Carlton H&A Discussion

[Big Mac]

I cannot flowering believe we said Robinson and Garlett are on the trade table and then said they'd be delisted if a deal was made...far out

Atleast Garlett won't be delisted  :P What do you think Carlton will take for him?

[Master Q]

Cooney!?!?  :o

[Vinny]

Wtf hahaha. He is 29.

It's rumoured to be:

Adam Cooney, Liam Jones + N45 FOR N28

[Mat0369]

Our trade period just keeps getting weirder.

[Vinny]

The extent of Carlton's interest in Cooney since the package deal was proposed was not clear on Tuesday night.
The mooted trade could yet be scuttled, given the Blues are considering using pick 28 in a trade for former No. 12 draft pick Kristian Jaksch, who wants to be traded to Carlton from Greater Western Sydney.

The Blues have been looking at a three-club trade in which Carlton would receive Jaksch, Hawthorns pick 19 and the Giants' pick 21, giving up picks 7 and 28 to GWS.
In that scenario, uncontracted Giants onballer Jono O'Rouke would be traded to the Hawks.

7 & 28 for Jaksch? F off.

[roo boys!]

Hawks win in that one, again. 19 for O'Rourke is pretty good i reckon

[Master Q]

Trade Pick 7 and I'm moving clubs  :P

[Mat0369]

Offer up a 4th round pick for Jones and tell the Dogs take it or leave it. Forget about Jaksch, Cooney, Tutt and everyone else and just draft our own players.

[Mat0369]

If our off-season keeps trending the way it has been going, lock us in for a top 5 pick next year.

[Vinny]

Garlett + Pick 83 for Pick 61 and 79. :'(

[_wato]

You boys not happy with Pick 7 (Durdin) for Jaksch (Pick 12), Whiley and Pick 19?

Think it's reasonably fair.. Although you seem to not be very happy about it.

[Vinny]

I really wanted to keep Pick 7 man. It doesn't look that terrible but I don't see the point. Why would we want to do that?

Jaksch hasn't shown heaps other than being a high draft pick and Durdin is meant to be a gun. I know nothing about Whiley to be honest.

The only way I would be satisfied with the trade is if Pick 19 magically landed Reece McKenzie.

[nrich102]

@CarltonFC: National Recruiting Manager Shane Rogers says Adam Cooney won

[Mat0369]

Whiley is a tagger that took some big scalps. Carlton don't need another tagger. Pick 7 is not necessarily Durdin either. Carlton need to take as many high quality kids in this draft as possible. This would be like us trading Watson, Cachia and a 2nd round pick for the Suns pick after ours.

[_wato]

Big bodied midfielder though, 187cm and 90kg so has the right frame, and could potentially be transformed into a ball winning midfielder.

If you were to keep 7 you would get Durdin, there's no doubts about that, he is what you're lacking (over anything else).