Team A or Team B?

Started by big_lynch82, March 15, 2010, 01:49:01 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Team A or Team B?

Team A
1 (25%)
Team B
3 (75%)

Total Members Voted: 3

big_lynch82

hey i need some help guys.

Team A
backs: enright, fisher, hodge, kennelly, hunt, greenwood, waters
mids: swan, NDS, selwood, gibbs, trengrove, martin
rucks: tippett and hille
frwds: Riewoldt, O'keefe, franklin, gray, ziebell, danger and mayne.
bank $187k

Team B
backs: drummond, enright, hodge, MacDonald, kennelly, hunt, waters
mids: ablett, swan, NDS, trengrove, martin and barlow
rucks: sandi and tippett
frwds: Riewoldt, O'keefe, franklin, gray, ziebell, danger and mayne.
bank: $23k

both teams hav the same bench so the bench is irrelavant.
so which team is better and why? i need sum thoughts.
anyone? thanks

c4v3m4n

Run a poll. Faster results, easier for other SuperCoaches.

But IMO, go with Team A. But use that cash to get Ablett and fix the backline up (having Hunt, Greenwood, Waters are too risky).

PS. I'd love to hear your thoughts on my team too. Thanks.
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,9354.msg58942.html#msg58942

reesbr

please tell us who is on your bench

big_lynch82

ok ill run a poll but i also want feedback.
thanks c4.
reesbr my bench is backs. davis and webberley.
mids: shuey and bastinac
frwds. hitchcock and rockliff
ruck: warnock and skipper

big_lynch82

also c4 if i get ablett who should i trade for him?
thanks for your help

Kazahkstan

I would say choose Team A and use the cash to fix the backline, but it would turn out similar to B.

I like the structure of B, including Macdonald down back. Forward line seems a little weak, imo.

big_lynch82

yea thanks kazakhstan.
the problem is i cant have it all!!
with team B who should i downgrade to strengthen the forwards?

Kazahkstan

Not really sure, to be honest.
Perhaps Tippett, as he seems inconsistent at times...

big_lynch82

any1 else have an opinion?

Middo

just returning the favour big lynch
i would go team B simply because it has ablett and sandi