Greatest of all time

[Mailman the 2nd]

But if Mitchell was good enough he would play every game when his not injured and not continue to dominate games in the NEAFL

he has been carrying or working through an ankle injury all this year.

Ohhhhh so that's why he has played the first four games got dropped and played the last 3 in the NEAFL because he was injured.

Is it also why he played 8 NEAFL games in 2012 and played the first 8 games of last year in the NEAFL

I suppose in total those 19 NEAFL games since coming to the Swans is due to an ankle injury.

Chad on the other hand has never played a single game in the reserves and walked straight out team round 1 2013.

Because the Swans won a premiership in 2012?

We're just humoring you anyway. Chad is better at the moment, but if first years are comparable, Mitchell will be up there

[Noz]

Just to back up my statements

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2013-05-15/mitchell-fit-and-ready-

May15 last year - He debut 2 weeks later after back to back 50+ disp in the NEAFL

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/sydney-midfielder-tom-mitchell-finishes-with-64-disposals-and-269-supercoach-points-in-neafl/story-fni5f3gz-1226922849904

then yesterday.

"since Mitchell was forced out due to an ankle injury."

That's wonderful

In the future maybe Sydney should be aware that if a player is carrying an injury they don't let them play football. That way they can rest to ensure they get back the the starting 22 ASAP.

Since Sydney let Mitchell play its obvious that they don't see him as an important player.

[Toga]

Chad is love, Chad is life. :-*

[tbagrocks]

If your best player at a club isn't a midfielder than you have problems.

Wayne Carey? Gary Ablett Snr? Lance Franklin (08)? Warren Tredrea?

[Capper]

i am shocked, i thought you would have had


<3

Im not voting until JB Jnr is on the list

[SydneyRox]

LOL - Only cos Chad needed some stiff competition.

There is no contest with Parker he is in a league above Wingard.

[Capper]

LOL - Only cos Chad needed some stiff competition.

There is no contest with Parker he is in a league above Wingard.

you have changed. I thought i knew you

[Vinny]

Chris Judd & Gary Ablett.

That's all.

[GoLions]

Chris Judd & Gary Ablett.

That's all.

Being a young'un myself, those 2 plus Simon Black are probably the best I've seen.

[Vinny]

Chris Judd & Gary Ablett.

That's all.

Being a young'un myself, those 2 plus Simon Black are probably the best I've seen.

Yeah same here man.

Swanny
Ablett
Judd
NRoo
Pav
Black
Lloyd

I'm probably forgetting some more.

[Bill Manspeaker]

Robert Harvey, Michael Voss, James Hird. guns 8)

[Noz]

I figured i would just ask the question and everyone will agree with me.  :-\

[Toga]

Chad is love, Chad is life. :-*

[Ringo]

Little bit hard comparing eras.

Whilst Wingard appears to be going well he has a way to go reach some of the p[layers in the past or even GAJ, Pendles etc.

The next 5 years will decide whether he will be in the elite category.

[T Dog]

Tuck, Buckley, Carey, Riccuito, Brereton, Jacovich.....and the mighty Wiz... 8)