Round 14 - Tigers v Swans - Friday Jun 20th - MCG

[Ricochet]

Dusty 144.
Parker 125.
Buddy 125.

Cannot complain. 8)

great start ledge! I don't think 125 is enough for VC though. Gonna run with Pendles I think

[Mat0369]

129.

I might have to go a week earlier then I planned with the 125 tonight.

[Frozensage]

More weight for the last qtr cause when the game was won, and cotchin went missing when his team needed him.

[Jroo]

Absolutely gutted with Cotch's score, how did he get 13 points knocked off?

Because when the game was on the line, he was riding the pine. How can people complain? Game got hard and he scrubbed it up.

Played well tonight, was on 105 a 3 quarter time, no way did he deserve a 13 point penalty.

Agreed,  was CLEARLY BOG, in the first three quarters.
He looked a lot better this week, so there promising signs.

[Bones Bombers]

Cotchin very harshly treated IMO. And I don't have him.
I know he didn't finish the game that well but his work early helped the team get right into the game.

[Mat0369]

Cotchin averaging 6 meters a possession.

[Bully]

Cotchin very harshly treated IMO. And I don't have him.
I know he didn't finish the game that well but his work early helped the team get right into the game.

Exactly, rubbish score at the end, I can understand not giving him any points but knocking off 13 is a joke.

[Bully]

Cotchin had a much bigger influence than JPK yet gets robbed of 13 points, sometimes the scoring system reeks of playing favourites.

[Nige]

Longmire: "I'm not gonna comment on the umpires tonight"

Now we wait for Dimma's two cents. Ask away Stevo!

[Mat0369]

Cotchin had a much bigger influence than JPK yet gets robbed of 13 points, sometimes the scoring system reeks of playing favourites.

Cotchin averaging 6 meters a possession.

That is the actual stat, they have said it on Fox multiple times tonight. Throw in tackles and CP's and getting them when it was a 2 point game.

[quinny88]

Cotchin very harshly treated IMO. And I don't have him.
I know he didn't finish the game that well but his work early helped the team get right into the game.

Exactly, rubbish score at the end, I can understand not giving him any points but knocking off 13 is a joke.

It's because CD take the points from players in close games and give them to others. I don't think there should be this 3300 number or whatever it is. Give the points to the players that deserve them without taking from others.

[Bully]

Longmire: "I'm not gonna comment on the umpires tonight"

Now we wait for Dimma's two cents. Ask away Stevo!

The umpiring was a joke, Deledio's mark disallowed had all the hallmarks of incompetence.

[Vinny]

Yep, my only two problems with the scoring system are:

1) 30+ points for kicking the game winning goal.
2) 3300 scaling rule.

[Bones Bombers]

Cotchin very harshly treated IMO. And I don't have him.
I know he didn't finish the game that well but his work early helped the team get right into the game.

Exactly, rubbish score at the end, I can understand not giving him any points but knocking off 13 is a joke.

It's because CD take the points from players in close games and give them to others. I don't think there should be this 3300 number or whatever it is. Give the points to the players that deserve them without taking from others.

They should just take them from the no hopers down the bottom of the points table!

[Mailman the 2nd]

Cotchin had a much bigger influence than JPK yet gets robbed of 13 points, sometimes the scoring system reeks of playing favourites.

JPK did well when the game was there to be won, Cotchin didn't

Pretty simple