WXV Trade Talk

[Nige]

Soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo.

Why don't we all just trade with Cairo then? Our trades always go through.

#NoCairoNoTrade

[kilbluff1985]

and the Gibbs trade is funny cause some people thought Seoul was laughing all the way to the bank with that one and so did we

[elephants]

So much bants!

[Holz]

sorry RD but i think the Bennell and Hoskin-Elliot trade was right to get rejected

both will be forwards you could have gotten much more

Bennell will be a mid long term. New York is doing a good job and having a long term plan while also picking up a premium forward next year. This isnt a 1 year comp

a premium forward?

Walters averaged 78 and Green averaged 66

so who is the premium forward?

If people value walters as a 78 forward to be honest they shouldnt be allowed to vote. Do abit of research and see if he is worth a 78 forward.

this is why Mckenzie trade got passed. This was the worst trade for the worlds this year and probably one of the worst trades I have seen in any XV comp I have played in 3 years.

[Nige]

So much bants!

This is pretty much how you know it's the off-season.  8)

[Memphistopheles]

People negging nothing trades is a flowering joke.

This is what I have an issue with too.

Fair enough if you have a valid reason to neg a trade but because it's a 'nothing trade' is ridiculous.

[kilbluff1985]

yeah well the Bennell one is one of the worst i have seen

[Toga]

So much bants!

[Holz]

yeah well the Bennell one is one of the worst i have seen

would love a logical and statics based reason for that.

because I can mount a very strong case that I overpaid.

[Toga]

So much bants!

[Vinny]

People negging nothing trades is a flowering joke.

This is what I have an issue with too.

Fair enough if you have a valid reason to neg a trade but because it's a 'nothing trade' is ridiculous.

Mm, nothing wrong with the system, people just seem to be abusing it.

"Irritated because it was a nothing trade.''

flower off.

[RaisyDaisy]

So our SJ trade got neg'd, because people thought we paid too much offering Picks 8 and 21 I think it was, but Pacific offering picks 2, 4 and 20 for Barlow is fine and gets passed

LOL

[Memphistopheles]

yeah well the Bennell one is one of the worst i have seen

would love a logical and statics based reason for that.

because I can mount a very strong case that I overpaid.

Remove WHE from one side and Pick 57 from the other and the trade is fine imo.

Bennell and WHE will both be premo guns. Walters is a gun but Black is not and I doubt he ever will be.

Jed Anderson > Templeton and TMac > Pick 10 imo as well but the promise of who your could get with Pick 10 and how they could develop is enough that I think if I had a vote (I don't being an assistant) I would maybe just pass that one.

[RaisyDaisy]

We gave Pick 10 for McKenzie because that pick allowed us to get Duncan

[Nige]

So many subjective posts, I can't even.

To accurately reflect my thoughts on all of this, here's my Michael Jordan.