trading out hanley

[Frozensage]

hanley -> simpson which then gives me enough cash to go mcdonald to sloane via mitchell.

I  feel simpson and hanley should score similar and sloane gives me 70 pts extra every week.

[RaisyDaisy]

Seems a bit odd, and Sloane only gives you 70 points more when he score 170, which I highly doubt he will do again

[Samm79]

Seems a bit odd, and Sloane only gives you 70 points more when he score 170, which I highly doubt he will do again

I think it's relative to McDonald RD, but I think it's 50 at best Frozensage

[_wato]

Hanley with Macaffer and Crowley upcoming ~ avg of 60 expected? Then Geelong to play, so say 100 points.. 220-230 over that period?
Simpson with Geel, PA, Ess - avg of 95 expected? 45-50 points gained already!

McDonald with WB/Adel/Melb - could avg 75 at best? Sloane with Rich/NM/Stk - should avg 115-120? 120 points gained.

So 160-175 points gained and that's only if Hanley really plays terrible - but has in the past.

I'm against trading premos but you have to ask yourself whether two trades is worth 160-175 points.

An average of 50-60ppg is definitely worth it at this stage! I'd bite the bullet and go for it!

[Redbaron]

I would not get rid of Hanley
Heath shaw has bargain written all over him at 440k this ia where I would spend cash.  ( 12 weeks ago everyone wanted simpson.......6 weeks ago no one wanted him.......now every one wants him again, which suggested that e time to buy him was 6 weeks ago  he will ave 95 in last 3.   Shaw will ave 95 too

[Diesels Pups]

Nut! Don't like it. Interesting move though. Hanley has that huge score in him where Simmo will get you that 90 to 100 score and Sloane the same generally. He who takes risk in life, reaps the reward. Or something like that.

[Samm79]

Hanley with Macaffer and Crowley upcoming ~ avg of 60 expected? Then Geelong to play, so say 100 points.. 220-230 over that period?
Simpson with Geel, PA, Ess - avg of 95 expected? 45-50 points gained already!

McDonald with WB/Adel/Melb - could avg 75 at best? Sloane with Rich/NM/Stk - should avg 115-120? 120 points gained.

So 160-175 points gained and that's only if Hanley really plays terrible - but has in the past.

I'm against trading premos but you have to ask yourself whether two trades is worth 160-175 points.

An average of 50-60ppg is definitely worth it at this stage! I'd bite the bullet and go for it!

Very interesting dissection Wato, I see your logic and agree.