Gilbee vs Mattner

[cooney17]

Which do who guys think is a good option for my second back

[ando10]

gilbee gets more of the footy but mattner is a tackling king so its a tough choice

i had mattner last year it payed off

this year i have gone with gillbee

so gilbee

[cooney17]

What about having both in the team?

[Marcus]

I had both last year and as much as Gilbee annoyed me and Mattner pleased me last year. I'm going with Gilbee. He is a pinpoint kick that is rewarded heavily in Supercoach. He is more of a running back than Mattner is too which means he will get more points for effective kicks out of defense.
Gilbee's year last year was also poor by his standards and therefore he is relatively cheap.
Go with Gilbee imo.