AXVS: TRADE DISCUSSION (2014/15)

[Noz]

I think I just received possibly the worst trade offer of all time.

Share?

Im after a ruck man preferably a second or third string ruck man for your time.

If you have plenty of ruck man hit me up.

[Jroo]

I think I just received possibly the worst trade offer of all time.

Cmon man, Majak Daw for Buddy Franklin isn't that bad of an offer?

[Ricochet]

I think I just received possibly the worst trade offer of all time.

haha tell?

[nrich102]

James Aish + Lewis Taylor + Jack Crisp

For

Lance Franklin + Billy Hartung + Karl Amon

:o

[JBs-Hawks]

James Aish + Lewis Taylor + Jack Crisp

For

Lance Franklin + Billy Hartung + Karl Amon

:o

Yep horrible offer compared to 5 premiums traded out for 5 of the most mediocre players going around.

[PowerBug]

James Aish + Lewis Taylor + Jack Crisp

For

Lance Franklin + Billy Hartung + Karl Amon

:o

Yep horrible offer compared to 5 premiums traded out for 5 of the most mediocre players going around.

Yeah I think that's better than the trade that got accepted and passed :P Aish and Taylor can play

[kilbluff1985]

don't see how that's a terrible offer

[Memphistopheles]

don't see how that's a terrible offer

That's not even close to the worst offer of all time. In fact I don't think it's that bad - it's certainly one I'd negotiate.

I'm guessing they're trying to prize the Lions players off of you which is why you think it's so bad?

[kilbluff1985]

don't see how that's a terrible offer

That's not even close to the worst offer of all time. In fact I don't think it's that bad - it's certainly one I'd negotiate.

I'm guessing they're trying to prize the Lions players off of you which is why you think it's so bad?

i'm so confused

who are you talking to in the 2nd sentence ?

[Nige]

I'm guessing they're trying to prize the Lions players off of you which is why you think it's so bad?

Um Memph... nrich is the one getting the Lions in the trade above.

[Memphistopheles]

I'm guessing they're trying to prize the Lions players off of you which is why you think it's so bad?

Um Memph... nrich is the one getting the Lions in the trade above.

Well then he should be loving that trade then...

[Nige]

I'm guessing they're trying to prize the Lions players off of you which is why you think it's so bad?

Um Memph... nrich is the one getting the Lions in the trade above.

Well then he should be loving that trade then...

If you say so.

[kilbluff1985]

just curious would people say Taylor is worth a top 10 pick? i think would be close

obviously Aish would be worth a top 10 pick

[Nige]

just curious would people say Taylor is worth a top 10 pick? i think would be close

obviously Aish would be worth a top 10 pick

Probably a tad biased considering he's arguably my favourite player from his draft class, but I'd say yes.

[Ricochet]

just curious would people say Taylor is worth a top 10 pick? i think would be close

obviously Aish would be worth a top 10 pick

Top 10 maybe, Top 5 no