With 6 trades left should I bring in JPK for Cotchin?

Started by ben_020285, July 28, 2014, 08:51:02 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

ants

Quote from: Rowan1812 on July 29, 2014, 06:59:09 AM
I have the skill and knowledge to make the better team and in supercoach there is a bit of luck and that my friend is how you are in front of me in the rankings
still 5 weeks to go! Time will tell! 6 trades left and ranked 54 is pretty good! Ps I'm ranked 78 and my teams better than both ya all! Lol

GCSkiwi

Quote from: Rowan1812 on July 29, 2014, 06:59:09 AM
I have the skill and knowledge to make the better team and in supercoach there is a bit of luck and that my friend is how you are in front of me in the rankings

I seriously struggle to decide whether or not you're just a troll, or just overly cocky. Everyone here uses their knowledge and skills and gets an element of luck, flat out your team is not better because you aren't ranked higher. That's how numbers work. Pretty hard to get lucky enough over 18 rounds so far to gain that many places on you. You might have a couple of higher scoring players but it's not just about having the best players by the end game, it's about getting their points in early too. I'd be killing this comp if I had my current side from round 1, the point is other coaches have been better at getting good players in earlier. Fair enough to have an opinion mate but stop talking like yours is fact.

Ben I reckon with 6 trades it's definitely worth pulling the trigger, assuming the rest of your team is complete. Agree with what you said earlier about Cotch not really being a premo mid this year.

ants

Quote from: GCSkiwi on July 29, 2014, 09:08:34 AM
Quote from: Rowan1812 on July 29, 2014, 06:59:09 AM
I have the skill and knowledge to make the better team and in supercoach there is a bit of luck and that my friend is how you are in front of me in the rankings

I seriously struggle to decide whether or not you're just a troll, or just overly cocky. Everyone here uses their knowledge and skills and gets an element of luck, flat out your team is not better because you aren't ranked higher. That's how numbers work. Pretty hard to get lucky enough over 18 rounds so far to gain that many places on you. You might have a couple of higher scoring players but it's not just about having the best players by the end game, it's about getting their points in early too. I'd be killing this comp if I had my current side from round 1, the point is other coaches have been better at getting good players in earlier. Fair enough to have an opinion mate but stop talking like yours is fact.

Ben I reckon with 6 trades it's definitely worth pulling the trigger, assuming the rest of your team is complete. Agree with what you said earlier about Cotch not really being a premo mid this year.
well said!

shaker

Quote from: Rowan1812 on July 29, 2014, 06:59:09 AM
I have the skill and knowledge to make the better team and in supercoach there is a bit of luck and that my friend is how you are in front of me in the rankin
Good to see someone who is so humble , get a grip man  :o

Any way ben I don't think it's a bad idea GWS tend to tag quite a lot and JPK has had a far better year

Bully

Quote from: GCSkiwi on July 29, 2014, 09:08:34 AM
Quote from: Rowan1812 on July 29, 2014, 06:59:09 AM
I have the skill and knowledge to make the better team and in supercoach there is a bit of luck and that my friend is how you are in front of me in the rankings

I seriously struggle to decide whether or not you're just a troll, or just overly cocky. Everyone here uses their knowledge and skills and gets an element of luck, flat out your team is not better because you aren't ranked higher. That's how numbers work. Pretty hard to get lucky enough over 18 rounds so far to gain that many places on you. You might have a couple of higher scoring players but it's not just about having the best players by the end game, it's about getting their points in early too. I'd be killing this comp if I had my current side from round 1, the point is other coaches have been better at getting good players in earlier. Fair enough to have an opinion mate but stop talking like yours is fact.

Ben I reckon with 6 trades it's definitely worth pulling the trigger, assuming the rest of your team is complete. Agree with what you said earlier about Cotch not really being a premo mid this year.

Well said, Ben has worked his loopholes beautifully, 2 KP players is often better than 1 consistent mid, then there's the critical capatain's selection every week. There's a whole lot more to this game than just merely getting the highest averaging players. Knowing when to fold is another important facet, the Cotch for JPK trade is yet another example of this. I don't pretend to know the answers but I can see the logic in making such a switch.

quinny88

Wow  :o remove your head from your ass Rowan and you might catch up

tor01doc

Quote from: quinny88 on July 29, 2014, 12:07:46 PM
Wow  :o remove your head from your ass Rowan and you might catch up

I specifically checked out this thread once I saw that quinny has posted - and I was not disappointed.

quinny881 - rowan18120

DaveElNacho

Quote from: tor01doc on July 29, 2014, 01:08:24 PM
Quote from: quinny88 on July 29, 2014, 12:07:46 PM
Wow  :o remove your head from your ass Rowan and you might catch up

I specifically checked out this thread once I saw that quinny has posted - and I was not disappointed.

quinny88 : 1 - rowan1812 : 0

FTFY

tor01doc