R10 Trades: Wingard a good option for F5?

[geoffmack]

R9:
20 trades left. $13k in kitty.

Thinking of these three trades this week:
Suckling/Aish/Webster to Gardiner/Acres/Jobe leaving over $200k.

Team would b:

Hibberd, Burgoyne, mcveigh, jaensch, enright, Langdon (Langford, Gardiner)

Gaz, pendles, jobe, beams, cotch, polec, dunstan, Taylor (Robertson, Acres)

Sandi, Sauce ( Derickx, Currie)

Parker, danger, zorko, dusty, JKH, Lloyd (impey, ambrose)

Leaves enough cash for next week:
Polec/dunstan/Robertson for selwood/Libba/rookie mid.

Thoughts??

[tor01doc]

I would keep Aish as he'll play and won't lose a lot. His potential for a big score will be handy this round with best 18 used.

Polec out this week instead is worth a thought.

With Webster playing, I would also consider holding him. I am not sure Gardiner is a ripper but I would canvass others for their more informed opinion about this one.

Def could be - Hibberd McVeigh Jaensch Enright Webster - Langford Burgoyne Suckling (I am assuming Langdon is in mids?)

Polec out for Acres

Mids - GAJ Pendles Beams Watson Cotchin Dunstan Langdon Aish - Taylor Robertson Acres

Rucks good

Then Impey could go and Taylor forward.

Fwd - Danger Parker Zorko Dusty JKH Lloyd  - Ambrose Taylor

That gives 19 playing like that.

And then work out how much money left and consider getting Swallow as a defender this week for ? Suckling - extra points and better longterm than Gardiner and his cash (maybe)

So you'd end up with a defence set - with Langdon D7 and Langford D8?

I find it hard to get my head around teams that already have changes though.

God luck.

[geoffmack]

Doc,

Team as of end R8:

DEF: Hibberd, Burgoyne, mcveigh, jaensch, enright, Suckling (Langford, Webster)

MID: Gaz, pendles, beams, cotch, polec, dunstan, Taylor, Aish (Robertson, Langdon)

RUCK: Sandi, Sauce ( Derickx, Currie)

FWD: Parker, danger, zorko, dusty, JKH, Lloyd (impey, ambrose)

Hope that helps!!

Thanks

[tor01doc]

I would get rid of Suckling and Polec - neither playing this week and neither a keeper and both done well making you money.

In with Acres - very good cash cow by the looks.

In with Swallow - completes your defence - also having Langdon in mids add flexibility - and he is the top averaging defender and has had his bye. No decent def cash cows looming is therefore not a problem anymore.

Forward line can sit until after this round as there is a dearth of decent round 8 bye forwards apart from the 2 (some would say 1) you already have. I wouldn't go for Boomer, Cloke, Wright, Jack Roo or any others like Hawkins. Prefer others next week.

Good luck.

[geoffmack]

Hmm wondering if I should keep Aish this week and dump Robertson not playing

Aish to go down, Robbo price stays the same.

Hmmm perhaps not, leave Robbo on pine, play taylor and dump the player who will most prob lose money.

[tor01doc]

Robertson to Acres.

[geoffmack]

Really, I got heaps of players this week, Aish BE 99 he aint gonna get that, he drops 10k, robbo price doesnt change, cant see the logic in dumping robbo this week over Aish

[Ringo]

Can now with Robbo not being named,  I was in the same boat was going to downgrade Aish but with Robbo not being named moved to get Acres. Aish will be gone next week. Cash drop will be minimal and may count on best 18 on field.

[geoffmack]

Can now with Robbo not being named,  I was in the same boat was going to downgrade Aish but with Robbo not being named moved to get Acres. Aish will be gone next week. Cash drop will be minimal and may count on best 18 on field.

I got 22 players with or without robbo. My opponent has 20.  Can win with an Aish trade me thinks!!

[tor01doc]

I owe you an apology for having the audacity to put you off Boomer!  :-[

[geoffmack]

I owe you an apology for having the audacity to put you off Boomer!  :-[

Who knew!!!
:P

[geoffmack]

R9 2156, Trades left 17, $299,600 in kitty.

DEF: Hibberd, Burgoyne, Mcveigh, Jaensch, Enright, Swallow (Langford, Gardiner)

MID: Gaz, Pendles, Beams, Cotch, Polec, Dunstan, Taylor, Langdon (Robertson, Acres)

RUCK: Sandi, Sauce (Derickx, Currie)

FWD: Parker, Danger, Zorko, Dusty, JKH, Lloyd (Impey, Ambrose)

Plan this week:
Polec/Dunstan/Robertson for Selwood/Libba/rookie mid - Hartung. Leaves $73k

Thoughts??

[Ringo]

Looks Good mate

Only other suggestion I would make is keep polec and look at JKH to Cameron/Lennon. Polec will make more cash this week with a 58 B/e. Selwood has a 92 B/e so will not rise as much either so can afford to play Polec,

Something to consider, 

[geoffmack]

Looks Good mate

Only other suggestion I would make is keep polec and look at JKH to Cameron/Lennon. Polec will make more cash this week with a 58 B/e. Selwood has a 92 B/e so will not rise as much either so can afford to play Polec,

Something to consider,

Bloody hell Ringo its something to definitely consider!! Going one step further doing: JKH/Dunstan/Robertson for Wingard/Libba/Rookie gives me approx $50k to spend next week. Lets say Selwood increases by 20k given he is playing the kangas and with polec low BE he could go up 20k as well basically means swap Polec for Selwood next week and possibly only lose 5 k. This I like.
Thanks man.
:)

[geoffmack]

Guys i face a dilemma. I have $299600 in the kitty. My team needs a FWD upgrade. My trade thoughts this week are JKH/Robbo/Dunstan to Wingard/Libba/Hartung JKH is the obvious choice to trade, and my initial thoughts are bring in Wingard DPP, BE 73 easily gettable.

I also am keen on Selwood BE 92 in the mids and was considering Polec BE 58 for him, next week could do it, both will increase roughly the same according to SC Gold. The problem is I will need a downgrade. I like Taylor in the mids as M8 as he has cash to make for a while and his JS is good.

Should I dump Sam Lloyd next week for Shenton DPP on the bubble neg BE to achieve this or is this a waste given Lloyd still has cash to make?

Or should I grab Selwood now for Polec and wait it out on the FWD line??