Which way should I go?

[quinny88]

In a bit of a pickle this week with a few outs in the midfield. Copping the donut is not an option

Current Mids:

Ablett, Pendles, Selwood, StevieJ, Rockliff, Fyfe, Beams, Goddard (Miles, O'Brien)

Obviously Ablett has to go so am trading him to JPK then comes the decision of weather I trade Goddard to one of Libba, Sloane, Ward or trade O'brien to Honeychurch

[dickitch]

The latter, no brainer to me

[quinny88]

The latter, no brainer to me

The reason being?

P.s Rest of my team is complete

[Ramus]

The latter, no brainer to me

The reason being?

P.s Rest of my team is complete

Why would you trade out Goddard?

[dickitch]

ah fair enough, with a complete team then a sideways is the way forward if you can't cop the donut.  I personally like Sloane for the finals run

[quinny88]

The latter, no brainer to me

The reason being?

P.s Rest of my team is complete

Why would you trade out Goddard?

Because I need to win the game and its either trade goddard to another premo or trade a kid to another kid. Im not really gaining much in the long run from either scenario so figured atleast trading goddard to a premo will give me an extra 110+ points for the week

[Big Mac]

Goddard out, Sloane in.

[shaker]

Well big Q you can not trade out rocky so Goddard it must be , if you have trades up your sleeve that's all good but if not think you need to pick someone in a team that has no risk of being rested  ;) I will leave the rest to you as I think you are above me in the league we are in  ::)

[Ramus]

The latter, no brainer to me

The reason being?

P.s Rest of my team is complete

Why would you trade out Goddard?

Because I need to win the game and its either trade goddard to another premo or trade a kid to another kid. Im not really gaining much in the long run from either scenario so figured atleast trading goddard to a premo will give me an extra 110+ points for the week

Well you must have plenty of trades left to go sideways for short term gain.

Rookie for Rookie is a waste. How much cash do you have, can you trade Ablett & O'Brien for two decent mids?

[quinny88]

5 trades currently

Once I do Ablett to JPK ill have 135k left so cant get anything decent for O'brien

[Ramus]

5 trades currently

Once I do Ablett to JPK ill have 135k left so cant get anything decent for O'brien

With just 5 trades and Goddard only out for the one week, I would be inclined to hold, still 7 weeks to go?

I only have 4 trades, have GAJ to replace and am not sure whether to trade for the future (bank some cash) or for now (go for gold!).

[quinny88]

5 trades currently

Once I do Ablett to JPK ill have 135k left so cant get anything decent for O'brien

With just 5 trades and Goddard only out for the one week, I would be inclined to hold, still 7 weeks to go?

I only have 4 trades, have GAJ to replace and am not sure whether to trade for the future (bank some cash) or for now (go for gold!).

Yeah I dont think I can cop the donut though. A lot of tight games in my leagues and either just in or out of the top 4 in all leagues.

[HotTiges]

No shame in trading Goddard to a gun. I'm doing the same myself..  Dam donuts

[Jackross10]

Ablett - JPK
BJ - Sloane.