JPK+SMitch vs NDS+Hanley

Started by Bones Bombers, July 11, 2014, 06:39:44 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Bones Bombers

Need to replace Ablett and want to bring in a DPP defender to move Langdon to mid bench.
Which combo will score more for the rest of the season and why?
Thanks in advance!

Big Mac

JPK - 120
SMitch - 90
= 210

NDS - 110
Hanley - 100
= 210

Shower. That usually works out. Um, I would probably go option 1 although Smitch would need to get his body right pretty quick

Bones Bombers

Quote from: Big  Mac on July 11, 2014, 06:42:59 PM
JPK - 120
SMitch - 90
= 210

NDS - 110
Hanley - 100
= 210

Shower. That usually works out. Um, I would probably go option 1 although Smitch would need to get his body right pretty quick
Haha yeah thanks it's pretty close. I've actually been leaning more towards NDS and Hanley due to being unsure about Mitch's fitness and role. But then Hanley can cop a hard tag too.

Jroo

IMO,
JPK > NDS
SMitch = Hanley
So, I'd go with option 1.

kilbluff1985

wouldn't be bringing in NDS will get tagged in 4 of his last games plays Carlton, Geelong, GWS and Adelaide they will all tag NDS you would think

Bones Bombers

Quote from: JROO8 on July 11, 2014, 06:57:45 PM
IMO,
JPK > NDS
SMitch = Hanley
So, I'd go with option 1.
Hmm well I better make this decision before tonights game then!

Bully


ZEEMAN


Jackross10


tommy10

Yep Option 1 too. JPK is more consistent than NDS.

Bones Bombers

#10
Well, looks like its unanimous! Welcome JPK and welcome back Sammy Mitchell. Go hard boys!

Thanks so much for the assistance. Needed some perspective.

Bones Bombers

Now to decide who to bench, between Langdon and Shenton this week with Goddard not playing?

kilbluff1985

Quote from: Bones Bombers on July 11, 2014, 07:35:16 PM
Now to decide who to bench, between Langdon and Shenton this week with Goddard not playing?

flip a coin

Big Mac

Just looked at Smitch's draw - He cops Melbourne, WB, Freo and Collingwood - Is he likely to get the no. 1 tag in these games?

Bones Bombers

Quote from: Big  Mac on July 11, 2014, 07:59:28 PM
Just looked at Smitch's draw - He cops Melbourne, WB, Freo and Collingwood - Is he likely to get the no. 1 tag in these games?
Hope not cos he's in now lol