WXV Trade Talk

[Justin Bieber]

I had a mid sem worth 30% yesterday,  assignment due the day before then only got back home at 3am since also went to a ball tonight. I said I have been busy this week and been checking here on phone in between like on bus or between working. Sending messages especially pms are difficult on this phone as something shifty happens when a long one.

I said I would do it on Friday or Saturday, well within the week limit..

[Toga]

all good HP just get em in when you can 8)

[elephants]

all good HP just get em in when you can 8)

[ossie85]

Just the 2 coaches to vote.... I could make decisions now on all trades, but I'd prefer the other two coaches (Hellopplz and pothead) to vote.

Only really a couple of contentous ones this time

[Nails]

Just the 2 coaches to vote.... I could make decisions now on all trades, but I'd prefer the other two coaches (Hellopplz and pothead) to vote.

Only really a couple of contentous ones this time

can you tell me if any of mine are "contentous" please Ossie? inbox?  :-*

The one reason I wish the trade voting was a shorter time period is because I like to base my future trades off whether my previous trades passed. Makes me hold off not knowing if they went through or not, IDK what I actually have etc.

[RaisyDaisy]

So I guess we get the results today, and then this weeks trades to vote on too ? :)

[Nige]

Jarman Impey is on the table. Would like a decent defender who could be started at D3/4, happy to throw in a pick or somebody like Tory Dickson to get a deal across the line.  ;)

Chuck us a PM if you're keen.

[ossie85]

Only pothead hasn't replied, still has time though


Trade 38
Cape Town give: Dale Thomas
Berlin Brewers give: Lachie Hunter + Mitch Honeychurch + Pick 48

Votes against: 3

Coach Comments: 2 people think Berlin giving up too much, 1 thinking Cape Town giving away too much

Admin Comments: A risky strategy, and I think one side wins the trade, but not enough to reject

Final Verdict: PASSED


Trade 39
Berlin trade: Josh J Kennedy, Paul Duffield + Pick 30
New York trade: Adam Treloar + Pick 24

Votes against: 6

Coach Comments: 5 coaches think pick 24 is too much (Treloar worth about Kennedy, Duffield and 30), 1 coach think New York needs to add a first round pick.

Admin Comments: Basically 4 against (5 one way, 1 the other), I think its one rising superstar for 2 solid premiums. Happy enough.... just.

Final Verdict: PASSED


Trade 40
Berlin trade: Jack Trengove + Pick 24 (from New York)
New Delhi trade: Leigh Montagna + Will Langford

Votes against: 3

Coach Comments: Feel New Delhi are giving too much

Admin Comments: A fantastic finals series may have edged this trade in favour of Berlin, but not fair to factor that in!

Final Verdict: PASSED


Trade 41
Beijing give: Pick #5 ID + Sam Naismith + John Butcher
PNL give: Matthew Jaensch + Clay Smith + Cameron Shenton

Votes against: 2

Coach Comments: Believe PNL Is giving up too much

Admin Comments: Surprisingly uncontroversial

Final Verdict: PASSED


Trade 42
Pacific give: Dean Terlich
Mexico City give: NAT Pick #55

Votes against: 0

Coach Comments: 0

Admin Comments: 0

Final Verdict: PASSED


Trade 43
Pacific give: Jack Frost + NAT pick #49
Tokyo give: NAT pick #27

Votes against: 0

Coach Comments: 0

Admin Comments: 0

Final Verdict: PASSED


Trade 44
Moscow give: Heath Shaw, NAT Pick 28 and NAT Pick 53
New York give: David Armitage and Luke McDonald

Votes against: 0

Coach Comments: 0

Admin Comments: Finally :P

Final Verdict: PASSED


Trade 45
Mexico City give: Stewart Crameri, Brandon Jack
Cape Town give: Brad Hill, Jed Lamb

Votes against: 1

Coach Comments: Believe Hill is worth far more than Crameri, with other 2 cancelling out

Admin Comments: I agree. Brad Hill is a player with huge potential, surprised only 1 voted against it. Probably would have voted against it also.

Final Verdict: PASSED


Trade 46
New Delhi give: N42 + N78
New York give: Apeness + Sinclair

Votes against: 1

Coach Comments: Believe Apeness potential worth more than both picks

Admin Comments: Seems cheap

Final Verdict: PASSED


Trade 47
Tokyo give: Pick 49 (from Pacific)
New York give: Aaron Young & Aidan Corr

Votes against: 1

Coach Comments: Believes that pick 49 far too cheap

Admin Comments: Kinda agree!

Final Verdict: PASSED


Trade 48
Cape Town gives: Nat Pick 41
New York give: Will Schofield and Brant Colledge

Votes against: 0

Coach Comments: 0

Admin Comments: 0

Final Verdict: PASSED


Trade 49
Cairo give: N45 and N67
New York give: Matt Arnot, Arryn Siposs and Jake Batchelor

Votes against: 1

Coach Comments: Believe New York giving away far too much

Admin Comments: Again, seems a cheap price

Final Verdict: PASSED


Trade 50
Cape Town give: Matt Crouch + Patrick Karnezis
Buenos Aires give: #4 + #54

Votes against: 1

Coach Comments: Believes Crouch not worth anywhere near pick 4, and the other trade doesn't even it up at all

Admin Comments: Strange, but why not

Final Verdict: PASSED


Trade 51
Dublin Give: Pick 12 + Pick 21 + Luke Delaney + Shuan Grigg + Sam Frost + Neville Jetta + George Hewett
Dillos Give: Dane Swan + Paul Chapman

Votes against: 7

Coach Comments: Generally feel Dublin giving away too much

Admin Comments: Feel that this trade is bad for the competition.

Final Verdict: REJECTED

[Nails]

flower you all :(

[Justin Bieber]

Btw, JJK is like a 79 average forward, far from a Premium :P.

[Vinny]

How did the Treloar trade pass?

[Master Q]

If I had Treloar I wouldn't even write his name on our player list. I'd never trade him  :P

[Vinny]

Hahaha who the flower said NY needed to add a first rounder with Treloar?

[Holz]

I don't understand, I cop flack for taking out people in trades to benefit my own. I see that dillos are struggling and rather than shaft them knowing they need to let their old players go I not only make a good offer I over pay to try and make up for everyone trying to rip them off.

Not sure what to do, I win slightly and a trade gets rejected as I'm trying to exploit everyone. I lose and it gets rejected. It's pretty tough to make the perfectly even tradefor everyone.

Personally trealor for jjk duffman 30 is a robbery, let alone 24.

[Master Q]

3/7 of your trades haven't passed. You just admitted that trade you overpaid.

What world are you living in Holz?