2015 Trade Discussion Thread,

[kilbluff1985]

A Hall, J Lamb, R Tarrant and C Wood are for sale

i mainly want a pick in the 20's range for each of them or might take a couple picks instead a bit later or will consider earlyish rookie picks and can package

[Vinny]

24 year old Tex Walker is on the table. Just signed a contract that will keep him at the Crows until 2018.

Willing to add N39 + MORE for an upgrade on him.

[Nige]

24 year old Tex Walker is on the table. Just signed a contract that will keep him at the Crows until 2018.

Willing to add N39 + MORE for an upgrade on him.

T.Cloke.  8)

[GoLions]

24 year old Tex Walker is on the table.

[Vinny]

Haha I thought I'd re-announce it considering he signed. I'm happy to keep him too, just putting it out there. He averaged 80 coming back from injury in what was a very average season.

[kilbluff1985]

24 year old Tex Walker is on the table. Just signed a contract that will keep him at the Crows until 2018.

Willing to add N39 + MORE for an upgrade on him.

T.Cloke.  8)

he clearly says he wants an upgrade

[Memphistopheles]

A Hall, J Lamb, R Tarrant and C Wood are for sale

i mainly want a pick in the 20's range for each of them or might take a couple picks instead a bit later or will consider earlyish rookie picks and can package

No offence but none of these guys are worth a Nat Pick in the 20s.

Hall probably the most valuable but even then you'd be lucky to get late 20s at best I think.

[JBs-Hawks]

24 year old Tex Walker is on the table. Just signed a contract that will keep him at the Crows until 2018.

Willing to add N39 + MORE for an upgrade on him.

T.Cloke.  8)

N. Riewoldt :)

[Vinny]

24 year old Tex Walker is on the table. Just signed a contract that will keep him at the Crows until 2018.

Willing to add N39 + MORE for an upgrade on him.

T.Cloke.  8)

N. Riewoldt :)

Definitely an upgrade on scoring man but with NRoo only having 2 years left and averaging 15 points more on top of what I said above. I think Tex is worth more sorry.

[Nige]

I always though that considering how average basically everyone but midfielders are in this comp that if you have a ruck, forward or defender that is even half good that you're always best off keeping them rather than trying to 'upgrade' them.

It's actually the reason I went out and got Cloke in the first place. He's not the greatest, but on his day he can be a solid contributor and I really think he just had an off season. Don't remember it exactly, but iirc he scored like 167 at one point this season, which shows he capable of getting good scores.

Hindsight tells me my Walters and McGovern for Masten and Roberton trade is going to haunt me for a while though.

[kilbluff1985]

A Hall, J Lamb, R Tarrant and C Wood are for sale

i mainly want a pick in the 20's range for each of them or might take a couple picks instead a bit later or will consider earlyish rookie picks and can package

No offence but none of these guys are worth a Nat Pick in the 20s.

Hall probably the most valuable but even then you'd be lucky to get late 20s at best I think.

haha well rightly i may have overpaid but a year ago i gave up NAT 13 for A Hall as i said i overpaid but i thought he would get better, and i gave a pick in the 20's for Lamb a year ago and i think Wood is worth a pick in the 20's

we debate enough about trades obviously we see things very differently

i don't really like how i'm trying to sell players and your lowering there value by saying what YOU think they are worth

[Vinny]

Yeah I understand what you mean but I'm not trading a forward for a midfielder, I'm looking for another forward. Plus there are 23 forwards averaging 95+ obviously some will lose DPP but there is still a fair share of decent forwards.

Also, Cloke is shower. :P

[kilbluff1985]

Yeah I understand what you mean but I'm not trading a forward for a midfielder, I'm looking for another forward. Plus there are 23 forwards averaging 95+ obviously some will lose DPP but there is still a fair share of decent forwards.

Also, Cloke is shower. :P

23 decent forwards spread across 16 teams Vinny?

[Vinny]

Yeah I understand what you mean but I'm not trading a forward for a midfielder, I'm looking for another forward. Plus there are 23 forwards averaging 95+ obviously some will lose DPP but there is still a fair share of decent forwards.

Also, Cloke is shower. :P

23 decent forwards spread across 16 teams Vinny?

Knew this would come up haha. Yes dude, but I'm offering a forward + more for a better forward. Which makes sense to me!

[Nige]

Damn it, made a post but my internet cut out and it didn't post.  :(