Is SMitch worth two trades?

Started by monga77, July 17, 2014, 08:37:06 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

monga77

So looking to getting in Sam Mitchell, but who do I trade out to get him in?
Would love to get him in for Langford and then loophole suckling and SDThompson for d6/d7 but I'm just short on cash to pull that move off, so it's either use 2 trades which will now be something like Shenton > Morabito and  Langford > Mitchell or just straight swap suckling or Thompson?

Jackross10

#1
Most will probably disagree but. I don't Like Mitchell's draw and the taggers he will come up against. They do yet Smith a lot but still.

Swans - Bird.
Dogs - Wallis/Picken
Dees -  Mckenzie ?
Freo - Crowley
Geelong - Guthrie
Pies -  Caff.

Although Mitchell doesn't seem to be fussed too much by taggers. Just my opinion though.

Bully

Quote from: Jackross10 on July 17, 2014, 08:41:03 PM
Most will probably disagree but. I don't Like Mitchell's draw and the taggers he will come up against. They do yet Smith a lot but still.

Swans - Bird.
Dogs - Wallis/Picken
Dees -  Mckenzie ?
Freo - Crowley
Geelong - Guthrie
Pies -  Caff.

Although Mitchell doesn't seem to be fussed too much by taggers. Just my opinion though.

These were his scores the last time he met the above.

vs Sydney (93)
vs Dogs (158)
vs Dees (74)
vs Freo (114)
vs Geel (143)
vs Coll (95)

It's fair to say he can handle a tag, been doing it for over a decade & should have a Brownlow around his neck too.

Jroo

Quote from: Bully on July 17, 2014, 08:53:24 PM
Quote from: Jackross10 on July 17, 2014, 08:41:03 PM
Most will probably disagree but. I don't Like Mitchell's draw and the taggers he will come up against. They do yet Smith a lot but still.

Swans - Bird.
Dogs - Wallis/Picken
Dees -  Mckenzie ?
Freo - Crowley
Geelong - Guthrie
Pies -  Caff.

Although Mitchell doesn't seem to be fussed too much by taggers. Just my opinion though.

These were his scores the last time he met the above.

vs Sydney (93)
vs Dogs (158)
vs Dees (74)
vs Freo (114)
vs Geel (143)
vs Coll (95)

It's fair to say he can handle a tag, been doing it for over a decade & should have a Brownlow around his neck too.
Good post, I wouldn't be worried. I'm not even sure he'll get tagged, Hill and Smith may get it.
Along with Cotch, Mitchell should have the 2012 Brownlow around his neck  ;) :P

About using two trades, it depends on how many trades you have left.

Jackross10

Yeah fair enough. I was just pointing that out  :P he should go 100+ still

monga77

Yeh well I'll pretty much definitely be getting him just a matter of who for, I have 5 trades left 46k