2014 Review and Rule discussions for 2015.

[SydneyRox]

I am happy with the way they are as well. End of first round to go with a top 1-3 should be enough

[Spite]

I propose an award for the highest scoring player in the Grand Final like the Norm Smith.

Winning team gets +10 to its player - for example

Team A has Ablett who scores 160

Team B has Pendles who scores 165

Team A won so Ablett + 10 = 170 which is greater than Pendles 165 so Ablett wins the norm smith or whatever we call it.

[Vinny]

Good idea Spite, I like that award.

I wouldn't mind going back and seeing who the pass 3 Norm Smith winners would have been and chucking it in the records.

[SydneyRox]

I like it. giving the +10 is an interesting idea. It should go to the winners unless there is a remarkable opposition performance.

[Spite]

Good idea Spite, I like that award.

I wouldn't mind going back and seeing who the pass 3 Norm Smith winners would have been and chucking it in the records.

Yeah i would like to know too but I assume it'll be ablett :P Besides this year being Lachie Neale

[Memphistopheles]

Good idea Spite, I like that award.

Yeah great idea mate.

Marc down Bontempelli for the 2017 Norm Smith :P

[Vinny]

Haha they didn't have Ablett I think? It was  actually Priddis with (146+10) just beating one of your guys Scooter. (155)

[Spite]

Haha they didn't have Ablett I think? It was  actually Priddis with (146+10) just beating one of your guys Scooter. (155)

...then I'd like to propose a change and make it +5 :P

[JBs-Hawks]

Could also give forwards and defenders a +10 bonus aswell so that midfielders dont win it every time

[Spite]

Could also give forwards and defenders a +10 bonus aswell so that midfielders dont win it every time

As in +10 to all forwards and defenders (not utilities) and then an additional +10 for winning the match? That's pretty good too but maybe make it +15 for forwards and defenders since even the best forward is like 40 points below the best mid

[Ringo]

If this was to be in effect this year would have been

Hedgehogs Lachie Neale 170
Werewolves Matt Priddis 140

As Hedgehogs won the final Lachie Neale 170+10 so Lachie Neale would wing the Norm Smith

Last Year

Werewolves Matt Priddis 146
Hedgehogs Scott Selwood 155
As Werewolves won the Title Norm Smith to Priddis 146+10 = 156 Over Selwood.

Is this worth adding to awards for future years as proposed by Spite. Comments Welcome.
Only issue I see is 10 points enough of an advantage to winning team. So comments on this area welcome.  My Thoughts are a 10% Loading for winning the GF but open to all comments.

[Vinny]

Definitely worth it IMO, adds another element to the grandfinal and will be cool to take guesses on who'll take out the North Smith.

Priddis is a grandfinal specialist!

I think as the boys said above, 10 points for winning team and 15 points for defenders or forwards sounds pretty good.

[Nige]

Would have to be called the Ringo Starr Medal surely?  :P

[Spite]

Would have to be called the Ringo Starr Medal surely?  :P

Like it haha

[Memphistopheles]

Would have to be called the Ringo Starr Medal surely?  :P

Like it haha

Love it - and 10% added over 10 points added works better I think.