Mackie vs Duffield vs Gram vs Gilbert

[pinochio]

Mackie vs Duffield vs Gram vs Gilbert

Similar priced,

NEED HELP :P

[mEnty]

You only want one? I would pick either gram or duffield. Both should score pretty solidly.

[Russ dogga]

have the same problem  :-\ dont 4get bout broughton, but i wood cancell out mackie an gilbert

[pinochio]

Yep mEnty just 1....i think goddard is way to pricey....

Russ, dont really want Broughton as he is still a relitivly new player  ???  ....

But ye Gram vs Duffield basically :) - Gram is on the more consistent team which might sway your mind to .....

[dog]

Have you got Hodge, Goodwin and Enright???

Dont pick any one from Freo bar Pavlich or a rookie (Barlow)

Seriously though? No Goddard?

[pinochio]

dog,

Nah -  I just think goddard is to pricey atm.....rd 4-7 maybe (in my dreams :))

I have hodgey and enright, not a fan of goodwin (might be a tad too old)

U say not to pick anyone from freo cept barlow/pav - what bout Sandi or you think Clark will start where he left of last year???

but out of gram and duff - what u think pal?

[Russ dogga]

yeh i thought bout that 2 but since duffield got a 111 when they got smashed so hes lookin pretty consistent but still early days

[Cicjose]

i have mackie and gram

[dog]

Apologies mate! Totally forgot about Sandi (bit of a freo hater just quitely!)

I have locked Sandi, Pav and Barlow.

I think you might regret not having Goddard. If your worried about the cash, downgrade a mid pricer to a rookie and upgrade another mid pricer to a full premium.

Mate to be honest Gram and Duffield have never come into my calculations so I dont think my opinion is very relevant. Both are proven performers and worthy picks. Saints have a point to prove this year and cant see Fremantle improving too much on last year, therefore I would lean towards Gram.

Consider Goodwin though, look at his last 8 to 10 games last year! old yes but if he stays injury free all year will be a worthy keeper

[chatters24]

Duffield for mine. Consistent performer, doesn't get a lot of attention because he doesn't do a whole lot of damage. He's a good hard running back flanker who attracts heaps of footy. I wouldn't consider Mackie of Gilbert as they can get jobs on key forwards and they're main focus goes from getting the footy to stopping their opponent whereas both Duffield and Gram don't have that.