WXV Trade Talk

[Nige]

Christchurch need defenders? Isn't Sicily a forward?

[meow meow]

Christchurch need defenders? Isn't Sicily a forward?

Trading Sicily (forward) allows me to keep Gilbert (defender). Gilbert is worth heaps more to me since he would be in my starting XV.

[Nige]

Christchurch need defenders? Isn't Sicily a forward?

Trading Sicily (forward) allows me to keep Gilbert (defender). Gilbert is worth heaps more to me since he would be in my starting XV.

Ohhh, I get it.

[Toga]

Come on Nige keep up to date man  ;)

[Holz]

I agree with meow here, Gilbert is certainly worth more than Sicily.

Breaking into the hawks side will be tough, his VFL stats are also very unimpressive.

I can say this without a doubt. Sandi is much better than Sicily. Wether that difference is enough to make up the huge drop from rocky to Gibbs . Well that's for each team to decide.

[Nige]

I can say this without a doubt. Sandi is much better than Sicily.

I salute you Captain Obvious.

[Holz]

I can say this without a doubt. Sandi is much better than Sicily.

I salute you Captain Obvious.

Memph just posted that Sicily was better than Gilbert. Just throwing my support behind meow. This trade is certainly more even ithan the previous one.

I still rate Rocky over Sandi Gibbs but at least this is better.

[Master Q]

I can say this without a doubt. Sandi is much better than Sicily.

We salute you Captain Obvious.

[Bill Manspeaker]

I disagree. Sicily would be a much better place to live

[kilbluff1985]

Gibbs Sandi for Rocky I would reject aswell

:o

btw kinda funny when i was at Tokyo we were considering a deal which involved pick 9 for Sandi which i think is about right for Sandi so it's pretty funny you don't think Gibbs + Sandi is worth Rocky

How long ago was that though? Unless I had zero ruck stocks, no chance I'd give up pick 9 for Sandi

was towards the end of this season we were in talks i believe so we were desperate to get a better ruck then Simpson but there probably would have been something to even it up a bit

[Holz]

I can say this without a doubt. Sandi is much better than Sicily.

We salute you Captain Obvious.

I can say this though,  without a doubt Rocky is much much much better than Gibbs so trade unfair.

[Nige]

I disagree. Sicily would be a much better place to live

;D

[JBs-Hawks]

I can say this without a doubt. Sandi is much better than Sicily.

We salute you Captain Obvious.

I can say this though,  without a doubt Rocky is much much much better than Gibbs so trade unfair.

I can say this though. Rocky is 10 ppg better than Gibbs but Sandi is 100 ppg better then sicily.

[Vinny]

Acres > Lennon :P

Haha I'd say they are pretty even but we need a forward more haha. Plus Lennon will get DPP and has better VFL numbers.

[Bill Manspeaker]

Acres > Lennon :P