Carlton H&A Discussion

[Vinny]

[Mat0369]

The best news I read there is Kane Lucas is out of contract. Brock is going to sign a one year deal. We have shot ourselves in the foot with Robbo/Jeffy. Both are FA and the fact we have said we don't want to keep them because of the drinking incident means teams will just wait it out for Carlton to delist them. Honestly, if we can't get a fair deal for them we should keep them but I don't see it happening.

[Vinny]

I won't be happy with getting nothing for Jeffy and Robinson either. Garlett seems extremely stiff to be let go based on that, I mean he was there and shouldn't have been but he didn't do anything wrong. Robinson lied at least which makes him being trading understandable.

Jaksch could be worth the punt IMO. He seems a solid player and can play at both ends. As long as we don't lose Pick 6, I am fine with it. 194 cm, 85 Kg. He went at Pick 12 intially but couldn't break into GWS forward line which makes sense.

''A tall forward who can also play in defence, Jaksch is extremely strong overhead and uses the ball well when in defence.''

McLean has been serviceable but I think he should retire and let the young guys come through. :x

Lucas, haha.

Did you hear about Waite's wife have a massive go at the club when he left. It was on Twitter or Instagram not sure which one. People were ripping into Jarrad so she started getting angry or something and said: Look at your list, it is crap. etc. but Jarrad deleted it all I think or something idk.

[Mat0369]

I think with the turnover of players we need Brock for at least one more year.

Duigan, Boots, Waite, McInnes, Temay, Robbo, Jeffy and Lucas

That is 8 guys.

If he is willing to play in the VFL most weeks he will provide some good coverage if guys like Bell, Judd, Carrots get injured, but if he isn't in our best midfield he doesn't get a game. He is to slow to play elsewhere. He had a great finish to the season in that Essendon game, so he does still have some left in the tank, but we can't carry to many players like him in the 1's each week.

Nah doesn't surprise me, at least she has his back and I can't blame her though if people are taking direct shots at Jarrad.  The club chose to offer him a 1 year deal when they knew it would take 2 to keep him. The look at your list it's crap lines probably don't go over too well, but when you get pissed you make some of those comments. It isn't necessarily false either, the list has gone backwards in the last 3 years and compared to North who are looking to finish top 4 it is right. We still have an elite core of players, it is just the guys around them need to lift.

[Vinny]

Jarrad Waite officially gone to North. :( Hopefully we get a 3rd rounder for him.



Looks shower.


Liam Jones agreed to for Pick 43.
Jason Tutt agreed to for Pick 62.

[Vinny]

Happy Mat? :P

[elephants]

Looks shower.

Lol :p

[Vinny]

Looks shower.

Lol :p

Let me bitter. :P

[Nige]

Looks shower.

Lol :p

Let me bitter. :P

Now in English.  :P

[Vinny]

Looks shower.

Lol :p

Let me be bitter. :P

Now in English.  :P

:-X :P

[Mat0369]

No, too depressed

[Bill Manspeaker]

No, too depressed

don't be too depressed mate. I highly doubt Waite would be part of your next premiership tilt anyway, if you can get something for him may as well ship him off

[Ricochet]

Patrick Keane ‏@AFL_PKeane  3m3 minutes ago
AFL has advised Carlton that due to contract amount offer to J Waite & player's age, there will be no compensation for his move to NMelb.


Sorry lads

[kilbluff1985]

Mick might lose the plot

[Mailman the 2nd]

To be fair, this is what FA should be for with no compensation for any of the clubs.