Round 10 - Giants v Tigers - Saturday May 24th - Spotless Stadium

[Sweetness]

I have Cotchin who got -2 in the first 1/4
I also have Ward who has gone -3 for this 1/4.

[Mailman the 2nd]

Everyone blamed injury when I said GWS has gone backwards but now its even clearer than ever where they're at.

Have absolutely 0 defensive pressure now against a team who's best players are getting tagged out of the game.

They'll finish last again this season no doubt

[GoLions]

They'll finish last again this season no doubt

I dunno about that... ::)

[Mailman the 2nd]

They'll finish last again this season no doubt

I dunno about that... ::)

Possibly lol, but I think you're a better side than GWS atm even if you have a much worse off draw

[LaHug]

If you should be a Top 8 side, you would be. You guys are doing well today but no point pretending, you are where you at because you have been playing shower footy.

Thanks captain obvious. I'm not saying we deserve to be top 8. I'm saying that we're a good enough side to be top 8 and we haven't been playing like it. When we play our best footy (see today), we're definitely a finals side. Unfortunately, this is the first time we've played it all season.





Also, I'm obviously biased, but it looks like Richmond players are being held at every ball up.

[kilbluff1985]

HALF TIME: GWS v Richmond

A poor showing from the Giants. Jack Riewoldt has 7 now and is trying to beat Josh Kennedy's 11. The margin only looks like getting bigger.

GWS 1.6.12
Richmond 14.2.86

GWS:
5 Dylan Shiel 83
3 Stephen Coniglio 60
38 Stephen Gilham 53
17 Adam Treloar 52
10 Devon Smith 49
8 Callan Ward 42
46 Dylan Addison 35
31 Jacob Townsend 33
6 Lachlan Whitfield 27
7 Rhys Palmer 27
2 Curtly Hampton 25
35 Aidan Corr 23
9 Tom Scully 22
33 Will Hoskin-Elliott 21
20 Adam Tomlinson 18
26 Jonathan Giles 15
23 Heath Shaw 10
41 Shane Mumford 9
40 Adam Kennedy 8
12 Jonathon Patton 8
18 Jeremy Cameron 4
22 Joshua Kelly 0 (sub)

RICHMOND:
8 Jack Riewoldt 104
19 Matt Thomas 77
5 Brandon Ellis 66
4 Dustin Martin 57
29 Ty Vickery 53
3 Brett Deledio 49
16 Shaun Hampson 48
24 Ben Griffiths 45
25 Troy Chaplin 43
18 Alex Rance 42
30 Reece Conca 42
35 Ben Lennon 36
14 Bachar Houli 35
7 Matt Dea 35
10 Shane Edwards 32
6 Shaun Grigg 32
41 Nathan Foley 29
2 Dylan Grimes 26 (sub on)
36 Matt McDonough 25
9 Trent Cotchin 23
38 Steven Morris 20
23 Daniel Jackson 15 (sub off)

[AaronKirk]

Also, I'm obviously biased, but it looks like Richmond players are being held at every ball up.

Yep, thus Cotch's frustration which led to the fracas with Scully.

[GoLions]

They'll finish last again this season no doubt

I dunno about that... ::)

Possibly lol, but I think you're a better side than GWS atm even if you have a much worse off draw

Haha yeah, but we're gonna be without Rich for the rest of the season, Leuey for most of it (if not all), and who knows with Staker. Depends on how the kids play I guess whether we can get some more wins on the board after the bye or not. I hope we do.

[Jackross10]

C'mon Ward get a move on

[Bully]

Cotch needs to kick some goals to bring back some respectability to his score, better quarter but needs to lift.

[Vinny]

If you should be a Top 8 side, you would be. You guys are doing well today but no point pretending, you are where you at because you have been playing shower footy.

Thanks captain obvious. I'm not saying we deserve to be top 8. I'm saying that we're a good enough side to be top 8 and we haven't been playing like it. When we play our best footy (see today), we're definitely a finals side. Unfortunately, this is the first time we've played it all season.

You're welcome. There are quite a few teams that when they play their "best footy" they are a Top 8 side. But the Top 8 sides are there because they have been playing good footy consistently. So no I don't think Richmond should be there. None of your players have improved bar maybe a couple. The other sides have improved far more than you have.

[kilbluff1985]

Cameron might get a week off they just showed him punching someone in the gut

[Master Q]

What has gotten into JRoo!?

Also Mumford, if you could wake up, that'd be great.

[GoLions]

Of course I traded Hampson to Goldy this week in SC.


Of flowering course I did.

[Ricochet]

Cotchin wtf. At this point I'd be happy with 75+ from you