Help me chose between trades

[pies124]

Swallow, Bartell, Mcveigh, Hanley, Suckling, Langdon (Langford, Cutler)

Ablett, Pendles, Selwood, Beams, Stevie J, Rocky, Polec, Hallahan (Acres, Taylor)

Sandi, Goldy (derickx, Thurlow)

Danger, Parker, Roughy, Dusty, Lennon, C.Cameron (Impey, Rohan)

Ok so here are my possible trades

1. Polec to JPK/ fyfe and Taylor to Shenton- This one gets the most cash

2. Polec JPK/fyfe and impey/ rohan to shenton- less cash but creates dpp

I'm leaning towards trade two because i can get rid of impey/ rohan, which do you recomend? iv'e heard Rohan is close to a recalll and playing as a defender so has scoring potential where as impey is never going to make more money but he plays every week and is a good emergency. The good thing about this is that it creates a DPP with taylor and shenton which ideally id keep for the rest of the year and it would be pretty good benchcover. the problem with this is that it doesnt allow me to get thee cash from taylor to help upgrade the rest of my team, with not many rookies on the horizon i'm worried i might not have enough cash to upgrade my whole team.

I have 17 trades and $356,000 in the bank

thanks guys

[GCSkiwi]

Polec to Watson and Impey to Shenton, then Upgrade Rooster next week, that forward line from F5 onwards is your biggest worry, not mids.

[pies124]

Polec to Watson and Impey to Shenton, then Upgrade Rooster next week, that forward line from F5 onwards is your biggest worry, not mids.

But that will only leave me with $256,000 plus rohan $160,000. so i have to upgrade to someone who is $416,000 or less when dalhaus and gray are the only two forwards who really appeal to me. who would you recomend for that price?

[GCSkiwi]

The way I'm looking at it you've got Langford you can downgrade, Cutler as a D7, cash from Langford could be used to upgreade Suckers and Langdon to true prems to complete the backline.
Rucks are done.
Mids if you upgrade Polec to Watson you'll only have Hallahan left to finish, Acres as a liability and Taylor again an acceptable M9

Forwards are the real trouble as you've got Lennon and Cameron playing who will both need a while to come up significantly in value, and Impey and Rohan on the bench who are both going nowhere fast.

You've got lots of trades but the money isn't really there. Polec to Watson gets you another cheap premo, otherwise Goddard is also a great pickup for 50k less. I've been tossing up between the two of them and still can't decide, at the moment going with Watson though. Impey to Shenton gives you a potentially better cow and a bit more money in the bank. Next week depending on how the lions go you could trade taylor to beams, netting more cash and another cow. This does eliminate the DPP set up with Shenton though. The other option would be to invest slightly to swap out Acres to beams, Acres is dead weight anyway, keeps DPP and gives you another cow. But then you would have to just bunker down and wait for Hallahan, Shenton, Cameron, Lennon and Beams to all come up in price and hopefully manage a 2 downgrade/3upgrade over a few weeks...

[ants]

impey to franklin and polec to goddard/watson or even k mitchell could be an option in your position! if t mitchell cant get in the the swans team then rohan has no chance so look to get rid of him soon!!!

[pies124]

alright so after playing around for a while i've done this
Langford to bews
Polec to shenton
this gives me $839,800
Then next week i can go
Shenton to FWD creating dpp via Rohan/ Impey and trade one of them to fyfe
And Langdon to Simpson

This finishes of my backs with suckling being 50-50
and i create a lot of cash with two super premos in back and mids
it also still alllows me to get dpp

What do you guys think?

[GCSkiwi]

alright so after playing around for a while i've done this
Langford to bews
Polec to shenton
this gives me $839,800
Then next week i can go
Shenton to FWD creating dpp via Rohan/ Impey and trade one of them to fyfe
And Langdon to Simpson

This finishes of my backs with suckling being 50-50
and i create a lot of cash with two super premos in back and mids
it also still alllows me to get dpp

What do you guys think?

Forwards are the real trouble

What would be the rough idea of how you see yourself upgrading forwards? Next week Impey to Fyfe and Langdon to Simpson will cost you in the vicinity of 600k, leaving you with 240k going forward, 2 rookie forwards playing, and not a lot of cash on the bench. That's ok if you're happy with the fact you'll be playing Lennon, Shenton and Cameron for a while... And also relying on them not getting dropped, if one of them is you're in strife money wise.