WXV Trade Talk

[RaisyDaisy]

If people rate bennell soo highly why haven't people put in huge offers for him..

If you think he is a 100 average forward for the next 10 years, throw your team at him.

I honestly think Bennell could be DPP for the next 2 years or so, ala Danger and Dusty, so there is every chance you come out the winner with this trade, but the reality is that the guarantee of Gunston always being a forward makes the trade fair IMO

Anyway, theres been enough discussion about the trade for now lol, and most people seem to think its fair, with the slight chance that you could be the winner here, but these chances go with every trade made anyway

[AaronKirk]

No one apart from Holz has offered what we wanted for  Bennell ( or Libba for that matter)

If people think he is worth more than you should have made a good offer.

I hope it is not negged just because Holz is involved.

Its not as if he has not been available for the whole trade period    ::)

[Boomz]

He's worth more than I'm willing to pay & have enough forwards. Don't know if others feel the same though.

[Nige]

He's worth more than I'm willing to pay & have enough forwards.

[meow meow]

You guys wanted both Gunston and Devon Smith for him and WHE when I enquired. Said Devon Smith had the same value as WHE ::)

Smith is worth as much as Libba. So by your logic WHE = Libba? No wonder we couldn't work out a trade.

[AaronKirk]

You guys wanted both Gunston and Devon Smith for him and WHE when I enquired. Said Devon Smith had the same value as WHE ::)

Smith is worth as much as Libba. So by your logic WHE = Libba? No wonder we couldn't work out a trade.

lol

Smith is not worth as much as Libba.

at that time everyone else here was talking up WHE as the next Fyfe. We tried to exploit that.


libba + bennell is not worth Gunston + Smith... yet

[Vinny]

As a forward, he is.

[JBs-Hawks]

As a forward, he is.

[Nige]

As a forward, he is.

[Ringo]

Willing to package McVeigh and Stanton for a strong starting mid so PM offers.

[Vinny]

Alright guys, 7 hours to go.

DILLOS FIRE SALE.

All of these guys must go or the Dillos are pretty much screwed. :(

Daniel Cross, Paul Chapman, Drew Petrie and Jay Schulz.

Looking for either:
Top 30 picks + Bit Extra.
Mixture of good depth
Package up a few a better pick or a better player.

Willing to add #15 if necessary.

Younger blokes like Blake Acres, Ben Newton, Patrick Karnezis can move in packages for better players as well.

If you are offering just picks, keep in mind we might need some cap help as well.

Thanks!

[Nige]

Alright guys, 7 hours to go.

DILLOS FIRE SALE.

All of these guys must go or the Dillos are pretty much screwed. :(

Daniel Cross, Paul Chapman, Drew Petrie and Jay Schulz.

Looking for either:
Top 30 picks + Bit Extra.
Mixture of good depth
Package up a few a better pick or a better player.

Willing to add #15 if necessary.

Younger blokes like Blake Acres, Ben Newton, Patrick Karnezis can move in packages for better players as well.

If you are offering just picks, keep in mind we might need some cap help as well.

Thanks!

You're screwed if you keep them? How?

[Master Q]

Because they will be worth even less after this season and they need as much value as they can for the rebuild.

Not rocket science  :P

[Vinny]

Well their value is just going to decline, we gotta sell them now while we can get something for them. In 2 years, they will be worth nothing. They aren't good enough to get good players for. Legitimately are whole starting XV has been killed cause we were running a retirement village for the last two years. :P

[Nige]

Well their value is just going to decline, we gotta sell them now while we can get something for them. In 2 years, they will be worth nothing. They aren't good enough to get good players for. Legitimately are whole starting XV has been killed cause we were running a retirement village for the last two years. :P

Oh yeah, right.

I'll talk to the lads, might be able to help.  ;)