AXVS: TRADE DISCUSSION (2014/15)

[tbagrocks]

OK I HAVE TOO MANY PLAYERS ON MY LIST, So I want to move some mids as a combo package to try get a gun or two

Lyons, Clay Smith, Brad Hill, Acres, Adam Carter, Kerridge, Ben Jacobs David Mundy, Jake Batchelor, Terry Milera, John Butcher, Luke Brown, Jake Spencer. All picks other than NAT #3, #6

Possibly Eli Templeton, Andy Otten, Ty Vickery, Jake Neade, Dan Gorringe.

I need to rid a few players and I want a gun or two, let me know hey? :)

[Justin Bieber]

OK I HAVE TOO MANY PLAYERS ON MY LIST, So I want to move some mids as a combo package to try get a gun or two

Lyons, Clay Smith, Brad Hill, Acres, Adam Carter, Kerridge, Ben Jacobs David Mundy, Jake Batchelor, Terry Milera, John Butcher, Luke Brown, Jake Spencer

Possibly Eli Templeton, Andy Otten, Ty Vickery, Jake Neade, Dan Gorringe. All picks other than NAT #3, #6

I need to rid a few players and I want a gun or two, let me know hey? :)

Do you realise Milera is or about to be delisted?

[tbagrocks]

Do you realize players can go into a pre-season draft? :o

[Nige]

Do you realize players can go into a pre-season draft? :o

I think the rule is that you can't trade them regardless if they're not on a list at the time you're trading them though.  :-\

[Justin Bieber]

Do you realize players can go into a pre-season draft? :o

I think the rule is that you can't trade them regardless if they're not on a list at the time you're trading them though.  :-\

This plus I hear he's going to the SANFL next year.

[upthemaidens]

 It will be hard to justify declining any future trades now. 

[tbagrocks]

Build a bridge mate, who bluddy well cares what happens to Terry anyway ::)  If he stays, great. If the Crows swoop, great

If he goes, who even cares. Build a bridge and get over it ::)

[Hellopplz]

I know many rate McGovern as a potential gun in the future, but defenders tend to be scarce and hard to find scoring defenders compared to scoring forwards in this comp (as if I remember, forwards get more points for goals). I rate picks so reckon the pick upgrade is a pretty handy one, just depends if it closes the gap really.... Reckon it was a pick in the 30s/40s, would be more even, but think the current deal is fair enough to pass going off McGovern's potential + a top draft pick upgrade.

It probably has a winner in Bangkok but really depends how people rate McGovern as personally I'd prefer Hibberd in a game like this since he is a top 10 defender. If looking at that aspect, then I'd neg. But don't think it's so uneven to neg it 100%.

I was apart of the trade committee. This was my email back to BB. To be honest, personally I'd neg the trade as I don't rate McGovern as highly as others. But if you consider many rate him alot, and I also rate top picks (when used well), can consider it more even. Would I trade out a top 10 defender? Not unless for a heck lot more, but then again I rate high picks unlike many people I come across in other systems (and I'm pretty hard to trade with).

[Nige]

Can everyone opposing the Hibberd trade please state what they would offer from their teams?  :)

[Vinny]

It's not a great look when every other coach and the administrator reckons the trade shouldn't go through except for the two coaches involved, and then it goes through. It shouldn't have went to the committee especially considering the amount of people against it. Doesn't that mean any trade rejected goes to the committee and almost makes BBs decision pointless.

[Ricochet]

It's not a great look when every other coach and the administrator reckons the trade shouldn't go through except for the two coaches involved, and then it goes through. It shouldn't have went to the committee especially considering the amount of people against it. Doesn't that mean any trade rejected goes to the committee and almost makes BBs decision pointless.

Agree mate. This is why I reckon blocked trades should need at least 2 outsiders pushing it to be re-evaluated before it goes to the committee

[Jroo]

Can everyone opposing the Hibberd trade please state what they would offer from their teams?  :)

I offered Hurn/Harbrow + Dempsey for Hibbo + a spud. Koop was going to do it, but I had to pull out.


In other news, all my depth is on the table:

Defenders: Shaun Higgins, Courtenay Dempsey, Sean Dempster, Clancee Pearce, Josh Gibson, Daniel Talia, Matt McDonough
Midfielders: Sam Gibson, Richard Douglas, Danyle Pearce, Shaun Grigg, Farren Ray
Rucks: Tom Bellchambers, Shaun McKernan, Majak Daw
Forwards: Mitch Robinson. Jeff Garlett, Troy Menzel, Kyle Hardingham,Tom Lee

Rookies: Jake Lloyd (M), Zac O'Brien (M), Tom Downie (R)

Picks
ND - 44, 60, 76
Rookie - 12, 28, 44, 60, 76

[Nige]

Can everyone opposing the Hibberd trade please state what they would offer from their teams?  :)

I offered Hurn/Harbrow + Dempsey for Hibbo + a spud. Koop was going to do it, but I had to pull out.

Yep, I know. I did like the Hurn + Dempsey idea until you said you had to pull out of it.

[Noz]

Can everyone opposing the Hibberd trade please state what they would offer from their teams?  :)

I would throw Tom Mitchell's name first and then try and work around that.

[Justin Bieber]

I did offer Pick 8 and pick 13. On this evidence, McGovern is worth more than pick 8. A lot more.