Is it too much to have Pendles, Swan and Beams??

[SydneyRox]

My current mids are

Ablett, JPK, Beams, Pendles, Selwood, Polec, Tyson, Thomas, Dunstan, Lloyd

I have $275k in the bank and am ready to upgrade at least Dunstan this week, which gets me a straight swap to anyone.

Stevie was the plan, but now I am looking around. Keep going back to Swan... who I rate above others who are avail this week like Murphy, Gibson and Ebert.

But will 3 Pies in the mids be too much of a risk? I still cant work out if they are a top4 side or going to slide once the business end of the season starts...

[Capper]

3 pies is greedy, you will get fat!!

I think the Crows will start to hit theikr straps soon so maybe a crow like Thomo, Sloane, etc

[fertalong]

I honestly don't have very much faith in swanny atm. Doesn't look anywhere near his best so i wouldn't be bringing him in.
In saying that, I do have all 3 pies (started with swan and beams) and I don't think it's too much.

Maybe upgrade elsewhere and get the likes of rocky, fyfe, barlow, heppel, watson etc next week?

[SydneyRox]

i am planning on bringin in either rocky/sj next week ATM.

Swan has played well below his best, yet he still has an avg of 101. and last 5 avg of closer to 111

Both those figures deflated by the 79 last week!

Imagine if started playing well!!

Too late, I have sold myself!!

[pommyadam]

you're sidetrading a player that's hit over 135 in his last 2 games?
wish I had that luxury

personally, I'd put cash into Polec and Dunstan, turning them into Griffen/Scooter/Goddard

[j959]

I've got all 3 - but only had them altogether since last round ... too early to call atm ...  ;)

[T Dog]

Had them all from rd 1....swannie had me nervous for a few rds... ???

[SydneyRox]

you're sidetrading a player that's hit over 135 in his last 2 games?
wish I had that luxury

personally, I'd put cash into Polec and Dunstan, turning them into Griffen/Scooter/Goddard

?

Dunstan to Swan was the move I made

[fidou]

If you don't support Collingwood then having three Collingwood players will dishearten you when you watch the games. Its quite sole destroying cheering kicks from Beams, Pendles, Swan etc. The only Collingwood player I enjoyed watching was Heath Scotland.

[T Dog]

If you don't support Collingwood then having three Collingwood players will dishearten you when you watch the games. Its quite sole destroying cheering kicks from Beams, Pendles, Swan etc. The only Collingwood player I enjoyed watching was Heath Scotland.

::) sole destroying?......sad to hear blues supporters have sore feet......GoPies..Go Hard.. ;D

[Mr.Craig]

I've cheered Cloke, how do you think that felt?

[SydneyRox]

I've cheered Cloke, how do you think that felt?

well at least you have had to cheer a lot lately :P