WXV Trade Talk

[Purple 77]

you seem to be underrating Hoskin-Elliot some say he could be as good as Fyfe

Some say Zac Dawson could be as good as Fyfe if he was released into the midfield where he should be played!

Tell it preacher!

[CrowsFan]

the Burgoyne/Wallis deal was passed unopposed  (we were the team that negged it, Wallis is still not a regular at the dogs and Burgoyne is a XV starter at any team)

Don't see what you have against that deal. As ossie said it's a win win with me getting short term scoring for 1 season and nails getting long term scoring for his young approach.

[AaronKirk]

you seem to be underrating Hoskin-Elliot some say he could be as good as Fyfe

in 3 years from 39 games he has has 20+ touches twice.

in Fyfe's first 39 games he has 20+ touches 25 times.

WHE is a solid player who would not be in our best XV as a mid, we got a fair deal.

[kilbluff1985]

you seem to be underrating Hoskin-Elliot some say he could be as good as Fyfe

in 3 years from 39 games he has has 20+ touches twice.

in Fyfe's first 39 games he has 20+ touches 25 times.

WHE is a solid player who would not be in our best XV as a mid, we got a fair deal.

but he will most likely get DPP

[JBs-Hawks]

Even though I was happy with the original trade maybe if you take WHE and one of the picks out the other coaches might look more favourably on it?

[AaronKirk]

you seem to be underrating Hoskin-Elliot some say he could be as good as Fyfe

in 3 years from 39 games he has has 20+ touches twice.

in Fyfe's first 39 games he has 20+ touches 25 times.

WHE is a solid player who would not be in our best XV as a mid, we got a fair deal.

but he will most likely get DPP

Still would not be in our best XV. Not ahead of Tippett, Duncan (could well get DPP), Cloke and Walters (once we finish that deal)

[Jay]

91 average, Sam Gibson is available to anyone looking for a solid mid. The best offer come a few days from now will get his services.

Ok, go!

[Memphistopheles]

Even though I was happy with the original trade maybe if you take WHE and one of the picks out the other coaches might look more favourably on it?

This.

Remove WHE from your side and Pick 57 from the other side and it's fair imo.

[Justin Bieber]

that's why you get a trades committee ossie so people can appeal your decision if they not happy then the committee decides

I don't mind this if the committee had no affiliation with any team in Worlds.

What's wrong with the way its run now? Has been working fine. Just people complaining sometimes but that will happen no matter what the system is

This is normal though, kinda get use to it. And people complain when teams get destroyed, complain when stronger teams get stronger, yet when they are negged to stop this, people complain. Just no winners.

On the plus side, PNL fairly solid with the cap issues. Still got some depth we can shop but plenty of time for that when people start looking for fillers later in the period to slot into some gaps :).

[Jroo]

Looking for some late picks.
Willing to give up these spuds:
Daniel Pearce
James Strauss
Josh Prudden
Tim McGenniss
Brent Moloney  :P
Dylan Addison
Cameron Hitchcock
Daniel Merrett

[Holz]

Even though I was happy with the original trade maybe if you take WHE and one of the picks out the other coaches might look more favourably on it?

This.

Remove WHE from your side and Pick 57 from the other side and it's fair imo.

I dont think its fair at all.

With how highly people are rating bennell i think people should start offering up their best player for him.

[Nige]

At the end of the 2015 season, I think we should ban trading.  :P

[Boomz]

What did I miss?  :P

[AaronKirk]

After long discussions with Dublin we cannot work out a revised deal which suits both sides.

Bennell and WHE on the table for trade.

You think they are worth more than we were going to get than put your money where your mouth is  :-X

Message RD if you are interested

Looking for  90+ average forwards and  a 90+ average defender.

[nrich102]

Bennell will probably be a forward next year   ???