whoever said Seoul are losing to much

[Nige]

I don't know why, but I was worried our little Bews trade would get heat for some reason.  :P

[Ricochet]

New Delhi --> Personally see this as a strange swap. Young unproven Saint midfielder for another? But whatever, no reason to reject that part of it.

Curren has been a favourite of ours for a while. Currently doing a tagging apprenticeship but showed last year his scoring capabilities. Also closer to best 22 at the Saints than what Templeton is.

[Vinny]

If Swan is worth much more PM us with your offers!

[Holz]

pretty silly whoever said Seoul are losing to much

Agree here, Seoul won big in the trade.

Whitfield is a star.

[Jroo]

pretty silly whoever said Seoul are losing to much

Agree here, Seoul won big in the trade.

Whitfield is a star.

I should've traded him to you then  ::) :P