LaHug's Captains 2014 - Round 13

[pommyadam]

psk - I'm personally liking the idea of Treloar, but that "rest" in rd8 has me concerned that it'll happen again come finals time

still, I'm liking it as a POD (but then the last time I did that.... Scooter in rd1)

Yeah it's a tough decision, also Treloar may be in form now, however, we can't be sure of the remainder of his season. Pendlebury is a guaranteed +110. If I skip on Pendles and Treloar ends the season with a 90's average (would consist of a second half average in the 80's) it would be a terrible decision. High Risk v. Reward on Treloar. I wish that Watson didn't get injured. Would have avoided all this trouble (& non-progressive trading week) if I could have just kept him, & he was playing great as well.

Looking at his history, he seems to keep his scores pretty consistent (okay, 3 years in a developing team isn't the best sample) and seems to improve in the 2nd half of the year
I'm jumping on, YOLO

edit: just out of interest, GWS have only conceded 3 scores over 130 this season (to midfielders), of which they are Macrae, Dangerfield and Zaharakis
also, Hawthorn have given up 9 120+ scores to mids this season (joint most with Brisbane) - if it's not Murphy scoring those points, then who is it? funnily enough, only Rocky in rd1 is the only leading mid not to crack the ton against them

[jvalles69]

I'm not sold on Rocky, but got a feeling about Swan so I might have to go with the pig!

[Nige]

My boy Dyson Heppell as always, thanks!

Brad Ebert or Levi Greenwood?

Also Isaac Smith please!

[jvalles69]

My boy Dyson Heppell as always, thanks!

Brad Ebert or Levi Greenwood?

Also Isaac Smith please!

Heppell will get Cross for sure this week, leave well alone!!!

[powersuperkents]

psk - I'm personally liking the idea of Treloar, but that "rest" in rd8 has me concerned that it'll happen again come finals time

still, I'm liking it as a POD (but then the last time I did that.... Scooter in rd1)

Yeah it's a tough decision, also Treloar may be in form now, however, we can't be sure of the remainder of his season. Pendlebury is a guaranteed +110. If I skip on Pendles and Treloar ends the season with a 90's average (would consist of a second half average in the 80's) it would be a terrible decision. High Risk v. Reward on Treloar. I wish that Watson didn't get injured. Would have avoided all this trouble (& non-progressive trading week) if I could have just kept him, & he was playing great as well.

Looking at his history, he seems to keep his scores pretty consistent (okay, 3 years in a developing team isn't the best sample) and seems to improve in the 2nd half of the year
I'm jumping on, YOLO

edit: just out of interest, GWS have only conceded 3 scores over 130 this season (to midfielders), of which they are Macrae, Dangerfield and Zaharakis
also, Hawthorn have given up 9 120+ scores to mids this season (joint most with Brisbane) - if it's not Murphy scoring those points, then who is it? funnily enough, only Rocky in rd1 is the only leading mid not to crack the ton against them
Rocky was tagging though that game, so considering that, 97 is quite good

I'm going Pendles, I think it's better to wait on Treloar & Libby (I think it will be one of them to crack +110), I'll give them 5 or so weeks to make sure I pick up the right one

[pommyadam]

true there psk, i just found it hilarious that the leading average mid is the only leading mid who hasn't cracked the ton against Hawthorn this season

requests have been updated, and Brebert is in the opening post.

[Nige]

requests have been updated, and Brebert is in the opening post.

Cheers.

Looks like it's going to be a terrible week in XVs this week.  :(

[LaHug]

if it's not Murphy scoring those points, then who is it?

Gibbs

[Barra13]

if it's not Murphy scoring those points, then who is it?

Kade Simpson

For me, its either Swan or Stevie J.

[pommyadam]

if it's not Murphy scoring those points, then who is it?

Gibbs

not gonna lie, Carlton are that DT-irrelevant that I completely forgot he played for them

[LaHug]

if it's not Murphy scoring those points, then who is it?

Gibbs

not gonna lie, Carlton are that DT-irrelevant that I completely forgot he played for them

Haha, honestly reckon Gibbs and Simpson will outscore Murphy this week.

[Money]

would I be able to make a request?

[pommyadam]

would I be able to make a request?

go for it, that's what we I do here

[LaHug]

Just realised I don't have any of my own top 5 in AF.......

[Money]

would I be able to make a request?

go for it, that's what we I do here

Grazie, Stanton please mate!