Team 1 or Team 2?

[Middo]

Team1:
Hunt, Boyd, Riewoldt, Gia, O'Keefe

Team 2:
Malceski, Gibbs, O'Keefe, Franklin, Pavlich

Thoughts??

[big_lynch82]

gees thats a tough one.
team 2 by a whisker. no real reason as both combos are good.
just prefer gibbs and buddy over gia and boyd.
can u help me with my thread middo?

[Middo]

dont like the dogs?
r u sure?
team 1 has riewoldt and o keefe and franklin isnt playing round 1
isnt much difference between gia and gibbs and hunt and malceski.
any other reasons?

[big_lynch82]

well no im not really sure lol
both teams hav upside but gia isnt that consistent either is buddy.
but i think buddy can pull out the big ones more frequently than gia.
i think gibbs will have a great year has had a good preseason. boyd needs to really rack the possies up to score well. more of a DT player.
roo over pav though. but still team  2 has the goods.....just!
the best possible combo out of those players IMO would be
Hunt, gibbs, Okeefe, franklin, roo/pav

[Middo]

ok well that isnt going to happen.
do u reckon have ROK instead of roo?
if i do that trade i cant get gibbs and buddy...would u have boyd and buddy or gibbs and gia?