Round 14 - Tigers v Swans - Friday Jun 20th - MCG

[Nige]

Longmire: "I'm not gonna comment on the umpires tonight"

Now we wait for Dimma's two cents. Ask away Stevo!

The umpiring was a joke, Deledio's mark disallowed had all the hallmarks of incompetence.

The terrible call of not paying the holding the ball against Richards.

There was also a call where Petterd should have got a free kick in the forward pocket that didn't get picked out.

[Mailman the 2nd]

Longmire: "I'm not gonna comment on the umpires tonight"

Now we wait for Dimma's two cents. Ask away Stevo!

The umpiring was a joke, Deledio's mark disallowed had all the hallmarks of incompetence.

The terrible call of not paying the holding the ball against Richards.

There was also a call where Petterd should have got a free kick in the forward pocket that didn't get picked out.

Lets be fair here Buddy was denied a good 5 inside 50 frees from trips and holds

[Vinny]

Yep the umpiring was shower both ways IMO.

Buddy got destroyed by the umps

[Bones Bombers]

Longmire: "I'm not gonna comment on the umpires tonight"

Now we wait for Dimma's two cents. Ask away Stevo!

The umpiring was a joke, Deledio's mark disallowed had all the hallmarks of incompetence.

The terrible call of not paying the holding the ball against Richards.

There was also a call where Petterd should have got a free kick in the forward pocket that didn't get picked out.

Yeah but Buddy was getting raped. Hope Rance used protection. The umpiring has been terrible for every team. Can't do much about it.

[Mailman the 2nd]

I just hope it gets better for the rest of the week. I can't stand watching games umpired like these ones

[Bully]

Cotchin had a much bigger influence than JPK yet gets robbed of 13 points, sometimes the scoring system reeks of playing favourites.

Cotchin averaging 6 meters a possession.

That is the actual stat, they have said it on Fox multiple times tonight. Throw in tackles and CP's and getting them when it was a 2 point game.

Kennedy butchered the ball tonight, I couldn't care less if Cotchin kicked the ball short, at least they hit the mark. Absolute robbery if you ask me, I bet he gets coaches votes tonight, JPK will get nothing of the sort.

[Mailman the 2nd]

Cotchin had a much bigger influence than JPK yet gets robbed of 13 points, sometimes the scoring system reeks of playing favourites.

Cotchin averaging 6 meters a possession.

That is the actual stat, they have said it on Fox multiple times tonight. Throw in tackles and CP's and getting them when it was a 2 point game.

Kennedy butchered the ball tonight, I couldn't care less if Cotchin kicked the ball short, at least they hit the mark. Absolute robbery if you ask me, I bet he gets coaches votes tonight, JPK will get nothing of the sort.

Don't think you watched the same game, JPK did well when the game was on the line, Cotchin didn't

There really isn't anything more to it

[Vinny]

JPK had 12 tackles, Cotchin had 2 tackles.

Both butchered it.

JPK was influential when the game was in the balance, Cotchin on the other hand went to sleep.

[Mat0369]

Yeah but Buddy was getting raped. Hope Rance used protection. The umpiring has been terrible for every team. Can't do much about it.

^^^^This


and

Kennedy butchered the ball tonight, I couldn't care less if Cotchin kicked the ball short, at least they hit the mark. Absolute robbery if you ask me, I bet he gets coaches votes tonight, JPK will get nothing of the sort.

Cotchin 66% and 21 uncontested touches vs 58% and 17 CP's, 7 clearances and 12 tackles. CD hate short kicks, especially when it comes from and UP. Plus if you are averaging 6m a possession I don't know if those are exactly effective kicks. JPK was still racking them up when it was close in the last, Cotchin went missing

[Ricochet]

wow Hardwick handling questions about the umpires very very well

[Bully]

Yeah but Buddy was getting raped. Hope Rance used protection. The umpiring has been terrible for every team. Can't do much about it.

^^^^This


and

Kennedy butchered the ball tonight, I couldn't care less if Cotchin kicked the ball short, at least they hit the mark. Absolute robbery if you ask me, I bet he gets coaches votes tonight, JPK will get nothing of the sort.

Cotchin 66% and 21 uncontested touches vs 58% and 17 CP's, 7 clearances and 12 tackles. CD hate short kicks, especially when it comes from and UP. Plus if you are averaging 6m a possession I don't know if those are exactly effective kicks. JPK was still racking them up when it was close in the last, Cotchin went missing

Let's just see who gets the coaches votes shall we, and pulling up stats like this doesn't excuse the fact he had 13 points taken away from his 3 quarter time score. Absolute joke.

[quinny88]

wow Hardwick handling questions about the umpires very very well

Damn I missed it. He looked furious after the game

[Ricochet]

wow Hardwick handling questions about the umpires very very well

Damn I missed it. He looked furious after the game

Nah he was fine. Although did imply they might be being coached wrong, but did feel sorry for them and said it must be hard to umpire the current game

[Mailman the 2nd]

wow Hardwick handling questions about the umpires very very well

Damn I missed it. He looked furious after the game

Nah he was fine. Although did imply they might be being coached wrong, but did feel sorry for them and said it must be hard to umpire the current game

Its because they got advised by that joke of a director Jeff Gieschen for 3-4 years

[quinny88]

Yeah doesn't help that the AFL change the focus and interpretations of every rule week to week and the umpires have to somehow adjust. Just leave the friggen game alone